search for home built boring bar-long
Lyle Jamieson
I will start a new thread cause the other thread is kind of buried. Many of you are correct in trying to help Steve go bigger.
There are three things that can cause vibration. 1) exceed limits of the boring bar. 2) exceed the limits of the lathe, spindle or chucking method. 3) The wood itself can flex and move. (Solution for (3): use bigger wood to support the cut away from the faceplate or, in my opinion, the last resort is to use a steady rest.)
John is correct, the kind of steel in the bar has little or no impact on the vibration issue. HSS, drill rod, stainless, hot rolled, or cold rolled, will all have near the same reach over the tool rest before vibration starts. I use Stress Proof steel for my boring bars because it is case hardened, not to get better reach, but to prevent the bar from damaging itself during hollowing. The softer steels will get a washboard dimpling effect on the bottom surface of the bar from the pressure of the tool rest while cutting. Do you think the forces are significant?? Sure are!! There must be some engineers out there to confirm this flexibility of different steels. And what about the strength issue of different shaped bars.?? An �I� beam will carry the most support over a long distance. But an �I� beam will not work for turning because it has little resistance to the twisting forces. There are tremendous torque forces when we get the cutter out to the side. The next best thing is thick walled square tubing. Two horizontal and two vertical supports of the square will give you the same reach over the tool rest as a solid bar the same size, only less weight, an important consideration the bigger you go.
Mark is correct with the 15-1 formula. To go deeper you need a bigger bar.
With all that said, Steve lets address again your tip issue. I have used them all and there are huge differences in efficiency of cut. This will translate to deeper reach without vibration. Put the cutters into two categories, scrapers and slicing cutters.
When I use the HSS scraper, it is 3/16 inch because it is the most efficient cutter size. Larger cutters especially teardrop shaped cutters, take too much wood at a time. Smaller cutters cut too easily and are much harder to control.
I have graduated to the Carbide cutter for almost all my hollowing now. It too is small, at 3/16 inch diameter. I have set it on a dedicated angle to get an efficient slicing action and bevel support to clean up the bottom of end grain hollow forms and make such a sweet line and clean surface that it looks like it has been sanded already right off the tool. It acts like a hook or ring tool across the bottom. The slicing action is very efficient. I don�t know if I can get any deeper with it but it is a lot easier then the scraping mode. When I hog off large amounts of wood with the carbide cutter the trick is not to ride the bevel at the same time. Both taking a big aggressive cut and riding the bevel at the same time will accelerate vibration. So when hogging out I use a slight scooping action pulling away from the bevel slightly as I sweep across the surface. Then go back and take a light cleaning up cut with the bevel support.
As for your hook tool getting you deeper, Im not sure. It cuts easier with the slicing action but I would be surprised if it will get you any farther off the tool rest. The reach is going to be more of a bar size function then slice vs scrape. I will give you my opinion on the capped cutters like the Wood Cut or Munro cutters. They are much less efficient then the unprotected hook tool. These type of cutters are not your answer to the aggressive behavior of the hook tool.
You can test your cutting capabilities on your own lathe. Put a small waste block of wood on a faceplate and move the tool rest back at different intervals to see when vibration starts. You don�t need a tall vessel to test the reach over the tool rest. If you get vibration out at the mouth opening of a tall vessel then you have a chucking method problem not a boring bar problem � two different things.



