Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?
robo hippy
Well, they out perform the standard wheels in every single category you can think of except they cost more, but you get so much more.
CBN (cubic boric nitride) is almost as hard as diamonds, and is made specifically for grinding steel. It cuts steel better than diamond, which works better on carbide, ceramics, and other similar materials.
They come spin and bubble balanced, so if you are running them on your grinder, and they are vibrating, it is the grinder shaft, and not the wheels. They run true. No balancing set up needed.
They don't load up. The CBN cuts smooth and even, and the steel powder falls off. You do get fuzzy tools if you lay one down by your grinder because the grinding action seems to make them magnetic. A simple tap on any steel and that will demagnetize them. I sweep the steel filings into the shavings. Because they never load up, you never need to clean them up. Loading up is part of what causes extra heat. The CBN is also better at dispersing heat as it cuts. Sharpening bench chisels is simple, and using a light touch you will not blue your edges. Because you don't have to clean them, there is never any aluminum oxide dust to contend with (very bad to inhale).
Because they are solid steel, they never change shape, so you never have to adjust grinder rests to compensate.
Because they are solid steel, there is no risk of them ever blowing up.
Because they are solid steel, there is never any need to true them up again.
Mine get sludge on them from turning wet wood. If they get bad, I take them into the kitchen sink and use some Ajax and a plastic bristle brush. Good as new.
Most mount with a metal bushing. These are generally ordered with the wheel to fit your specific grinder. If you have the plastic bushings on your standard wheels, get rid of them, they are junk.
The price seems extreme, but if you consider that one CBN wheel will out last by far the same $ amount of any other wheel out there, they are a bargain. Mine are over 2 years old. I would have worn out maybe 2 standard wheels in that time.
The only real considerations are which grits and which width. You can get away with one, and I would suggest the 180. I have to have both the 180, and the 80. They do cut a lot faster than comparable grits in standard wheels. For widths, there are 1 1/2 inch wide, and 1 inch wide. After having 1 inch wide wheels for years, I tried the D Way wheels that are 1 1/2 inch wide. With them, I have never run off the edge of the wheel. With 1 inch wide wheels, even when I used to use gouge jigs, this happened from time to time, leaving a fair sized divot in the wings of my gouges. Not any more. I did switch back to the 1 inch wheel to test out a Cutter Master, and prefer the wider wheels (other wide wheel is Optigrind). The narrower wheels are available through Packard (Woodcut wheel) and Craft Supplies (Optigrind wheel that is 1 inch wide). Some have a side grind option. I can't see it as being necessary, but if I was going for that, I would use the Optigrind, which has 5/8 inch of side grind grit. Cuttermaster and D Way have 1/4 inch. D Way does have a wheel with a 1/4 round profile on the edge. Purpose is to that you can push straight through rather than rotate the tools. I can see this as being handy for hollowing tips (check out John's sharpening video clip where he demos this, but is using standard wheels, or on the D Way site). Some grinders have short shafts, and I think D Way is the only one to make a special adapter for the wheel to acomodate the short shaft.
They can so some of the softer carbon steel, brass, copper, etc, but I do not recommend it. Mostly because they will load up. If you take a heavy scraper and sharpen it after you get some load up on the wheel, it is very effective in cleaning them up as good as new.
I would worry a bit on small grinder motors. I think 1/2 hp will work but these wheels are heavy (5 to almost 8 pounds, depending on the wheel). I would hand spin the wheels to get them started before hitting the on switch. Maybe not necessary, but just to be sure..... A 3/4 hp motor should have no problem, but not all 3/4 hp motors are equal. I have to put some effort into it to slow down my Baldor grinder. Little or no effort to stall the one blue no name grinder from Woodcraft. Again, with them, I would hand start. These wheels because of the weight will spin for a long time after you turn off the motor, so you may want to brake them by riding the heel of your gouge or scraper on the wheel to bring it to a quicker stop.
robo hippy