Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Now I remember why . . .

Posts

Now I remember why . . .

#1

Now I remember why . . .

charlie belden

I don't turn green wood.






This is a christmas ornament sized piece I WAS turing out of green Bay Laurel root burl.

Did you know that unlike when you hollow dry wood, with green wood, you can't tell by the sound when you're turning close to TOO THIN!

Will do some experimenting with applying dye from the inside on this little warped and deformed all to hell piece - of a piece.

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#2

Re: Now I remember why . . .

Carole Valentine

Yes , you CAN tell...you just have to listen closely.

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#3

Re: Now I remember why . . .

Sam Scalzo

Charle

That is why I only turn DRY WOOD

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#4

Leo Cuellar

Re: Now I remember why . . .

Leo Cuellar

I sympathize completely, Charlie. I've been having some fun(?) with several large rounds of Black Locust a friend brought over. It has given me an opportunity to play with the DNA treatment though. I'm just going to have to try thicker rough outs next time. Lots of significant warping near any interesting grain.

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#5

Steven Antonucci

Turn with a lamp behind it

steven antonucci

If I was turning wet and thin, I might add a lamp nearby and use light transmission as my caliper. Just make sure to stop befor you get to the color white...

Steve

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#6

Re: Now I remember why . . .

charlie belden

With a 25 percent hearing loss, in part thanks to a Blue Cheer concert in a small auditorium I worked at 40+ years ago, and 10+ years of using power tools without hearing protection, detecting small changes in sound is no longer possible for me. Hearing aids are also out of the question, given by ability to lose lit flashlights in dark rooms ; ).

Add to the mix that this is root burl, with grain running in unpredictable directions, some soft, some much harder, this may have just been The Perfect Storm phenomenon. The little vase I turned earlier from this same wood behaved better and didn't deform near as much as it dried (though it does have a noticable lean to it and did go oval a bit).

I guess I should just set aside a couple of days to play with this stuff and get to know it better.. Maybe the secret is to do small pieces ; )


Re: Now I remember why . . .

#7

Re: Turn with a lamp behind it

Doc Green

Have you tried it? There may be a few problems.

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#8

Steven Antonucci

All of the time

steven antonucci

It's very similar to what Hannes Michelsen does when he makes a hat. Light transmits through the wood, and it usually is pretty easy to get something uniform if you can see inside it. My hats are somewhere around 50/1000ths, which is less than a 1/16".

I've been kicking around an idea to have a bright light on the tip of a hollowing tool and hollowing by exterior color in the dark... real, blind turning!

Steve

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#9

Re: All of the time

John Jordan

Probably 80-90% of N. American hardwoods can be turned green without issues. A few woods are quite volatile, and roots, crotches etc. may move quite a bit, but its all quite predictable once you are familiar with that particular wood.

Implying that green wood is a problem because one piece moves some is faulty logic, Charlie. But you've heard that from me in person. :D

I've made a pretty good, and long career turning green wood without issues.

Here's some waiting to be carved. :)

John

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#10

Re: All of the time

joe Dickason

John--what kind of wall thickness?

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#11

A warm fuzzy.......:)


Re: Now I remember why . . .

#12

Re: All of the time

charlie belden

John:

It may be merely a matter of experience with a particular wood - and the scale of the piece. For the tall narrow little vase I turned from this same green bay laurel, I used your 1/4" straight and goose neck pair in your 12" handle (should've got the 16" handle instead - look for a future order, along with another 1/4" sleeve, one's now permanently stuck on my 1/4" goose neck).

I think if I were hollowing a larger green piece, through a larger opening (the little christmas ornament was being hollowed through a half in hole) things might have gone better,

I tend to jump around a lot - different ideas, different woods, different tools, different methods - sort of a Liberal Arts approach rather thana BS in Chem Eng.. There are disappointments with this approach, but also interesting discoveries. Perhaps someday I may settle down and become a mature turner - but I doubt it.

Out of curiosity - how long had you been turning before you found the types of pieces you so obviiously enjoy doing - and evolving?

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: Now I remember why . . .

Brad Vietje

Not about to start a war or sprinkle salt on anyone's wounds, but I would MUCH rather play with green wood than dry, although for shiny items like ornaments I actually do both, roughing green, then saving finishing for the air-dried wood.

As John says, once you learn how much each wood moves, you plan ahead, and most of the wood is removed when its green, and easy, and cool, and dust-free, and infinitely more pleasant, tools stay sharp longer... and, well, you get it (or perhaps not, but that's how I see it). It is, after all, wood, so it does move, and that's part of what wood is. If we were looking for greater precision, then why turn wood at all? Other materials, like plastics, metals or ceramics will hold their shape better, and are easier to work with great precision.

I figure if someone likes turning dry wood, they'll absolutely love turning green wood. For those that say they don't like turning green wood, It's not the turning that bothers them, its the movement, the raised grain, or getting it to dry without cracks, etc...

Anyhow, that's some pretty cool looking wood Charlie has there, and I'd be happy to turn it if it's too disagreeable.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#14

Harry Robinette

Re: All of the time

harry robinette

Steve A.

Lighting the end of the tool works wonders been using it sense Frank Sudal started it back in the early 2000 or late 1900 when he was doing the tall thin vases and piercing them ( 24" tall 1/16"walls ).

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#15

Blue Cheer

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Well, I love turning green wood. For me it is the best wood to turn.

But your mention of Blue Cheer really took me back. It was one of my all time favorite bands. It even made me go to youtube to get me a dose of Summertime Blues.

I do relate to your hearing loss, I played in bands for 15 years, and always seemed to have the biggest and loudest amp right next to me.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#16

Katherine Kowalski

I must admit to being envious...

Katherine Kowalski

... I LOVE turning green burls. I delight in the crinklies they make, the undulations on the surface. Wonderful stuff.

However, if you're looking to make bits and pieces that fit together, (like a box, or Christmas ornament w/ finial, et al.), dry out your wood first, then turn it.

Katherine

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#17

Steven Antonucci

I'd love to see a picture 


Re: Now I remember why . . .

#18

Re: All of the time

bernie feinerman

One of the hollowing tool makers sells a light kit to mount at the end of its boring bar. It uses a 12 volt lamp driven from a battery charger - they recommend using a higher voltage to get more light at the expense of shorter bulb life.

http://www.onegoodturn.ca/pages/HollowingTools.html describes the tools and includes the light kit.

I have not used it and will probably have a go at making my own version.

Bernie

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#19

Re: Blue Cheer

charlie belden

It's not the amps that get you - it's the speakers. In Blue Cheers case, their Marshal (sp?) amps, FOUR per musician, amplified the signal. But it was the huge. two plus foot diameter Voice Of The Theater speaker cones and their large metal "horns" on top that moved the air a LOT of air.

At their benefit concert in a small high school theater in the Filmore, you had to keep your mouth open in order to equalize pressure on your ear drums. If you didn't things got PAINFUL.

Alas, Blue Cheer, and so many other bands, went for/go for sound VOLUME, ignoring sound QUALITY.

To really understand the difference you have to have listened to the Oveture of 1812, with 12 pound canons as the base percussion section, played through McIntosh ampS driving a high end, tuned speakers system that included Voice Of The Theaters and tweters that'd go up to 40Khz, in a sound room that has plush carpeting, heavy velvet floor to ceiling drapes and acoustic tiled ceiling.

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#20

Re: All of the time

Lan Brady

John,

Great group of carving blanks.

But, I am more impressed that you listen to Hayseed Dixie.

LOL, I have 2 of their albums.

Lan

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#21

Steven Antonucci

Might have to make one too!


Re: Now I remember why . . .

#22

Re: Blue Cheer

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Charlie,

Wow, I had no idea that the sound came of of speakers. Thanks for clearing that up for me. :)

Dave

Re: Now I remember why . . .

#23

Re: All of the time

charlie belden

Seems to me that a 12V light would generate heat, very close to the wood.

What about using a laser? The laser used for the MiniMonster runs on two AA batteries.