Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

speaking of glue...

Posts

speaking of glue...

#1

speaking of glue...

GaryG in MD

I just had a virtually brand-new, small bottle (used only once) of Gorilla Glue gel on me. What's that all about?

I use 5-minute epoxy for gluing pen tubes, but I've been getting some gaps, and I thought that maybe Gorilla Glue would be a better choice because it expands as it dries. But now, I'm not sure I want to buy any more.

So, my questions:

If you use Gorilla Glue,

1) Are your experiences good or bad?

2) Is it appropriate for gluing in pen tubes?

...GG

Re: speaking of glue...

#2

Re: speaking of glue...

John Lucas

Gorilla glue does not expand. It turns into a foam when it expands. not good. I have never gotten more than half bottle of use out of Polyeurethane glues. I haven't found anything that they will do that either wood glue or epoxy won't do better. Epoxy is a gap filler and can be cleaned up easily with alcohol. Gorilla glue will get on your hands and won't come off no matter what.

Re: speaking of glue...

#3

Re: speaking of glue...

Stuart Johnson

At one time I turned over 200 pens using Gorilla Glue. Scuff the tubes with course sandpaper and plugged the ends with bee's wax. Squeeze in some glue and spread it around with a piece of wire then slide in the tube. The only problem is being sure the tube isn't forced out when the glue expands.

I never used a complete bottle before it hardened so if you use it buy the smallest you can find.

Re: speaking of glue...

#4

Re: speaking of glue...

ron bauer

In my opinion the only thing Gorilla is good for is fixing chair rails where the foaming/expanding seems to hold well. Like every one else advises, buy the smallest bottle you can because any moisture will cause it to catalyze in the bottle.

Re: speaking of glue...

#5

If you think Gorilla is a good gap filler *LINK*

Dick Coers

......read the link.


woodgears

Re: speaking of glue...

#6

Re: If you think Gorilla is a good gap filler

GaryG in MD

That's an outstanding article.

Very well researched and well written.

Thanks, Dick. ...GG

Re: speaking of glue...

#7

Well that answers that question!

GaryG in MD

Thanks, all, for your direct comments.

Stuart, your success aside, I don't think I'll be buying any more of that stuff.

I'll be sticking with wood glue and epoxy for their appropriate applications. ...GG

Re: speaking of glue...

#8

Re: speaking of glue...

robo hippy

Since it is all bubbles when it expands, there is no strength to it. Two stories: One was a friend who made espresso tampers. Fine for holding some of the exotic woods, but he air mailed some to Japan. At altitude, the bubbles expanded and every one delaminated. I think it was stainless or Lignum glued onto a base. The other story was from Franklin glue, makers of Tite Bond. I asked them about the urethane glues and was told this by the 'old' master/guy in the shop: We laminated up base ball bat blanks using urethane and Titebond glues. When used, the urethane delaminated every time. The Titebond held up. So, I don't use it at all.

robo hippy

Re: speaking of glue...

#9

thanks for the stories, Reed.

GaryG in MD

Just confirms my thinking. ...GG

Re: speaking of glue...

#10

Re: thanks for the stories, Reed.

John Lucas

On the plus side. I use to use it to make cutting boards. Of course the joints were flawless and very tight. I used that glue because it was supposed to be water tight. I am still using one of them 15 years later. So I guess it does have it's place but you have to use it properly.

Re: speaking of glue...

#11

his other strength test *LINK*

John Lucas

His test was more sophisticated than mine. I did the tests about 10 years ago so having to rely on my memory for the results. I did a butt joint and tested them by sliding a 5lb weight out a lever attached to the wood that was glued together. I used epoxy, yellow glue, CA glue, and polyeurethane glue.

I used 3/4" maple blocks glued together with a butt joint. Each was clamped with as close to equal pressure as I could. I did 3 samples of each glue. What I remember was Epoxy was by far the strongest ( I did let it dry overnight and it was summer in Tennessee so I think it cured properly) Yellow glue next. CA was very weak and Polyeurethane barely allowed me to even move the weight before it broke.

My test wasn't about glue strength necessarily I was simply trying to find a glue that would give me a decent bond for end grain to end grain gluing that you sometimes end up doing for some segmented joints to achieve a certain look. I do try to avoid end grain to end grain joinery but sometimes for the sake of "art" you have to make exceptions.

Anyway it was great reading his articles and watching the videos. You can never learn to much about glue and wood movement.


http://woodgears.ca/joint_strength/glue.html

Re: speaking of glue...

#12

Betty Scarpino

Re: thanks for the stories, Reed.

Betty Scarpino

I'm still using a cutting board I made 30 years ago. I used yellow glue in the (perfect) joints.

Re: speaking of glue...

#13

good info; thanks!


Re: speaking of glue...

#14

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: thanks for the stories, Reed.

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Gee Betty, with such perfect skills in the flat world why did you and John switch to woodturning? :D

Dennis

Re: speaking of glue...

#15

I would say I hate glue-but

John Lucas

I still do segmented turning so I guess that's not true. I go to a lot of trouble to glue up flat wood just so i can make it round again. Sometimes i have to ask my self, why don't you just start with round wood in the first place. :)

Re: speaking of glue...

#16

Betty Scarpino

Re: Turning requires no measuring

Betty Scarpino

Good question, why if my skills were so perfect, did I switch to turning? I may have had good flat-work skills, but that didn't mean I enjoyed the struggle to create perfect glue joints (chest of drawers with dovetails and mortise-tenon joints--yikes!). With turning, if something doesn't work out, we all know it's simply another opportunity for a change in design.

Resting on my perfect-joint laurels in Indianapolis. ; .)