Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

A work in progress (and lab experiment)

Posts

A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#1

Steven Antonucci

A work in progress (and lab experiment)

steven antonucci

I've been following another turner's project over on the AAW site. He's making a very large hollow vessel out of a 300# cherry log, and the scale of it is intimidating. I had some back and forth with him over end grain cutting techniques, and then I realized that I've never been 4-5' over the rest, so what I thought might not translate at that distance. I set out to test a theory.

My lathe is certainly not up to spinning 300# of wood, so I had to scale things to what I owned. I started with a quartered section of an ash tree that was about 24" long. It is attached and rounded to about 7" at the far end, and roughly 6" at the faceplate. There are 4 1-1/4" concrete screw on the inner race of the face plate, and 4 2" deck screws on the outer race of the faceplate, which is a 6" Nova aluminum.

The first thing I noticed is that there is way too much flex in the wood/faceplate at that distance. My center at the tailstock end is probably moving by a 1/4" or more. When you work at this scale, bigger screws and a steel faceplate are a must. I tried to use my steady rest, but the vibrations kept loosening the wheels (I will be re building it-better, stronger, faster...)

Any attempts to use a bowl gouge or any conventional turning tools were impossible because of the vibration. I decided that the way to go was to remove some of the overhung mass. I did this by plunge cutting to the full length of my Stihl O17's 14" bar. At the end of this exercise, I had "hollowed" the first 14" to approximately 2" wall thickness. I think the key word here is "approximately"...

Now, with about 1/2 of the mass gone, I tried to cut again. Vibration was still horrific, but I eventually got it relatively uniform to be able to test three removal methods. On the AAW site, the other turner is using a modified drill bit/end mill. I suggested a hook tool. Finally, I wanted to compare a traditional Ellsworth style boring bar.

I grabbed a drill bit and modified it to match what the other turner is using. My boring bar is 3/4" round and telescopes into the handle, which is just blackpipe wrapped in leather to give it a better grip and keep my hands from getting black (1 out of 2 isn't bad...). In one end of the bar, there is a set screw to hold the mill cutter. The other end holds the hook or Ellsworth style cutter. There are several set screws to secure the bar at whatever extension I pick.

To be fair, I would drill a center hole with a 5/16" drill bit, and then cut into the face grain from the center hole. I would describe this as being efficient, but still taking the beating when you get 17-20" over the rest. It works very well at shorter distances.

The Ellsworth style bit was very hard to conrol at that distance. Even the slightest movement is amplified over that long of a lever, and I really couldn't do much with it.

The modified mill/drill bit worked very well for the turner on the AAW site, but I struggled with it greatly. I did manage to cut with it, but it seemed very finicky. You have to remember that I am doing this all completely hand held, so I felt every last ding or kick.

Finally, the hook that I used. I inched up towards that center hole,and it was almost sucked in. once it was in that hole, it was basically locked. All I needed to do was pull straight back, and the curls were flying. I kicked myself for not trying it sooner. For me, it was the easiest to control, the fastest to to remove material, and by far the best way to cut end grain. I think I will start another version of this test soon, but I have to borrow someone's lathe :-) I want to go BIG.

Here is a picture. The vessel is about 19" deep at this point, and will finish out around 21" total. it is meant to be very rough, as it is a prototype for a new process I will be trying in a few weeks when the weather cools off. The bar is probably about 5' as you see it here, and I am at the limits of what it can do, which is good, since my lathe can't do any more either.

Battered and bruised...

Steven

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#2

Barb Siddiqui

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

Barb Siddiqui

Steve, no steady rest for that?

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

Bill Blasic

Steve,

Wow! I'm impressed keep it going.

Bill

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#4

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

Joe Dickason

Steve,

What is the relationship of the centerline of the cutter to the centerline of your tool holder? Does this make sense? How about a close up of the cutter end of the tool?

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#5

Steven Antonucci

I tried to use mine!

steven antonucci

but I'm not sure if it was gremlins or harmonics or what... it made the vibrations worse!

I'm going to "rebuild" the steady rest using a much different construction method. The one I made is a pain to set up, and I don't think it's as rigid as it could be. V2 will fix all of that.

Steve

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#6

Steven Antonucci

I aim for centerline

steven antonucci

You have to remember that this bar now takes three very different types of cutters. The Mill/drill bit is a 5/16" diameter. The hook I made from 1/4" O1. The Ellsworth style cutters are made from 1/4" square stock. Currently, the hook and the Ellsworth share the same hole. The mill is on the other side of the bar.

At these distances, I think it's pretty darn near impossible to control centerline cutting unless you use a back outrigger (a la by buddy Lyle). The slightest movement translates nearly equally to the cutting tip. If you dip by 1/4", your tip goes up 1/4".

I started thinking about improving the accuracy of my "machining" last night. All of my holes are a little bit "off" since I hand drilled them by sighting with the bubble level. I have an idea to improve the accuracy 100%- and it is very simple. I will standardize on one diameter of cutter.

On the mill, it seems to want to use the trailing edge of the cutter, which means that I need to have the tool above center. The Ellsworth want to be on center or slightly above. The hook will depend upon where and how you present it, but generally around center too.

The business end of the bar is nothing more than a hole with an intersecting set screw, eyeballed to the center of the bar, about 3/4" deep.

Steve

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#7

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

Don Orr

Nice job so far Steve. You have some valuable data as well. I've been trying to watch the big vase progress too-need to check his work again though. I'm looking forward to see how you work this out.

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

Lyle Jamieson

Hay buddy Steve, You are up a creek without the right paddles. Been there � done that, way before there was such a thing as captured systems. You need to think bigger and stronger. Scale will hurt you. I have seen people doing some pretty dangerous things trying to exceed the limits of their tools. Your story revolves around the cutters but there are other matters more important to consider.

When you do your steady rest, make it bigger and stronger then you think you need. Use 4 or 5 or 6 wheels. Once you get that much weight pushing on the standard 3 wheel steady rests, the wheels will literally melt. Frank Sudol and I tested that back in the early 90�s. Frank did pieces up to 5 feet tall. It took a fork lift to move the boring bar.

You are correct you need a stronger and bigger lathe too. The spindle size and bearings will only take so much side motion stresses without telegraphing the vibrations. Better faceplate is a wise move too.

You need a much bigger boring bar to dangle over the tool rest that far. Its not the length but the diameter that will allow you to go deeper. When you get a heavier boring bar it becomes near impossible to hold it up on the handle end. Then you need a secondary backrest just to hold up the handle. Don�t forget the safety bar across the top. I think we are working our way toward a captured system again!!?? The danger is magnified with big vessels because the weight increases. The mass of big stuff spinning around will not just stop easily with a catch. I have seen people get lifted right off the ground.

You are wise to sneak up on the scale. Testing the tool limitations as you go is imperative.

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment) *LINK*

Mike Stafford

Steve, when I was reading about your trials and tribulations I knew that I had nothing to offer in the way of advice as I have never been more that 8 inches over the tool rest and can only imagine the difficulties that you are encountering.

But it did bring to mind another turner who has already solved your problems in a much bigger way. His name is Anatoly Tsiris and he lives in Charlotte. I have seen his work and it is larger than I am and folks who know me will tell you that is large indeed.

Here is a link to his web site where you can see his work and his solutions that might offer you some ideas. He has videos on one of his pages where you can see his large tooling.


Turning the big stuff!!!

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#10

Re: A work in progress - Another Big Turner  *LINK*

Neil Longhenry

Here is a site for another guy that turns big items from tree trunks. Some of the items start at 2000#. He uses a huge pattern making lathe that was used to turn Battleship drive shafts. Have seen his work and the finish is awesome.


Virgil Leih Tree Trunk Art

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#11

Re: More than 12"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

with a 3/4" bar? Nah nah nah. No wonder you're playing follow the bouncing tip.

Quick and dirty formula for boring bar size is 15 times the diameter of the bar if you want to minimize cutter vibration so 3/4" = 12" bore. For wood, you can push that a bit if the bar is hardened.

20-24" hollowing? Better call up ENCO, Steve, and get you some 1-1/2" drill rod in the UPS box. :D

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#12

Re: More than 12" I agree

John Lucas

I've hollowed up to 14" but started getting pretty bad chatter after 12. I did pick up a hollow bar that is 1 1/4" outside. I keep thinking I'll make a larger bar just haven't had the need yet. I'll hang on to it. You never know. I might want to make very large vase some day.

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#13

Steven Antonucci

loving the one your with...

steven antonucci

"If youcan't be with the one you love... I used what I had available :)

Overall, I agree with you on most points. I can say that I didn't get lifted, but I did catch a couple of good jolts in my armpit. The handle is WAY TOO SHORT and TOO LIGHT to counteract that kind of extension (unless I capture it:) )

With only 1.5 HP, I did manage to stall the lathe SEVERAL times. Keeping the belt a little looser is a fail safe.

I would be more likely to hurt myself on a bigger lathe though, since it wouldn't stop in a catch, but more likely batter me senseless (even moreso than I am currently...)

I am using the 3/4" bar simply because it was what I had. I think a bigger bar would help here, but it wasn't about the bar- it was about the cutter's efficiency. I would love to hear about using a hook tool in a captured system if you have any data.

Steve

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#14

Steven Antonucci

ancient chinese secret...

steven antonucci

I think Mark's Rule of Thumb is a good starting point, but it is a "Procrustean Bed" (you're probably going to have to Google it :) ). The purpose of the post was to expose that it depends on what you are using to remove the wood! I have hollowed with an even smaller bar than this (5/8") to 12" by using a hook instead of the Ellsworth style cutter.

The difference is that you are no longer scraping, but cutting instead. At 19" over the rest, it is SO FAST that you are holding on for dear life because it is almost self feeding! I think the formula doesn't take this into account.

That said, I priced out a 1" bar of hardened O1 @ $28.67...

Maybe I'll look into 1 1/4"...

S

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#15

Steven Antonucci

"You're gonna need a bigger boat"

steven antonucci

2 guys making storage problems :)

I have enough work in my shop that nobody's bought! I don't need the big stuff too!

S

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#16

An Italian

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Speaking in Greek, hmmmmmm

At least I covered myself with the appropriate qualifiers. The Rule, btw, is an old machinist's standard.

Oh, Good luck drilling on that hardened bar stock.

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#17

Re: ancient chinese secret...

bill crommett from Seneca

After watching Frank Sudol do one of his tall vases, I did a 16 in. deep vase with a long boring bar in a home made captured scraper system. It sits on the kitchen cabinet as one of my "Never-again-series". And the bar sits in the corner of the shop along with old broom handles and floor mops which are also part of a "Never again series ".

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#18

Re: ancient chinese secret...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Get a Kobra, Bill, and shorten your list. ;)

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#19

Steven Antonucci

The answer is always one more tool

steven antonucci

away from greatness!

If I figure this out (ok, when, not if...I'm not giving up!), I may only cut one or two more after this... just to make sure that I "got it". These big prototypes are 'expensive to store'!

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#20

Ancient Chinese Proverb

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"Yo Dude, it's your rice bowl."

;)

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#21

Re: ancient chinese secret...

John Lucas

Steve I think I'd try it with regular steel bar first. I don't really think the drill rod will change the vibrations that much. It is stiffer but when your talking about actual vibration reduction vs stiffness I don't know how the 2 would differ. I know when Vic from bestwoodtools was designing his tool rests he found that different steels absorbed vibration better. He found a steel designed by NASA specifically to absorb vibration and still be stiff.

Since there is such a huge difference in cost I'd give the cheap stuff a try unless you figure in labor costs.

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#22

Steven Antonucci

Youtube video of Elmer Adams

steven antonucci

If you search Youtube for Elmer Adams hollowing set-up, he's actually using a rectangular section on his hollowing setup. Lighter, stiffer, probably cheaper, and easier...

The only consideration is that you have to "attach something" to the end of the bar to hold your cutters and you commit to a larger entry hole...

I may just check out the local scrap yard before I call Enco...

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#23

Re: Scrap Yard

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

There's a pretty good one over the river in Easton.

Re: A work in progress (and lab experiment)

#24

Steven Antonucci

Might even source new materials

steven antonucci

I have two local (10 minutes away) sources, so it's just a matter of thinking about the problem a little bit longer before I go "treasure hunting". May even see about making that captured back rest that Lyle keeps telling me about :)