Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

new bowls

Posts

new bowls

#1

new bowls

john lucas

The first is my first segmented bowl in about 15 years. I used to make a lot of these so when I was setting up my new Makita sliding miter saw I decided to make another one. this allowed me to play with my old gluing techniques and refresh my memory on the steps and problems.

this one is the Honey Locust bowl that I posted a photo of the bottom the other day. I wanted to do a bowl with no feet to show the difference in lift that a foot would make.



Here is a comparison of how a foot affects the feeling of lift of bowls.


Re: new bowls

#2

Re: new bowls

Randy Gleckler

Love the comparisons there. I've been messing with the foot shape/size etc lately as well seeing how it effects how I see my own bowls. Nice work.

Re: new bowls

#3

Peter Martin

Re: new bowls

Peter

Lovely bowls, super comparison.

Peter

Re: new bowls

#4

Re: new bowls

oneplowboy

Not bad for a rookie.lol

Re: new bowls

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: new bowls

Keith Tompkins

Nice work John...as usual. I like the comparison between the bowls; foot, no foot, etc. I really like the looks of the three-footed bowl. A good post to study.

Re: new bowls

#6

It's the steroids 


Re: new bowls

#7

Re: new bowls

Mike Foydel

In the group of 4, I like the one on the left the best and the one second from right second best.

Re: new bowls

#8

Re: new bowls

Vince

Nice John

Re: new bowls

#9

Me too

John Lucas

If you look really close it's not just the feet on these. The shape of the bowl is better. The 3rd one from the left starts out great but then I let it flatten out so the curve changes as it goes under. This makes it look heavy. The last one on the right does the same thing. I thought I had the curve perfect on the lathe but if you look close there are 2 curves. One from the top down about 2/3rds of the way and then another one starts and goes across the bottom. That's a hard thing to see on the lathe. I've thought about mounting a camera over the lathe so you can pull it down and look at the bowl in the normal position. I think that makes it easier to see the curves.

Re: new bowls

#10

Aage Rendalen

About the foot: Depends on where your eye is

Aage Rendalen

I agree that a foot provides visual lift to a bowl, but in my opinion, whether to include one or not depends a lot on where your eye is going to be relative to the bowl. A bowl or vessel that'll spend its life on a shelf, at eye level, probably looks better without a foot, unless it's worthy of attention in and of itself (see your first bowl with carved feet). But bowls that will be placed on a low shelf or used on a table or counter can use a foot to avoid having it visually embed itself in the surface it sits on. That, or you need an outside curve that rises fairly steeply.

I like your segmented bowl, but shy away from all that work.

Re: new bowls

#11

Re: About the foot: Depends on where your eye is

john lucas

Lets not forget about functional bowls. The foot has to work with the function. Little pointy carved feet like on this bowl are easy to break and the bowl is kind of tippy. It's not the greatest thing as a functional bowl but then I don't make functional bowls out of wood with nice figure.

Re: new bowls

#12

Aage Rendalen

Re: About the foot: Depends on where your eye is

Aage Rendalen

Still, look at the bowl mills--all functional, no foot.

Re: new bowls

#13

Excellent Comparison Shot-Thanks.


Re: new bowls

#14

Katherine Kowalski

Re: new bowls

Katherine Kowalski

John,

Though I am not a segmenter, I have learnt a lot from my neighbor Curt Theobald about the construction of such bowls. From this knowledge, I would advise that you stagger your segments next time so that it will result in a stronger construction. (Think brick-work).

I like the combination of woods you've chosen -- they accent each other well.

Katherine