Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Posts

Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#1

Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

charlie belden

This is a follow on to my previous post on the use of jigs and grinders.

The Tried & True method of sharpening a finger nail grind is to use a grinding wheel and a jig - or two. The benefit of the method is said to produce a consistent grind and minimizes the amount of metal removed from the tool for each sharpening.

However, the Tried & True method has several DISADVANTAGES.

1. You can't SEE what's happening to the bevel - because the tool you're sharping is in the way. Yes, you can look in from the side - but with a finger nail grind - you'd have to keep moving your view from left to right - as you're sharpening. Not very practical in practice. Grind a little, check - and grind some more seems inefficient - one of the reasons for using jigs in the first place.

2. Because setting up a finger nail grind jig involves four variables

- the amount of the tool extending out in front of the jig

- the angle of the jig's "leg"

- the distance from the front of the grinding wheel to the "heel" of the horizontal support for the jig

- the grinding wheel's diameter

the jig is typically only set up ONCE - for ONE bevel angle.

The obvious compromise of the grinder and jigs sharpening method is the single bevel angle. But in actual use, One Size DOES NOT Fit All. With bowl gouges for example, wide shallow sloped bowls require a different bevel angle than a tall narrow bowl - or box. With grinder and jigs it's typically Go With The Middle Of The Road - and get a grind that works adequately for both types of bowls, but not as well as a pair of bowl gouge each ground for a specific function.

This assumes of course that you can't afford two, three or more jigs, each set up at different bevel angles.

BUT - other, better ways, are now available - for sharpening. Two come to mind - the JoolTool and the WorkSharp. With both tools, the tool being sharpened is held UNDER the sharpening wheel, bevel UP - where you can see it - because the sharpening material is on the underside of the abbrassive device. With the JoolTool, the abbrassive is on what looks like a NInja throwing star - basically a wheel - with abbrassive on the "spokes". The WorkSharp uses a slotted disk with slotted abbrassive stick ons. Neither requires using any jig or jigs.

search for JoolTool and WorkSharp on YouTube to see these systems and how to use them.

Once you HAVE the grind you want, you merely blacken the bevel you want to sharpen with a black Sharpe pen, bring it up to the abbrassive from below - as you watch where it is through the spinning abbrassive device - then remove all the BLACK. When the black is gone - you're done - and almost no metal is removed from the gouge. Both sharpening systems have much smaller foot prints than a bench grinder and jigs, don't generate near as much dust and storing all the stuff for the system doesn't take hardly any room.

Ironically, turners who are accustomed to and quite adept at moving a gouge around during a cut, find "free hand" sharpening a daunting challenge - even when seeing exactly where they're sharping. If the surface is still black - you haven't sharpened that area. If it's not black - you have.

So why aren't most turners sharpening From Below and seeing what they're doing?

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#2

Leo Cuellar

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Leo Cuellar

Hi Charlie. For one I think jigs give repeatability and consistency to a grind. I do a lot of freehand grinding, just not gouges. Drill bits are something I freehand because they are easy. In fact the old drill sharpening jigs are something I have converted for use as gouge sharpening jigs. They are cheap & easy to modify. Leg length is easy to change as well. Depending on whether you buy them new or used, you can get at least four of them for the price of one gouge jig, which are somewhat expensive. Probably why most people buy one & then "compromise" by not changing the setup. With a jig you don't have to look at the edge of tool while you are grinding. You can use a Sharpie with a jig also. Once you have established the geometries that work for you, it then becomes a RonCo thing, just set it & forget it. I personally find it far easier to maintain the flow of the curve while using a jig. If I try freehanding, I always end up with facets instead.

So, it all comes back to what one is comfortable with for their level of proficiency and natural ability & depth of wallet. This is one of those things where there is no right or wrong answer, if the end result is achieved to one's satisfaction. A difference that makes no difference is no difference.

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Bill Blasic

The only thing I have to see is the cutting edge of the tool. When the sparks start coming over that edge I know that it is sharp and the Wolverine system works great for that.

Bill

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#4

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Bill Jacksonville, NC

I started out freehand sharpening on a Craftsman belt sander. Now own a Hitachi combination belt disk sander and 4� angle grinder too. Any one of those inexpensive tools will sharpen my turning tools. Replacement of belts and disk for those tools very inexpensive.

I sharpen on a dry bench grinder with Wolverine sharpening system. I can put any bevel angle on a turning tool I want with minor adjustments. Been around long enough to know what bevel angles work for me. I get same bevel angle every time touch up and edge of a tool. Those friable AO wheels last several years.

Over at woodnet.com turning thread some men raved about their Work Sharp Systems. All WS owners talked about need for more turning tool jigs from manufacturer. I am not knocking WS, has ability to sharpen variety of different woodworking tools well.

At the end of the day, a dry bench grinder, friable AO wheels, sharpening jig gives me repeatability at lowest cost to maintain and sharpen turning tools. If wife would give me more money to throw around town would like to have Tormek with turning jigs too!

What does it cost to buy and maintain a Worksharp or Jool Tool system without turning tool jigs?

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Alan Zenreich

Charlie,

I have a variety of sharpening/grinding tools.

I started with a 2"x72" Bader III belt grinder, originally set up for knifemaking.

I use this for general tool sharpening, coupled with a Nova SharpCenter.

When my wife got into turning, I picked up an 8" slow speed grinder, with a OneWay wolverine jig.

Like you, she didn't enjoy sharpening 'blind'

We laid hands on a JoolTool at the AAW Symposium in Hartford, and aside from sharpening, it looked like it would work well for her using a variety of disks and 3M brushes, especially for jewelry and some metal/enamel work.

We didn't buy the Jooltool at the show, but I found one on Craigslist (in CA) and had it shipped to me, then proceeded to spend $$$ getting additional diamond disks, brushes and accessories.

I do have to say... now the JoolTool is the rig I go to for general sharpening.

I do shaping on the other grinders, but for us, and our admittedly offbeat approach to things, the JoolTool is a fine addition to the shop.





Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#6

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Bill Howatt

Me too. I use a Oneway Varigrind and just watch for the sparks coming over the top.

I used to freehand my gouges and I think I was reasonably good at it but now that I've used the Varigrind there is no way I'd abandon it in favor of freehanding. Consistent angles which are nice to use and less metal and stone worn away.

Not sure what this issue is about sharpening blind; don't consider that a problem with the Oneway.

Bill

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#7

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

charlie belden

I'm a Buy Once, Cry Once person - and quickly forget what I paid for something - so I don't recall the price of the JoolTool or WorkSharp systems. If you're interested their websites have prices for different packages and accessories.

jooltool.com

and

worksharptools.com

(I was a bit surprised to find a quote from my review of the JoolTool on their site. To be clear, I paid

retail for the JoolTool as well as the WorkSharp and have no connection to either company other than being a customer. )

To see how these things work, go to YouTube and search for JoolTool and WorkSharp to watch videos.

Of the two, I like the WorkSharp better for several reasons

1. It makes sharpening bench chisels and hand plane irons a quick, easy and accurate No Brainer thanks

to the Four Bevel angles built in "jig"

2. the glass disks and slotted plastic wheels are 6" in diameter rather than three so there's more flat surface to work on - above and below.

3. for flat bevels, you can put two grits on each glass disk - one on top and one on the bottom. Two disks give you FOUR grits - more than enough to regrindm sharpen and polish.

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#8

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

robo hippy

This is all like turning, we all do it differently, and if we had a sharpening symposium, I could teach just about any one how to free hand any gouge profile on a platform. Some would like it, some not. How consistent your gouge profiles are, and how fast you wear away your tools does not depend on which method you use, it depends on how you, as a sharpener do it.

robo hippy

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

#9

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Why Grinders & Jigs To Sharpen Tools?

Katherine Kowalski

Charlie,

I know several colleagues (professional turners), who have tried the JoolTool and ultimately went back to freehand grinding. There is a difficulty with the JoolTool -- you cannot control the bevel angle with any degree of accuracy.

I've read part of the other thread, and I belong to the category of folks who free-hand grinds all of my tools, simply because it's so much faster than using the jig. (However, I am also one who believes in using what you want/need to -- I don't believe that there is one "best way" for everyone).

Another reason I free-hand grind is to achieve an accurate bevel angle, with the sharpening marks perpendicular to the cutting edge. (This makes the edge stronger). There is research to support ease in cutting while using one bevel angle over another. (Using a 40' bevel cuts more easily than using a 60' or 80'). Not only that, but I want my entire bevel to have the same angle, including the wings. (For this, a platform is certainly recommended).

I've no desire to convince you one way or another... just be aware of what you are giving up with different grinding choices.

Katherine