I've all the chucks Teknitool makes, including this one and never had a big issue with any in ten years. The tommy bar one you're looking at has the advantage of being much thinner than a gear driven one like the Barracuda or the Nova G3. That will give you more headstock to tail stock space for turning spindle stuff. Some folks think the gear driven ones are more secure, but I haven't seen any difference in holding power or reliability. It's a bit more awkward using the two bars instead of the single splined tool, but not that much. The nice thing about Teknitool chucks is all the jaw sets work on all the chucks save one that's only for the Titan.
I agree with Walt as I too have all the Nova chucks and have never had a problem save one. That is when I walk say into Woodcraft and the Precision Midi is on sale as it is now I usually buy another. Best in my opinion to have a chuck for every jaw set.
I will also stand in support of Nova chucks. I only have 10 so I have feelings of inadequacy compared to Terry and Bill.
They have served me well and the thing I like most is that all Nova jaw sets will fit on all Nova chucks except the smallest one they made. Stick with the SuperNova II and you will be happy.
Vicmarc and Oneway also make very fine chucks and either of those brands will serve you well.
(The preceding statement issued to defuse the inevitable arguments over which chuck is best.)
After trying a Vicmarc chuck, I sold all my Novas. It is gear driven, right hand thread with allen wrench rather than splined tool. A little more money, but well worth the difference. Avoid cheap imatations. Just my opinion.
I have a mix of chucks - including both Barracuda and Nova.
I do not care for the tommy bar chucks as my lack of three hands or coordination make them a bit hard to use.
The Barracuda want to be a 1 by 8 chuck and has a hard time growing up. I now have a 1 `/4 by 8 headstock and the Barracuda is used for taking to the Tongass Turners meetings.
My observation is that the barracuda chucks are not a well machined with loose tolerances as compared to the nova - oneway and vicmark. The Barracuda set is good value and works.
If you are going to have out of round heavy stuff, think about the SuperNova 2 or Vicmark chucks.
I rank the vicmark the best fit, most solid of those I have with the oneway and nova products close behind. (I have all of the above in the stable).
If cash flow is a serious issue, the Barracuda is a very reasonable choice that will work well on a midi for a long time (I have one married to the Jet 1014VS I turn with in Tucson in the winter).
I agree with all the comments I have a nova2 and 2 psi chucks with cole jaws and long jaws the jaws are really good and very sturdy (thick) yes they are loose but if used for small stuff like boxes or small vessels up to 10" they work very well the nova is better but for the money psi is a way to go until you are ready for bigger and serious stuff,my2cents
I do not care for the tommy bar chucks as my lack of three hands or coordination make them a bit hard to use.
I understand this complaint. However, if your lathe has a locking headstock, tommy bar chucks can actually be easier to use than keyed chucks. By locking the headstock, you only need to use one of the tommy bars to open or close the chuck -- and opening or closing with a tommy bar is quicker than with a key.
I have both kinds of chucks and I prefer using my keyed chucks (one of my lathes doesn't have a locking headstock). I just wanted to point out that tommy bar chucks have a legitimate place in a turner's arsenal.
In case you haven't been keeping score, that's a whole lot of support for Nova, Oneway and Vicmarc and less than stunning support for the 'cuda. Me, I've got a pair of Supernova II's and the small Nova you linked to. My little one has got #1 jaws on it, one of the SN2's has #3's and the other SN2 get's changed as I need to. I love them. If I was in the market for a new chuck, I would seriously consider a Vicmarc because it seems most people who try them, switch to them over their Nova's and Oneway's (as funds permit).
The tommy bar chucks also work well if you have Arthritic wrists and it hurts to turn the key on the other chucks. I go through this occasionally and will pull out the old Nova Chuck on those days.
i have a grizzly, avicmarc copy,two novas a alon astronghold... i like the grizzly very much..
i have a
i have a $99 grizzly copy of avicmarc like it very much. also have two novas one talon one stronghold.. like them all. users lile the barra. i votf grizzly
Another in the mix: Axminister with Havarti jaws. The jaws are a convex circle on the inside. This allows for a simple 3/8" cove instead of a tenon for gripping. In case of a flying bowl or the simple need to remove the item from the chuck, it allows for easy, exact realigning. I wish that Craft Supplies still carried this combo. I purchased a new one for my PM lately, direct from England. With terrible freight charges, conversion to British pounds charge by Visa, and a duty charge of $26 the cost was PROHIBITATIVE. The only good thing was that I did not pay VAT. I still love my chuck! I wish that the other good manufacturers would make these jaws available.
IMHO, you would be better off the the Grizzly VicMarc knock-off than the PSI. Until you move to a larger lathe, for quality remember vicmarc, one-way, and nova. Then there are all the others to save money.
Nova chucks are good. So are the small Vicmarc and Oneway chucks. I have the Vicmarc VM100 and love it. It uses a key.
One comment on Tommy bar chucks........... In our club, we did the egg cup race right after the Utah Woodturning Symposium. I volunteered to go first. I had a tommy bar chuck on my lathe. I started and the block of wood let go and smacked me right in the faceshield. I quickly rechucked, tightened the block down real tight and started turning. The block let go again and smacked me in the faceshield. Since we held our club meetings at the time in the San Diego Woodturning Center, they sold out of faceshields that night (more than 15 sold). I bought a keyed chuck.
I with the NOVA crowd. I have 5 (I think). And I love all except the little Nova with the Tommy bars that goes with my Jet Mini. I hate Tommy Bars!!!! Whatever one you start with you will likely stay with, at least for a while, especially if you get a bunch of jaw sets.
The website pages in the link are a discussion of the chucks that are generally available.
There is a big difference in cost between the chucks you refer to in your message. That means the quality of the steel, the fit and finish, its accuracy, gripping power, and how long it will last may all have a considerable difference. The answer to how much you want to spend really depends on often you will be using it and for how many years you will expect it to last.
I would agree that a first quality chuck is usually better than a less expensive knock-off, and often the better value in the long haul.
However, a few points to ponder:
1) Nova isn't a knock-off; it's the original.
2) Not all Nova chucks are splined. The SuperNova II has the newer hex ball chuck key. I do prefer it to the original SuperNova, which can be awkward to operate.
3) Vicmarc chucks are excellent, too -- nicely made. I'd put Axminster in the same category, as well as the OneWay line. All are premium products, and a pleasure to use.
I have three chucks, (I have chuck envy after reading this thread), all Nova's. I started with the one that uses the tommy bars and pretty much hated it. (With regular jaws, I had stuff flying all over the shop) Went to the Super Nova with the goofy key and liked it well enough to buy another, a factory second off EBAY. I have come around on the first one. I use it with Cole Jaws. Great for that. Cole Jaws use a gentler grip suited to the little chuck. Also, with the Cole jaws, you only need one bar. You can just hold the chuck with one bar and turn the jaws directly. Then use both bars to snug it down. Also pays to make a set of bars long enough to let one hit the ways. use that one to lock the chuck in place and the other one to tighten it. Locking the lathe shaft also makes it easy.