Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

Posts

Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#1

Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

Donna Banfield

Ho do you handle requests for donations of your work for charity auctions? I've encountered two schools of thought; one is to donate an older turning that has been hanging around for awhile, or hasn't sold for one reason or another. Maybe it's a turning that you signed and dated with the year, and that might be turning people off -- oh that's LAST YEAR'S work. There's really nothing wrong with the turning, but it just hasn't sold. Some use the charity request to clear out some of the their inventory, and are happy to do that.

Another school of thought is to use the request to present your BEST work to date. This is another opportunity to get your work seen by a whole new audience. Do you want them to see work that is one or two years old? If you had a piece that wasn't selling, there might be a good reason -- so why would you want to put that piece out there into circulation? It also may not represent how good your work is now.

I used to practice the first school of thought, and then read an article pointing out the second school of thought, and it was a 'Doh' moment for me. From this point forward, when I decide to donate work, I will create a piece specifically for that charity. Below is a natural edge Elm calabash (8" high by 6" wide by 1/4" thick) that I turned for the Guild of NH woodworkers. They have a tent at the League of NH Craftsmen Fair (http://www.nhcrafts.org/) at Sunapee, NH every August, where we demonstrate and sell raffle tickets for the donated work. The proceeds from the raffle are used to fund scholarships for the membership.

The photographs are not the best, though. I had less than 1 hour between the time that I Bealle buffed the calabash, and when the Raffle Coordinator was picking it up. So no time to get it to my photographer. So do you donate work to charity? What do you think about the two schools of thought?





http://www.nhcrafts.org/

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#2

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

John Lucas

Sort of depends on what it's for. For simple gift donations (read that not a fundraiser) I try to give them a nice piece but one that I haven't spend a lot of time on. These do represent you so I do give them a nice piece not some junk piece.

If it's a fundraiser I try to do the best I can. After all your trying to raise money and a something that would normally sell at a low price won't raise much money. My pieces don't often bring as much as the glass and jewelry donations so I have to make something pretty spectacular to feel good about the donation. Of course sometimes they ask at really bad times and I simply don't have the better work and no time to make a piece so I either turn them down or give something of lesser quality. Kind of depends on the venue. I always want to help out but I don't want to embarass myself either so If I don't have a piece that fits that venue then I don't donate.

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

What I have done in the past

steven antonucci

Depending upon how much lead time I get, I will use one or the other approach. My wife has a habit of springing these things on me at the last minute, so I use them as an opportunity to empty the shelves of stuff that wasn't "just perfect." Most of these pieces are never signed or dated, so the folks that might bid on them don't know me from Pier 1 Imports. They buy them because they like them, and they tend to bring "below market value". My logic is that they are going to a good cause (whatever it is), and whatever they sell for is more than the value of them sitting on my shelves catching sawdust.

If I think that the audience is going to be slightly more sophisticated, I might put a hollowform in the event, otherwise, it is strictly bowls. You don't need to explain what you do with a bowl.

If I have enough lead time, I will make something 'quick' for the event following the same rules. I rarely sand bowls beyond 220 grit, and the finish is oil and wax. Start to finish is about an hour. The goal is to make them look good enough to sell, but not too good that they don't get used. I don't really understand the whole high finish bowl market...just another thing to dust!

Steve

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Rob Wallace

Hi Donna:

I have donated several pieces over the past few years, and have produced some 'simple' pieces, which, as Steve explained, don't take too long to make an acceptable piece. I also have used the donated pieces to experiment with some new techniques. About 3 years ago I was asked to donate a piece to the Central Iowa Symphony Fundraising Silent Auction, and I produced a display platter (in cherry) with antique brass inlay (I had not tried the inlay technique before). The title of the piece is "Get in Treble" - It featured a brass-inlayed treble clef with a ring of brass around the inside. In the written description displayed with the piece during the auction, I explained that this was the only item being sold where the successful buyer would not only "Get in Treble", but would also buy a brass band at the same time!

The piece was among the highest bidded items at the auction. I think that making the piece related to the group's mission (promotion of orchestral music) was a big factor in having it sell so well to this group.

Interesting thread...!!

Rob


Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#5

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Barry Irby

I have been asked to donate to two or three different things. One was a charity auction for a Garden Club. I gave them a trellis I made from copper pipe and it had a turning at the top. Oddly, unknown to me, my neighbor bought it and put it in their front yard. I drive by it every time I leave the neighborhood. It's sort of weird and gives me the "cat came back" feeling.

I donated another huge and much more elaborate trellis to a charity for animals. It sold for several times what I thought it was worth and raised several thousand for the charity. I got the feeling that it might raise the "value" of my work. I think your tax write off is the cost of the work, not what it sold for.

A group of Realtors asked me to make dog houses for homeless dogs. I gave them a few, but then realized some of them were being used in the Realtors yards, and stopped donating them. Someone here pointed out there might be legal issues with a Home Inspector to be donating stuff to Realtors.

I'll stop now, I think I have side tracked this conversation.

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#6

Re: It Depends

Steve C in NC

Donna

I have donated several items over the past few years. For Charity auctions, I usually try to make something special for the event but at times I have had to pull something off the shelf. I do try to make whatever I am sending a quality piece and always sign it.

Several times I have been asked to create a piece for a specific event (or person) such as a going away gift for a pastor or for recognition to a board member for a non profit. In these cases, if it is for a cause I support, I will create a special personalized piece and donate it. Again signed and dated.

Steve

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#7

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Lan Brady

Donna,

I probably donate more pieces than I sell. My only criteria is "am I proud of this turning? Do I want my name associated with it in public?"

Lan

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Mike Stafford

I donate a couple of pieces each year in support of the local arts center and I donate a piece for the NC Symposium.

I always try to donate something that was turned specifically for the event and something that I am proud of which I hope represents my best work.

If you are going to put your name on it then it should represent your name well.

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#9

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Bill-Jacksonville, NC

Think a deduction for your donation on your income tax more important than donating old or new work. Of course, if you do not itemize on 1040, your donation is a non-issue.

You must donate to a tax-exempt organization (501(3)c, or religious group or church. IRS is pretty specific who you can donate too and claim a deduction.

Non-cash contributions subject to strict record keeping and substantiation requirements. Especially if value of item (s) over $250 or $500. Think if donation over $500 organization must provide you with IRS Form 8283.

If you have routine, sales not sure record keeping or substantiating worth of items you donate is a big problem. If you do not sell your work normally, think you can still claim a deduction for donated. Still might not be worth the effort to claim a deduction.

Your mileage may vary.

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#10

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Donna Banfield

Thanks to everyone who responded. I was pleased to discover most of you follow the second school of thought -- create a turning specifically for that event, because it represents your best work to date. Yes, it may take longer, but it's not worth doing if you're not going to do it well. At least that's what I remember my Mom drilling into my head when I was a 'wild child' :D

By doing this I think we are all doing our part to help educate the general public about how something created from wood can hold a valued and treasured place in our homes, right next to the two-dimensional artwork.

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#11

Joe Fleming

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Joe Fleming

Donna,

I donate to a variety of fundraisers. What I have discovered is that I need to gauge the donation to the audience, both in terms of applicability and in value. I once donated a piece that I conservatively valued at $300. It sold for $80. When that happens, you cannot take it personally. Instead, I learn from the experience and adjust.

For a food bank auction at work, I donate Christmas ornaments and usually get above market. Once, I tried a hollow form and ended up buying it myself. I still sold it for more and the auction got its money. I often bid my own pieces up into the low-acceptable range, if I get a chance - especially in a silent auction - to keep the bidding public honest.

I always donate my best work whether old or not. I keep seconds for show and tell-off. :-)

Joe Fleming

San Diego

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long) *LINK*

#12

Re: Donating your work for charity? (Long)

Dave Long

I've helped out with a number of charity auctions over the years gathering pieces from different mediums (glass, wood, ceramic). Everyone faces the same problem as Donna. I always advise individuals to do something event specific if possible and make it your best work. You never know who is going to buy the piece and who may see it on display either at the auction or in someone's home. It may be your only chance to make a favorable impression on a potential client.