Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Posts

German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#1

German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Sergio

Hello everybody, I recently purchased a "german" spindle gouge by Hamlet. It is a 3/4 inch (bevel) it is very shallow and has the sides that end in a nice taper. I believe this is the main difference with the so called "continental" spindle gouges in which the sides are of the same thickness all around.

So today I tried it mainly to make shallow and long coves. It work very well and leaves a surface extremely smooth. I found that the best way to use is different from the usual spindle gouge: instead of rotating the gouge on its axis (the tool tend to become very unstable when rotated) I follow the curve of the cutting edge thus moving the handle left or right on the same axis and keeping it in contact wit the wood.

Being completely new to this tool I wonder if anybody can give me its experience with this gouge, whose shape to me makes a lot of sense.

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#2

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

robo hippy

I think the biggest difference is that this open fluted style gouge works better when used up on its side/flutes rolled over, rather than flutes more pointed up. Great for long smooth flowing lines. I use a Thompson Fluteless gouge for the same type of cuts. It is half round bar stock, with the same ) nose profile. Rounded, but not square or pointed.

robo hippy

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#3

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Craig Daymon

I think you will find that this is mainly used as a form of roughing gouge. I believe Rude Olsolnik used one, or a very similar gouge. (There is one sold under his name.) I would not put it in the same category as a Thompson fluteless gouge, though you can certainly do SOME of the same thing with either. I've cut coves with a 2.5" roughing gouge, which I also found easier to use for planing cuts (instead of a skew).

I have a wider one. The only issue with it is that it is not real easy to sharpen. (Too big for the jigs.)

I also use it to shear scrape inside bowls. I do this with the flute facing downwards and shear scraping with bottom bevel edge. My index finger is placed down the back of the flute and the handle runs along the underside if my forearm. The bottom edge of the flute securely rests on the toolrest. This is a GENTLE cut with a sharp tool. This is NOT used to remove large quantities of wood or perform dramatic reshaping. It is a finishing cut.

-Craig

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#4

Here is the Rude gouge I named.......

JamieDonaldson

...as a "spindle skew" and it is a wicked tool to master. I don't know if this is the profile you are describing, but he made the originals from planer blades, and they are also difficult to sharpen on a grinder with that long bevel. Rude used the sides of the grinder wheels, then did a lot of hand honing on the blade edges to keep them sharp.

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#5

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Sergio

I'm a little confused about the use of the word flute. I thought that the flute was the concavity grounded on the top of the original steel bar and that can be round or parabolic etc. the German gouge has a perfectly round tip and sides of uniform thickness accept at the side ends and I found, may be I'm using a wrong technique, that just rolling it a little it cut a nice cove with a very gentle curve. Much better in my opinion than a regular gouge. Also it does leave a very smooth surface. In my opinion it cut a little like a skew. Of course, having a much large cutting edge that a usual spindle gouge it can be a little unstable if rolled close to 90 degrees.

Here is an image of the gouge I'm talking about.


Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Keith Tompkins

HI Sergio, The tool you picture (which I have also) is a version of the continental spindle gouge. These were in wide use before the round spindle gouges came into favor. This tool will do anything a round spindle gouge will do...beads and coves, planning cuts, end-grain, etc. The trick is to use the tool on its side when cutting coves,(90 degrees to the tool rest) rolling the tool as the cut progresses until the flute is straight up. The tool should be aiming at the centerline of the turning, otherwise it will tend to skate back in the cut. V-grooves can be cut the same way. Cutting beads, just rest the tool on the bevel, raise the handle until it begins to cut, then roll the tool either right or left to complete the bead. I'll try to post a photo.

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#7

Re: Here is the Rude gouge I named....... *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Don't think that is the Rude gouge I'm thinking of. If I remember who who sells it, I'll try to post a link, if they have a pic on the page. As I recall, the smallest size was about 1.5", if not 2". Flatter than a traditional roughing gouge with a rounded nose and bevel similar to the Packard gouge I link to below.

I posted a link to the Packard page of the gouge I have. It gives a very clear pic of the gouge and a close up of the bevel on the end.

The Rude gouge I'm thinking of appears to be made by Henry Taylor. Here's a link showing it. Very similar to the Packard. Definitely a longer handle. The link is from Google images results, so it's super long.

https://www.google.com/search?q=rude+osolnik+roughing+gouge&sa=X&tbm=isch&imgil=Y0gh9KTKQCGnVM%253A%253Bhttps%253A%252F%252Fencrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com%252Fimages%253Fq%253Dtbn%253AANd9GcThAQj-TnogFTq-nhew9s901nncc1b1GKbBmJ3bdL0-ejEMpzNm%253B170%253B170%253BNUI3nHJdy_K6cM%253Bhttp%25253A%25252F%25252Fwww.1066tools.co.uk%25252Ftools%25252FHenry-Taylor-Turning-Tools.html&source=iu&usg=__2_3xEbCqIUUMYFXUIums33s1UtI%3D&ei=zx8IU978FunV2QXV_4CoAg&ved=0CGkQ9QEwCw&biw=1899&bih=954#facrc=_&imgdii=_&imgrc=_Ov0YJwqpBExsM%253A%3BCUfWwgN4k85OMM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.toolnut.co.uk%252Fimages%252Fproducts%252F973.jpg%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.toolnut.co.uk%252Fproducts%252Fturning_tools%252Fhenry_taylor_turning_tools_-_Gouges%252FShallow_Gouge_-_45mm.html%3B250%3B350


Packard German Spindle Gouge

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Keith Tompkins

HI Sergio, The tool you picture (which I have also) is a version of the continental spindle gouge. These were in wide use before the round spindle gouges came into favor. This tool will do anything a round spindle gouge will do...beads and coves, planning cuts, end-grain, etc. The trick is to use the tool on its side when cutting coves,(90 degrees to the tool rest) rolling the tool as the cut progresses until the flute is straight up. The tool should be aiming at the centerline of the turning, otherwise it will tend to skate back in the cut. V-grooves can be cut the same way. Cutting beads, just rest the tool on the bevel, raise the handle until it begins to cut, then roll the tool either right or left to complete the bead. First photo shows tool position to begin a cove cut, second image shows how tool is rolled to finish cove. V cuts, beads and end grain cuts are started as first image shows. Hope this helps.

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#9

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Sergio

Thank Keith, you use it as a regular spindle gouge but this is when in my ends, the tool starts to become a little unstable, but I guess is a matter of experience.

I just tried to follow the cove downhill keeping the tool slightly rolled up, flute up, and flattening it while moving the handle left when going wright or right when going left.

In any case, what is your opinion on this type of gouge, why you think it was abandoned in favor of the round stock. I have an old fried that uses only high carbon continental/german gouge for is spindle (repair a reproduction of antique american furniture) with marvelous results but I guess he is a little shy and I've never seen him turning.

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

keith tompkins

Sergio, I've used this type of tool for several years before the round gouges became popular. I thin the round tool is easier to produce; the continental tool has to be forged to its shape, while the round tool is made from round stock. The continental tool will do anything the round tool will do, it's just a matter of practice. In fact, the continental tool will make a planning cut more easily than the round tool, and its narrow profile allow steeper v-cuts than a round tool. Starting on the centerline of the turning is important, otherwise, the tool will tend to skate backwards.

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#11

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

steve worcester

Looking at the picture, it looks like a forged roughing gouge (now referred to as a spindle roughing gouge) but with a different grind

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

#12

Re: German spindle gauge, any ecperience?

Sergio

Thank you Keith.

For Steve : no, the flute is much shallower than a spindle roughing gouge. The grind is also different. It can be used for roughing but and gouge or a bedan can do it very well.