Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

Posts

WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#1

WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

klowwn

Came home to find a couple wood chunks on my doorstep. No idea who left it and no idea the type of wood. Both my wife and I smelled the wood and it's pretty bland without much odor.

Any thoughts on the type of wood?

Thanks

Ricc Havens

rv.havens AT gmail.com


Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#2

couple more pics 

klowwn

Here is a couple pics of a spindle blank I cut. A thought was sweet cherry but not sure


Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#3

Re: couple more pics

Ken

Looks like locust to me. Probably black locust.

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#4

Re: couple more pics

George Guadiane

If the wood seems kind of light weight, I might go with elm.

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#5

Re: couple more pics

Dale Bonertz

Sure looks like elm to me. Both bark and grain. Not all elm will have that distinctive aroma until you turn it and even then it doesn't always smell real bad. Of course I turn a lot of it and may be getting used to it but my wife and kids will always ask me if I have been turning that smelly wood again. :)

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#6

Steven Antonucci

Agree with elm


Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: couple more pics

Keith Tompkins

Look closely at the grain pattern...a zig-zag pattern indicates it may be elm.

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#8

Elm


Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#9

Rob Wallace

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

Rob Wallace

Almost certainly elm. If the end grain photo were a bit more in focus/sharper and slightly higher in magnification, it could be confirmed definitely.

Black Locust (Robinia) is a dense, ring-porous wood with abundant tyloses... likely not present in this sample.

The wavy ray figure in the tangential section is a dead give-away for elm.

If fresh, the cut wood might have an "unusual' smell, sometimes likened to an aged, uncleaned urinal - or a well-used horse stable.

In my experience, elm is a very stable wood with minimal checking upon drying. I like the way it finishes, and for me it sells very well. A pretty wood.

BTW -I'm pretty sure most everyone has RECOGNIZED this wood, but not formally ID'ed it......a subtle, but important difference.

Rob Wallace

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#10

Elm


Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#11

Re: couple more pics

Steve Kirincich

I think black locust has a coarser, textured bark.

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#12

Re: couple more pics

Ricc Havens

It is heavy not lightweught.

Ricc

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#13

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

Ricc Havens

Rob, the wood waa very green and fresh cut. Even when i was cutting the blanks on my bandsaw the wood was extremely wet. But, not smell like urine. No odor at all.

Ricc

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#14

Aage Rendalen

No doubt: elm

Aage Rendalen

I have turned quite a bit of both black locust and elm. Both are great turning woods, but his is elm. Black locust is great for natural edge bowls, since the bark stays on so well, and these bowls sell very well. Elm bark also stays on well, but I mostly turn regular bowls out of elm. As somebody else mentioned, the zig-zag pattern or elm grain is unmistakable. It looks as if the grain was laid down by sowing maching.

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#15

THANKS EVERYONE!!!


Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

#16

Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

I vote for black locust -- I just cut and turned some black locust last week and this piece is a dead ringer. Deeply furrowed bark and that characteristic green tint.