Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Fraternal twins

Posts

Fraternal twins

#1

Fraternal twins

Toney Robertson

I had an oval piece of maple burl and it set there for the longest time. I finally had the inspiration to make this. The base and finials are Walnut.

16 1/2" x 13" x 4 1/2". The two bowls are 5 1/2" x 5" and 6" x 5".

Quite a challenge for me to get the bowls aligned correctly.

All comments welcomed.


img

Re: Fraternal twins

#2

Pic #2 

Toney Robertson


img

Re: Fraternal twins

#3

Wonderful Toney

john lucas

Re: Fraternal twins

#4

WOW.....beautiful and perfect

Ruth Niles

Toney, this is awesome. The wood is perfect, the shapes are perfect, the bent wood base is perfect. Can you tell I like it??

Re: Fraternal twins

#5

Beautiful Lidded Pair

Gil Jones

Re: Fraternal twins

#6

Re: Pic #2

fgvanatta

A really great piece. I especially like the base - did you bend it with steam?

Re: Fraternal twins

#7

Beautiful!

Carole Valentine

Re: Fraternal twins

#8

Re: Pic #2

Toney Robertson

No, it is a laminated bend.

I used plastic resin glue so that creep would be minimized.

Thanks for the kind comments.

Re: Fraternal twins

#9

Barb Siddiqui

Wow. Really stunning.

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Fraternal twins

#10

karl jr

Re: Fraternal twins

karl jr

Wow, that really is taking it a step further. My attention is drawn to the lift and curves of the platform, which I think are beautiful. The finials, in my eyes, do not reflect the entire piece. Love the negative space heart shape.

KTK

Re: Fraternal twins

#11

Absolutely gorgeous! 

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Re: Fraternal twins

#12

extraordinary!

GaryG in MD

The two bowls would easily stand on their own (in terms of beauty), but your presentation is an inspiration. Outstanding! ...Gary

Re: Fraternal twins

#13

Re: Fraternal twins

Terry Scott

As my kids would say Way Cool Dad

Re: Fraternal twins

#14

Re: Fraternal twins

Joe Herrmann

Very nice. Great design.

Re: Fraternal twins

#15

Spectacular!

Don Orr

Re: Fraternal twins

#16

Speechless... it's that good...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

Re: Fraternal twins

#17

all of the above and more!

bob davis

Re: Fraternal twins

#18

Re: Fraternal twins

Barry L Elder

It's really great that you left that piece until the right time, Toni! You raised the bar quite a bit with this piece of art. This should grace the cover of one or two magazines! Kudos!!!

Re: Fraternal twins

#19

Re: Fraternal twins

Toney Robertson

I appreciate the nice comments and I am interested in your comment on the finials.

Do you have a suggestion on what would have looked better in your eyes in relation to the piece?

My thinking was to keep it simple so as not to detract or take away from the bowls and the curves.

Your further thoughts would be appreciated.

Re: Fraternal twins

#20

I appreciate all of your kind words.

Toney Robertson

Especially considering the wonderful pieces I see on here.

Re: Fraternal twins

#21

karl jr

Re: Fraternal twins

karl jr

Hi Toney.

First let me say that your "Fraternal twins" piece is quite beautiful, and well beyond anything that I've ever managed to create (or ideate).

I agree with your decision to use simple finials. I think highly ornate finials would pull ones attention away from the platform, and those fantastic curves.

In my opinion, those curves, and their repetition, are a major compositional element. Look at the symmetry of the curve of the upper container's lid and the curve of the platform directly below it, and the curve at the bottom of the platform. Or, compare the rims of the two vessels. That's what I'm talking about.

The finials themselves don't have that compositional unity with the rest of the piece. The upper finial profile has a similarity to the legs of the platform, but that's not strong enough to tie the whole thing together. Besides, it's mostly rectilinear, while the rest of the piece is all curves. The lower finial is more curvy, but it doesn't have the fullness of the rest of the parts. Perhaps that's what doesn't look right to me. Maybe more similar finials would be the solution.

I get the point of the name "Fraternal twins." If the finials were the same you would have called the piece "Identical twins."

Please take this all with a grain of salt. It's just an opinion, and everyones got one. I'm probably not even qualified to critique your work :)

KTK

Re: Fraternal twins

#22

Steve Kubien

Re: Fraternal twins

Steve Kubien

This is a special breed of "amazing". Very, very well done.

Re: Fraternal twins

#23

Re: Fraternal twins

Toney Robertson

Thanks for the reply. I enjoy honest critiques and I believe that it really helps me grow by incorporating different perspectives.

Re: Fraternal twins

#24

Re: Fraternal twins

ed hoxter

very nice toney. i really like your style. great job ed