Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

honey locust double bulls eye?

Posts

honey locust double bulls eye?

#1

honey locust double bulls eye?

GaryG in MD

I got some green honey locust from a neighbor's very large tree downed in our recent big storm. (Luckily it fell between the house, not on top of one.) It seems to want to pith crack very quickly. I have it cut and sealed, but I'm not sure how long that will last. I love the heartwood/sapwood contrast, and I'd like to highlight it by making a double-bulls-eye bowl/vase/cup/pot out of some of it -- but I'm concerned about its apparent propensity to crack. Is this the wrong wood for this? I've had good success with dogwood, but that's a very stable wood and, unfortunately doesn't have the contrast. Will it work, or am I barking up the wrong tree? ...Gary

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#2

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Honey locust is one of my favorite woods, especially when you are fortunate enough to obtain wood with lots of orange, red, and gray color. My experience has been this is a very tough and stable wood -- not easy to work, but it can finish out in a spectacular fashion.

You mentioned dogwood. My experience with dogwood has been much different from yours -- a beautiful wood and a joy to turn, but one that is born to crack. As one prominent woodturner likes to say, "dogwood will break your heart."

Good luck with the honey locust -- watch out for the thorns.

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#3

Walt Bennett

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

Walt Bennett

I've not done a lot with it, but have been working on two halves of a good sized crotch that's very dry. Kind of like trying to turn concrete. Haven't seen any checking and the bark seems to stay on well (one is going to have some natural edge). It is very pretty, although I don't know when I'll finally finish the one I've on my big lathe now. It'll have to be done by next May for certain - it'll be a wedding present for one of my daughters.

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#4

Thanks Emmett...

GaryG in MD

Glad to hear it. I'm looking forward to highlighting that lovely heartwood.

Interesting about the dogwood. We lost a big (!) flowering dogwood in our front yard a few years ago to borers (it died virtually overnight), and I salvaged some. I have pieces that have been basically mistreated -- left to the elements -- and they haven't cracked. Must depend on what varietal or the location. Bradford pear behaves very well here too -- that surprised me, altho Bradford is fruitless, so it's not technically a "fruit wood".

...Gary

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#5

Thanks Walt...

GaryG in MD

Glad to hear it. Sounds like I have a fighting chance. I'll get some on the lathe as soon as I can. ...Gary

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#6

Ellis Walentine

I've had great luck with it

Ellis Walentine

Very few and very minor pith cracks in the vessels I've turned from honey locust. Dropping the last on on the blacktop driveway was another matter.

By all means go for it, and forget dogwood, especially if there's pith anywhere near the turning blank.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#7

Thanks Ellis...

GaryG in MD

I'm very glad to hear it. I'm keeping six pieces of various sizes from 4" - 10" in diameter and donating the remainder to our MCW Silent Auction next week. One thing I want to try for sure is a Patrick O'Brien style NE, winged, double-bull's-eye pot. This should be perfect for that. Might make some nice little end-grain goblets too. Unfortunately, I have more inspiration than turning time! ...Gary

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#8

Re: Thanks Ellis...

John Jordan

Honey Locust is not crack prone at all, and is quite stable to boot. One of my favorites, too. As with any wood, if you leave the pith in it, you MAY have problems.

John

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#9

Hi John...

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your comment. I took the tree cutters word that this is honey locust, but I'm starting to wonder if it might not be black locust -- because the color of the heart wood is more on the yellow/green side. I'll ask Ed Karch next week at our meeting. Is black locust more prone to cracking? ...Gary

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Locust

Ellis Walentine

The bark is very different from black locust to honey locust -- black locust bark is very deeply furrowed -- and the heartwood of honey locust is decidedly pinkish, while black locust is yellowish. I haven't turned black locust, so I can't tell you about cracking.

Ellis

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#11

Thanks Ellis...

GaryG in MD

This is almost certainly black locust then because it has the deeply furrowed bark. So much for the expertise of tree cutters! Thanks, Gary

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#12

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

George Guadiane

I too really like Honey Locust, especially with the gray staining against the deep pink heart and yellow sap woods... Nice contrasts, and interesting combinations.

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#13

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

Jorge Casta�eda

Gary,

I love working with honey locust and my costumers love to buy those bowls, it is good and stable, the only cracks i got were in crotch pieces.

My experience with dogwood is different than yours.

Have fun!

Jorge

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#14

BlackLocust

Jorge Casta�eda

Ellis,

Black locust is very prone to cracking, turned green and let thinner than "normal" it may crack less but it still may crack on the outside and be ok on the inside. Once dry is very hard

My last night bowl is a black locust, people buy them.

Jorge

Re: honey locust double bulls eye?

#15

thanks Jorge...

garyg in md

Sorry I didn't have any big pieces for you. I had to really limit my "take" because I'm still backlogged on hickory and maple. ...Gary