French polishing questions
steven antonucci
Has anyone here tried a French polish with thinned lacquer instead of shellac?
I am debating giving is a whirl, and I could use some tips. The goal is to build a high gloss finish.
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
French polishing questions
steven antonucci
Has anyone here tried a French polish with thinned lacquer instead of shellac?
I am debating giving is a whirl, and I could use some tips. The goal is to build a high gloss finish.
Steve
Re: French polishing questions
Greg Haugen
Steven,
Are you talking about a "friction" polish? Like a turner's finish. French Polish is different. For bottle corkers and boxes of non-exotic hardwoods (even though the current batch has wipe on poly on the corkers) I use a version of Ray Key's finish method. Thinned lacquer sanding sealer, apply 2-4 coats and buff it with either white diamond or tripoli and it has a high level of sheen. If it's a box, the final step is a wax paste buff on the lathe. The whole process is approx. 4-5 minutes. Shellac is flexible enough that it can smooth out more than a lacquer can from the heat of the friction so I do go to a wheel for the final level of sheen on corkers. Something could also be done possibly on the lathe with a product like EEE, from the pen turners, for the final sheen. Some shellacs are not de-waxed so having that wax left in it helps in the friction finishes as well.
More like a guitar finish
steven antonucci
Not thinking about friction polish, which is usually wax and shellac. I am thinking about using Lacquer and a pad to build a high gloss finish. Mineral oil is also used to keep things fluid. If you've ever seen a piano or guitar with that super high gloss look, that's what I am after...
S
Re: More like a guitar finish
Keith Tompkins
Hey Steve, A New York company, Constantine's, used to sell a padding lacquer for doing exactly what you propose to do. Someone may still produce a similar product. I don't think you will have any luck with the mineral oil and lacquer; one layer of lacquer finish melds into the previous layer...the mineral oil will prevent that; any trace of oil or silicone will produce "fish eyes" in the finish. In the past, I've done much lacquer work; to achieve the finish you describe is a tedious process of spraying, sanding, spraying and sanding. Each coat must be sanded dead flat, with no signs of runs or any shiny spots before the next coat is applied. My business partner at the time had a technique of spraying the final coat with an extremely thinned-down mix...mostly thinner with minimal solids. The result was like glass. The finish on a musical instrument has been buffed and polished to a mirror-like gloss...an art in itself.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: More like a guitar finish
Stuart Johnson
There was a segmented turner that posted here several years ago that finished his stuff to a very high glass like shine. Maybe some else will remember his last name but I'm pretty sure the first is Mark. I know he posted his finishing steps a couple times and it involved a lot of fine wet hand sanding. If someone comes up with his name check the archives and I think you'll come up with what you want.
Mark Kauder
Ok, let's see here.
Greg Haugen
Instead of lacquer and mineral oil. Wasn't it a thinning agent and mineral oil to smooth what was already applied??
As someone has already mentioned, I'd contact Grizzly and look into what they suggest. There are products out there that are lacquer based but be cautious and if in doubt check MSDS. Some are still shellac based even though they say their not. Having "Lac" in the name doesn't always mean lacquer. Kind of like some of the "Tung Oil Finish" that are available that has no tung oil in it.
Most of the turners (3) I think of with glass sheen finishes; two spray lacquer and buff it or hand polish with auto compounds and the third uses wipe on poly. So no help there.
Re: Mark Kauder - thanks *LINK*
Stuart Johnson
One of his posts regarding his finish. The link at the bottom is to his web site.
Here is the finishing process:
1) Sand to at least 320, but I prefer 400-600 grit. Blow off all the dust, and inspect carefully for any surface defects that require your attention (sanding marks, etc).
2) Next, I follow a procedure that Russ recommends. Put on a thin layer of lacquer (brush or cloth or spray), let it set a minute, and then wipe it off so that none is shown on the surface - use a rag dampened with lacquer thinner if it is sticky. This process eliminates most surface oils that would interfere with finishing. It also works as a primer for the next layers to grab onto.
3) Next, Apply three medium to heavy coats of clear lacquer finish - seperating each coat by 10-30 minutes. Allow to dry at least 24 hours.
4) Wet sand (Water) with 320 or 400 grit. At this point you are trying to level out the surface. Some places you will sand through the lacquer to the wood, that is OK, but once you hit wood, stop sanding in that place.
5) Repeat steps 3 and 4 over and over again until your surface is absolutely smooth. After the first sanding, you can probalby move to 800 Grit sandpaper.
6) Once the surface is smooth with 800 grit, apply 1-2 light coats of lacquer, and sand once with 1500 grit.
7) Apply 1-2 light coats of lacquer, and sand with 2000 grit (and if you want, higher grits of Micromesh)
When you are done sanding, apply Finess-it to a soft rag, and rub out the lacquer is small circular motions all over the surface.
9) Buff with a clean cloth, and then apply wax and buff.
Note when sanding - Where possible, sand with the sandpaper in the palm of you hand, making large circular motions. DO NOT sand with the sandpaper on one finger rubbing is small circles - you will create a divot that will be easily seen - and hard to repair.
Tight grained woods will require fewer layers of Lacquer to become smooth. Open Grained wood like Walnut and Oak, will take many, many coats.
Remember, since you are sanding it all smooth, it is possible to spot spray troubled areas, w/o spraying the whole piece. It is also possible to, for instance, spray the top half, and then later spray the bottom. The sanding will blend them in together.
As Russ says, Lacquer is the easiest finish to use, but is the least forgiving in surface preparation - it shows every defect.
Hope this helps.
Mark
Mark Kauder
Re: Another Lacquer Source...
Bill Jacksonville, NC
Use Deft brushing lacquer a lot since available locally. Only thin it to use as a sanding sealer using lacquer thinner and separate container. Can also buy Deft spray can sanding sealer if do not want to mix your own. Hard to get much of a build with sanding sealer. Again might depend upon wood species too. Once apply one or two coats of sanding sealer use regular Deft.
I only wait 30 minutes between coats of sanding sealer manufacture recommends an hour between coats. If sand at all between coats of sanding sealer, use 320 grit.
Deft topcoat. Do not always sand between additional top coats but do follow manufacturers drying time 2 hour recommendation. If sanding required will use 220 grit to remove runs or brush bristles, if only dust or uneven coat use 320 grit. May use 3 or 6 coats of Deft depending upon wood.
Whether brushing or wiping on with paper towel important to keep surface wet and do not go back over missed spots. Wait for next coat to fix dry spots. Read need 21 days for Deft to cure, but go back after a week or two sanding and polishing with micromesh and water on the lathe. You do not always need to use sanding sealer. Have completed pens and other small projects with and without sanding sealer in one day including micromesh procedure.
JMHO, micromesh sheets will give you a depth of sheen whether lacquer fully cures or not as long as surface has no defects. Normally omit 1,500 & 1,800 grits, start with 2,400 through 12,000 grits.
Having spray equipment speeds up use of lacquer on turnings if shop has no dust, temperature & humidity cooperate, wood is at EMC.
Re: French polishing questions
john lucas
Steve I haven't read anyone else's responses yet. I'm in between getting things set up to shoot of group photo of 1500 people in the shape of 2015. Anyway, I put on 2 or 3 thin coats of lacquer thinned about 50/50. usually with the lathe off or very slow. Then I turn the speed up and buff it with a cotton cloth. If this isn't glossy enough or if I find streaks I put just a dot or two of lacquer on the cloth and then buff again. The small amount of lacquer sort of helps dissolve the streaks and clean things up.
This can be pretty high gloss on woods with no pores but I leave it kind of satin looking for woods like Oak.
Re: Mark Kauder - thanks
john lucas
It was Mark Kauder but as you can see his process is more like finishing a guitar than french polish. As I understand it and this is really brief. Guitar type finish is a build up of lacquer or could be other materials. Then this finish itself is sanded and polished until it's perfect.
French polish as I understand it is a built up finish but is then polished with the finish itself. I know that really a simplified version of the two and there are probably many variations inbetween. If I'm wrong someone straighten me out.
Stewart MacDonald *LINK*
Don Evans
Steve:
Go to the real experts, they have all the material including on their site all the information on how to do everything you want to do.
This link takes you directly to their article on "french polishing"
http://www.stewmac.com/tsarchive/ts0110.html
Re: Stewart MacDonald
Don Evans
Messed up on the link in message above, the shellac link was just FYI.
Go to Finishing on left for Nitrocellulose lacquer finishes...
Here is link to one of them, read reviews below in this link.
What you are looking at is thin spray coat, sanding it smooth, then another coat, then sanding etc, etc, etc.
Nothing different about doing it on wood and doing it on a car except on wood the lacquer used is more important because of movement of the material so stick with one of the luthier recommending lacquers.
Personally, I go with polyacrylic, hard and tuff finish.
Don
much appreciate it...awesome articles!