Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Bowl and a Question

Posts

Bowl and a Question

#1

Bowl and a Question

Bob Verne


This is a small bowl I recently turned (5-1/2" dia., 2-1/4" H). As yet it is unfinished. I'm pretty satisfied with the proportions. I couldn't get myself to add any surface embellishments. I liked the spalting too much.

C&C welcome.


The question is: What kind of wood is it? I cut the tree down from the woods in front of house, but the tree had no leaves or bark left. I had labeled the piece Sweet Gum, but, after turning and sanding it, I am doubtful. It doesn't look at all like any sweet gum I have turned in the past. Any ideas?

Bob

Re: Bowl and a Question

#2

Re: Bowl and a Question

john Veerkamp

Looks like spalted silver maple to me.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#3

Re: Bowl and a Question

Chuck Engstrom

Hi Bob -- nice piece! Looks to me like some kind of elm, maybe hackberry.

Best -- Chuck

Re: Bowl and a Question

#4

Re: Bowl and a Question

Jorge

That w looking grain makes me think it is one of the elms.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#5

Rob Wallace

Re: Bowl and a Question

Rob Wallace

Bob:

WHERE are you located?

It would be best if we could see a close up of the end grain. Given the views shown, I can't decide if it is elm, hackberry, or maple. It has some attributes of all of them.

Nice bowl. I agree with your decision - not every bowl needs surface embellishment or other "gussying-up" if the form and wood figure are attractive on their own.

Rob Wallace

Re: Bowl and a Question

#6

Bob Moffett

Re: Bowl and a Question

Bob Moffett

It looks like maple to me. You did a really nice job of turning this piece. I love the shape. I agree with you. That piece does not need any texturing. The wood is to pretty on it's own. Texturing would be a distraction.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#7

Re: Bowl and a Question

John Jordan

Elm, you can tell by the zig-zag grain.

John

Re: Bowl and a Question

#8

Re: Bowl and a Question

Bob Verne

Thanks for the suggestions. I am in eastern North Carolina (Chapel Hill). Here is an end grain picture.


The mention of elm makes sense. Although there is a lot of sweet gum near where the tree was cut, there is a fair amount of elm in the general area, too.

Regarding embellishments, my pendulum has swung from doing a lot of surface embellishments to doing almost none. Currently, I am more focused on trying to create purer forms and elegant shapes now. There is a happy medium I'm sure.

Bob

Re: Bowl and a Question

#9

Re: Bowl and a Question

Fred Holder

It looks like elm to me also. With spalting like that I would recommend an oil finish, such as Mike Mahoney's walnut oil finish. After it dries it will buff very well and the oil will really bring out the grain and spalting.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#10

Re: Bowl and a Question

GaryG in MD

Bob,

That's a classic Stocksdale shape.

They're a little out of vogue now in some circles, but I still love them.

Mother Nature did all the decorating needed.

Great job, Gary

Re: Bowl and a Question

#11

Re: Bowl and a Question

Bob Verne

Thanks, Gary.

Bob

Re: Bowl and a Question

#12

Oil can really darken or muddy spalted wood

Dick Coers

so be careful and oil a similar cutoff if you can. I prefer a spray acrylic.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#13

Re: Bowl and a Question

Chip in Plano

That end grain convinces me it is elm.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl and a Question

Keith Tompkins

HI Bob, It's elm. If unsure just write "wood" :)

Re: Bowl and a Question

#15

Re: Bowl and a Question

John Scheideman

It doesn't look like elm to me. I say it is spalted sycamore.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl and a Question *LINK*

Keith Tompkins

John, Sycamore has flecks that are highly visible when quartersawn..see link. Elm, and related species has a zig-zag pattern in the grain that is unmistakable. Another clue was the tree was leafless and barkless...a victim of Dutch elm disease.


http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=sycamore+wood+pictures&id=AC38B743D94CB49A768E704D2BE1140EF8F85C02&FORM=IQFRBA

Re: Bowl and a Question

#17

Rob Wallace

Elm

Rob Wallace

It can't be sycamore - the numerous parenchymal rays on the end grain are absent.

Without question it is an elm (Ulmus) - which species would need some additional sleuthing which can't easily be done over the Internet! We can't automatically assume it is a victim of Dutch Elm Disease without further information.

Rob Wallace

Re: Bowl and a Question

#18

Don Leydens

Re: Bowl and a Question

Don Leydens

That's some of the nicest spalting I've seen Bob. Love how dark the streaks are. Yup, no embellishments necessary. Well done!

Don

Re: Bowl and a Question

#19

Re: Bowl and a Question

Randy gleckler

Very nice Bowl Bob, that has fantastic shape on it. Really like it.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#20

Re: Bowl and a Question

carl civitella

Spalted yellow birch.

Re: Bowl and a Question

#21

Re: Bowl and a Question

Lan Brady

Wow, I hope you have a yard full of that stuff!!!!

Great piece, Lan

Re: Bowl and a Question

#22

Re: Bowl and a Question

Bob Verne

Only the bottom few feet or so was spalted (a pleasant surprise), yielding about 6 useful small bowl blanks. The rest was too split/rotten/punky, etc. But the price sure was right.

Thanks to you and the others for the nice compliments. The encouragement and affirmation is appreciated.

Bob

Re: Bowl and a Question

#23

Re: Bowl and a Question

John Scheideman

Keith,

That's what I thought I was seeing in the two bottom photos. But I am probably wrong.....darn, thought I solved this one!!

John

Re: Bowl and a Question

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl and a Question

Keith Tompkins

John, I split a lot of firewood....elm becomes easy to identify...it's murder to split!!!

Re: Bowl and a Question

#25

Re: Bowl and a Question

bill Crommett

Keith: Elm is murder to spit, but is even worse to use as lumber.. I remember the time about a hundred years or so ago when I bought some elm to make a chicken coop, because it was cheap. I was up at night working with a Colman lantern pulling out bent nails to replace them because the baby chicks were coming in the morning.