Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Posts

What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#1

What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

jake Niedling

I admit that I don't have a CBN wheel or even used a tool sharpen from one. What I do know is my slow speed 8" grinder with Aluminum oxide wheels do a pretty decent job of sharpening my tools. Usually the biggest problem is me not sharpening as often as I should.

So with out any brand names to be mention, how do I justify purchasing one? Or what are the basic advantages. What are some of the disadvantages besides cost (can you reshape a tool)?

RoboHippy - just said in a recent post "it is not if you going to buy one, it is just when". That is what got me thinking about this topic.

I think just a good topic for everyone.

Thanks,

Jake

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#2

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

John Lucas

Jake I use a 180 grit wheel but lets assume that you have 80 grit and you buy an 80 grit CBN. The CBN produces very little heat. Don't know how that works but it does.

The wheel is perfectly balanced so it's really easy lay a tool up there with or without a jig and get a good grind.

The wheel never changes size. I haven't moved my V arm in a month or more. Of course I do sharpen some tools on the older stone simply because the jig is already set.

The CBN wheel cuts faster than the same grit stone. This does take a learning curve. You have to be very light when sharpening but since the wheel is so well balanced it's easy to do.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#3

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

robo hippy

Well, they out perform the standard wheels in every single category you can think of except they cost more, but you get so much more.

CBN (cubic boric nitride) is almost as hard as diamonds, and is made specifically for grinding steel. It cuts steel better than diamond, which works better on carbide, ceramics, and other similar materials.

They come spin and bubble balanced, so if you are running them on your grinder, and they are vibrating, it is the grinder shaft, and not the wheels. They run true. No balancing set up needed.

They don't load up. The CBN cuts smooth and even, and the steel powder falls off. You do get fuzzy tools if you lay one down by your grinder because the grinding action seems to make them magnetic. A simple tap on any steel and that will demagnetize them. I sweep the steel filings into the shavings. Because they never load up, you never need to clean them up. Loading up is part of what causes extra heat. The CBN is also better at dispersing heat as it cuts. Sharpening bench chisels is simple, and using a light touch you will not blue your edges. Because you don't have to clean them, there is never any aluminum oxide dust to contend with (very bad to inhale).

Because they are solid steel, they never change shape, so you never have to adjust grinder rests to compensate.

Because they are solid steel, there is no risk of them ever blowing up.

Because they are solid steel, there is never any need to true them up again.

Mine get sludge on them from turning wet wood. If they get bad, I take them into the kitchen sink and use some Ajax and a plastic bristle brush. Good as new.

Most mount with a metal bushing. These are generally ordered with the wheel to fit your specific grinder. If you have the plastic bushings on your standard wheels, get rid of them, they are junk.

The price seems extreme, but if you consider that one CBN wheel will out last by far the same $ amount of any other wheel out there, they are a bargain. Mine are over 2 years old. I would have worn out maybe 2 standard wheels in that time.

The only real considerations are which grits and which width. You can get away with one, and I would suggest the 180. I have to have both the 180, and the 80. They do cut a lot faster than comparable grits in standard wheels. For widths, there are 1 1/2 inch wide, and 1 inch wide. After having 1 inch wide wheels for years, I tried the D Way wheels that are 1 1/2 inch wide. With them, I have never run off the edge of the wheel. With 1 inch wide wheels, even when I used to use gouge jigs, this happened from time to time, leaving a fair sized divot in the wings of my gouges. Not any more. I did switch back to the 1 inch wheel to test out a Cutter Master, and prefer the wider wheels (other wide wheel is Optigrind). The narrower wheels are available through Packard (Woodcut wheel) and Craft Supplies (Optigrind wheel that is 1 inch wide). Some have a side grind option. I can't see it as being necessary, but if I was going for that, I would use the Optigrind, which has 5/8 inch of side grind grit. Cuttermaster and D Way have 1/4 inch. D Way does have a wheel with a 1/4 round profile on the edge. Purpose is to that you can push straight through rather than rotate the tools. I can see this as being handy for hollowing tips (check out John's sharpening video clip where he demos this, but is using standard wheels, or on the D Way site). Some grinders have short shafts, and I think D Way is the only one to make a special adapter for the wheel to acomodate the short shaft.

They can so some of the softer carbon steel, brass, copper, etc, but I do not recommend it. Mostly because they will load up. If you take a heavy scraper and sharpen it after you get some load up on the wheel, it is very effective in cleaning them up as good as new.

I would worry a bit on small grinder motors. I think 1/2 hp will work but these wheels are heavy (5 to almost 8 pounds, depending on the wheel). I would hand spin the wheels to get them started before hitting the on switch. Maybe not necessary, but just to be sure..... A 3/4 hp motor should have no problem, but not all 3/4 hp motors are equal. I have to put some effort into it to slow down my Baldor grinder. Little or no effort to stall the one blue no name grinder from Woodcraft. Again, with them, I would hand start. These wheels because of the weight will spin for a long time after you turn off the motor, so you may want to brake them by riding the heel of your gouge or scraper on the wheel to bring it to a quicker stop.

robo hippy

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ric Taylor

I have a CBN and I'm really happy with it.

The only downside that I know of is the manufacturers all recommend using only high speed steel tools on these wheels. They say that using the older tools with other steels or metals will damage the CBN wheel in a manner that cannot be repaired.

I keep my old wheel on the other side of the grinder to use with my older tools.

Ric

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#5

Jake  I'll have it at the next meeting


Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#6

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ralph Lindberg

Ric

I don't believe that Dave (D-Way) says only HSS, he does say only hardened steels (HCS, etc).

No low-carbon, soft-iron, brass, etc.

But he does note you should be able to clean these off the wheel by going back with a hard steel.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#7

more on CBN life

Ralph Lindberg

While Robo certainly does more sharpening then most hobbyists, even he doesn't do as much as Dave (D-Way)

Dave shapes and sharpens the tools he sells on his CBN wheel, he has certainly shaped and sharpened thousands of tools and can still use his original wheels.

For most of us, a CBN wheel is a once in a life-time purchase.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#8

Ok - but what about the tool Sharpness?

jake Niedling

I appreciate all the details about the CBN wheels and fully understand that. Alot of good points were made.

So if I had two tools sharpen and one was from a good aluminum oxide wheel grinder set-up and one on a CBN wheel, could I tell the difference when I used them to turn. I guess what I am aking is what value is it to me relative to turning?

My logic thinks that it would be hard to tell the difference in my cuts, the finish of the wood, how often I need to sharpen, etc.

Thanks for the feedback and the discussion.

Jake

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#9

Re: Ok - but what about the tool Sharpness?

Jeff Smith

Jake - you didn't say whether you use a jig to sharpen or not - my experience with CBN wheels is that the 180 leaves a very clean surface and the smoothness of the wheel (from the precision balancing) means the tool doesn't bounce at all when in contact with the wheel. I spend much less time at the wheel when I do sharpen and get a better edge than I ever did from a matrix wheels. And the fact that there's no adjusting the jig to compensate for the wheel diameter as it wears is really nice. Everytime you sharpen you get the same grind.

Will it make a sharper edge? Will that edge last longer? Who knows - in my opinion those things are controlled by the angles you grind and how you use your tool much more than the nature of the tool you use to sharpen.

Can you use them to reshape - that's what the 80 grit excels at. Either the 80 or the 180 remove steel at a faster rate than matrix wheels. The 180 is probably more 'general purpose' of the two.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#10

Re: Ok - but what about the tool Sharpness?

John Lucas

Jake I can't say because I purchased a 180 grit wheel and only have 100 grit grinding stones. It would be interesting to compare 80 grits but I doubt the difference would be noticeable unless the fact that the CBN stays true it might cut cleaner.

What I can say is the 180 cuts as fast if not more so than my 100 grit white wheel and leaves a finish that is definitely better for cleaner cuts.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#11

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Philip F Duffy

Jake, I was holding back for a long time but now that I have a CBN I whole-heartily endorse getting one. Yes, it is expensive but all my tools now last 3 to 5 times longer, I believe, before needing another quick and easy go at the wheel. Save time and money over the long run. You will not be disappointed. Philip

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#12

Re: Ok - but what about the tool Sharpness?

Darryl

It might be my imagination but the edge on my bowl gouges does seem to be much smoother. So much so that I do find myself returning to the 180 wheel more frequently not because the tools are dull but because they do cut better. As I explained to David Elsworth ( where I got the wheel) the edge is so much better than before that I'm not as satisfied with what in the past I would have started out with. He thought I was complaining and offered to have me return the wheel. I told him in I would not return it that they would have to peel it from my cold dead hands.

The edge is smoother as mentioned above and is so much beyond my old edges that when I get to where the old edge would have just started I now return to freshen up the new edge. Cindy Drozda had an piece a bit ago that influenced me in the purchase. The only question I have is whether the edge lasts as long since it starts out so much smoother and sharper. I have a hunch it is approaching the old question about whether a honed edges last as long as one fresh off the grinder.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#13

Re: Ok - but what about the tool Sharpness?

robo hippy

Cindy Drozda did a blog spot on how CBN wheels do seem to sharpen the powder metal tools (V 10 like Thompson, Glaser, and I thing Stuart Batty tools) better than standard wheels. I do always start the finish cut with a fresh edge, no matter which steel I am using. The CBN wheels, especially after they get broken in, leave a very polished edge, much more so than standard wheels. From my experience, the steel seems to have more to do with how long your edge holds up than the wheel. Does the 60 grit wheel serrated edge cut better than the Tormek ground and honed edge? I haven't tried a 60 grit wheel, but couldn't notice any cutting difference between CBN sharpened and Tormek sharpened.

robo hippy

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#14

Re: Ok - but what about the tool Sharpness?

Ralph Lindberg

A couple additional points:

Recall the article in the AAW journal a few years back (by Lacer and ?? Metalurgy guy, name escapes me). Using micro-photography they showed the wood cut difference between a finally finished cutting edge and a rough cutting edge. This showed clearly that a good clean edge produces a better finish.

On the flip side I can recall Mike Mahoney saying (talking about CBN wheels) that he didn't like the fine edge as he though the serrated edge from the regular wheel cut better.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#15

Jesper, Denmark

Re: It re-opens the question......

Jesper, Denmark

......which John Lucas started a discussion about some time ago:

The Role of the burr on gouges........

My personal take is that in a push cut, the burr is quickly gone from the tip of the gouge, but the burr actually does the cutting on the wings. The tool angle of the tip is shearing/peeling at an acute angle, which is producing the final cut on the surface. The wings are roughing off material ahead of the tip.

In using a gouge for shear scraping, the burr is doing the work.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#16

Well I think I will stick to my Standard Wheel

jake Niedling

I do really appreciate the exchange on this CBN wheel topic. It was more for getting some information out here for us non-users of the CBN wheel.

Now I don't turn professionally, but usually turn every week-end and some evenings.

I have a perfectly great working aluminum oxide type wheel, which I keep balanced and clean. Keeping the adjustment for the changing diameter is a non issue with a simple jig. So I get a very good grind and a very good cut from the tool. Use the Wolerine jig with vair-grind and Elsworth jig.

Maybe some day when my current wheel wears out, I will get a CBN wheel.

Thanks,

Jake

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#17

Ric Taylor

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ric Taylor

My research on the various manufacturers of CBN wheels indicates that what materials can be used on a CBN wheel depends in great part on how the CBN is bonded to the wheel. There are at least three different bonding processes: resin bond, vitrified bond and metal bond. We as woodturners and customers generally don't know which manufacturing process is used, and therefore CBN wheels from different manufacturers may allow their use on different metals. I have noted that many (but not all) of the statements regarding possible damage to the wheels and what they may be used for have disappeared from various websites.

The Optigrind, D-Way and Raptor/Craft Supplies wheels are all manufactured in Austria. I wonder if they are all manufactured at the same facility, and if they might all be identical except for the shape of the wheels.

These are statements from various manufacturers, suppliers and users:

Currently on the D-Way website: The CBN wheels are specifically designed to grind HSS. You can grind all magnetic HARDENED HSS, and that includes powered metal and carbon steel. As a general rule if you can cut it with a file it is not a hardened material. Some have had questions about shaping drill rod. In the annealed state I would not recommend it, but once you heat treat it you are go to go. For the annealed steel, I would recommend using a belt sander with 60 or 80 grit belt.

Previously on the D-Way website: You should only grind high speed steel on a CBN wheel. Do not use it for mild steel or carbide.

On the Craft Supplies website: WARNING: Grinding non-heat treated steel such as carbon steel, aluminum and other soft metals will cause irreparable damage to the CBN wheel.

On the Packard Woodworks website: CBN Wheels are used for grinding hardened steels and should not be used on carbide.

On the Cuttermasters website: CBN grinding wheels are good for grinding high speed steel. For grinding carbide please look at our Diamond Grinding Wheels.

On the Optigrind website: CBN is also known by its trade name as Borazon and are suitable for the grinding of woodworking tools which are usually made from high-speed steel (HSS).

On the Georgiagrindingwheel.com website: A diamond wheel is specifically used for carbides, plastics and other synthetic materials. It will not grind steel well at all. CBN wheels should only be used on steels.

Bob Bergstrom: Just no carbide or cold roll steel.

John Keeton: CBN is designed for HSS, and the diamond is not.

The bottom line for me is that I am going to protect my investment in my CBN wheel. Nothing but high-speed steel will touch my wheel, as it is possible that it might be damaged by other metals.

Ric

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#18

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Dale Bonertz

Ric,

Are you sure they are all made in Austria. I know the optigrind and raptor are but I believe the D-way is made in China. Not that it really matters but just wanted to make sure there were no misunderstandings. Just so no one gets upset I own both the optigrind and the D-way and they are both performing well.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#19

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ralph Lindberg

Dale

I think you are correct that D-Way is made in China. I think I've heard Dave say that.

I also think the wheel from Craft Supplies is also made in China, but by a different source then D-Way.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#20

Ric Taylor

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ric Taylor

All of the information mentioned in my previous post comes from the sources mentioned, plus a few others. There are no opinions or guesses. For example, from the Craft Supplies website: "MADE IN AUSTRIA". Etc., etc., etc. ....... for everything in my post.

Additional information: the CBN wheels sold by JoHannes Michelsen are also made in Austria, by Optigrind.

Ric

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#21

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ralph Lindberg

Ric

Where did you learn Dave gets his wheels from Austria? It's not on his web-site.

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#22

Ric Taylor

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Ric Taylor

Ralph,

Everything I mentioned and a lot more that I didn't mention is easily found doing simple research and searches.

Ric

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#23

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

railbender

well i became interested in the cbn wheels and as reading on this site i noticed there was some

disagreement as to where the wheels were made. so i just ask Dave and the man at cuttermasters,

can't recall his name. D-way wheels are made in China. Cuttermasters are made in Taiwan.

Can't figure out why we can't make these in good ole USA? I know we could do it better !

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#24

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

robo hippy

Well, I may have to check, but Cuttermaster is Canadian, and made up there. The Woodcut wheel may come from Taiwan. Why can't they be made in the USA? Well, I got some of the matrix style (3/16 of the grinding matrix bonded onto a 1 inch thick aluminum hub) 8 or more years ago. Cost then was $300. We are getting so expensive that we can't afford ourselves.

robo hippy

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

#25

Jesper, Denmark

Re: What is the CBN Wheel Advantage?

Jesper, Denmark

On principle, I don't give a Tinker's Damn where products are made, as long as quality, price and support are in order.

I bought the CBN from the manufacturer in Austria, Holzer Hartstofftechnik and dealt directly with the owner, Dietmar Holzer. It is really nice to deal with companies small enough to so that they care about you and your business.

That is also a contributary reason why it Says Thompson on my turning tools.