Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

icing test

Posts

icing test

#1

icing test

John Lucas

I'm still trying to find the best recipe for cupcake icing. Here is a photo of the latest test. The top left one has the best icing look but the epoxy filler is tan so it really changes the color and I doubt you can get light pastels or whites which unfortunately is how most cup cake icings look.

To be a good candidate it has to hold a sharp edge, take color well and have a texture that resembles icing which is kind of sugary. To make these as lidded boxes it also has to be tough which rules out many of the nicer looking formulas I've tried.

The bottom left may be the best choice so far. It is a white filler that is so fine you must wear a mask to mix it because it floats in the air. It's hard to mix but doesn't change the color of the paint that I'm using and seems to hold a crisp edge. I'll mix some up later this week and use the icing decorator tips to try it out.

You can see two of the latest cupcakes in the back ground.

Re: icing test

#2

Ric Taylor

Have You Tried Spackling or Plaster?

Ric Taylor

Re: icing test

#3

I have, way to fragile.

John Lucas

Re: icing test

#4

Re: icing test

Randy Gleckler

Another idea you might mess with is Plastic Resin. You can get it in a clear formula that you can mix, dye etc to whatever you need. Ed Davidson might be able to weigh in on his thoughts on if that would work for this application.

Re: icing test

#5

Btw...

Randy Gleckler

My wife, the cake decorator, said the Top Left or Bottom Left would be the closest in her opinion. :-D

Re: icing test

#6

Re: icing test

John Lucas

Randy I've played with Resins of different types including fiberglass. The basic problem is the filler that you have to add to get it to an icing thickness. Most Resins and epoxies are too glossy looking. Adding the fillers not only changes the gloss but also thickens them. That's why I'm playing with different fillers because I need a certain texture as well as thickness to achieve the final results.

Re: icing test

#7

Re: icing test

Stuart Johnson

If you are trying to add the slight grain effect of sugar mixing in some very fine almost dust, white sand.

Re: icing test

#8

Micro Balloons Filler

charlie belden

Appearance somewhere between granulated sugar and confectionary sugar - closer to granlated - and white.

Micro ballons in white caulking might work - though drying time to firm for thick applications might be an issue.

Golden makes some pretty thick gel "mediums" that might be an off the shelf solution.

Re: icing test

#9

Re: icing test *LINK*

Ed McDonnell

I think Charlie was on the right track with the Golden Gels, except I think their pastes would work better for what you are trying.

Here's a link with lots of info.

Ed


Golden Company Website

Re: icing test

#10

Re: Micro Balloons Filler

John Lucas

Charlie I think micro balloons are what is in the filler I used on the bottom left sample. The top right sample is a gel medium similar to Golden's. It looks perfect and spreads just like icing but it simply doesn't get hard enough.

Re: icing test

#11

Rob Wallace

Did you try Bondo?

Rob Wallace

John:

You didn't say if you have tried good old Bondo auto body repair compound. I helped my son make a mountain & volcano with it this past school year, and it seemed like frosting to me! I air brushed the color onto the Bondo for his project, but you might be able to add colored pigments to it (..maybe dry tempra paint?) while you mix the filler and hardener to get the frosting color you want. Once it's cured, it has most of the properties you are looking for....alternatively, you could paint/air-brush the finished icing to the color you want using opaque paints.

Just a thought - you may have already been down the Bondo path already...??

Rob

Re: icing test

#12

Re: Did you try Bondo?

John Lucas

I did play with Bondo. It comes as gray or red and it's hard to mix any color with it. I did think about using "whatever" and then air brushing but I would have to mask off all the areas outside the icing and that would be a real pain. I'm trying to keep the cost down on these things because I know the won't sell if I get to expensive.

Re: icing test

#13

Metal glaze instead of bondo *LINK*

Dick Coers

They make a thin version of bondo called metal glaze. If you mix the catalyst rather light, it will take longer to dry and will flow out to a nice shine. The stuff we use here in the model shop comes in a nice pale blue color, and a dark blue glaze


metal glaze

Re: icing test

#14

Re: Metal glaze instead of bondo

John Lucas

Looks like fun stuff to play with but I don't want it to flow out. I need it to be about at thick as peanut butter.

Re: icing test

#15

Bake It To Harden It?

charlie belden

Perhaps you could bake it - at a lower temperature - say 150 - to get it to harden - or WAIT a few days.

Maybe a lot of thin layers, dried for an hour or two between applications would set up faster in the long run.

The other possibility is to just go with the Dipped Icing look.

Or you could use the formula in the upper left - epoxy filler - then airbrush with white primer to get it lighter, then airbrush whatever color you want.

Ain't the pursuit of Wild Hare Ideas fun? And with all this experimenting, you'll probably find something you don't need NOW - but may be perfect for a future piece. If nothing else, you're narrowing down the possibiliities that DON'T Work - to paraphrase Thomas Edison.

Re: icing test

#16

Latex caulk?

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

Re: icing test

#17

Re: icing test

gtwilkins

John,

Have you tried Durham's Water Putty:

http://www.waterputty.com/

I have been using this stuff for years to fill, fix, model etc. It dries in any shape and is tough stuff, I think it would hold up even on a box lid.

Trevor

Re: icing test

#18

Re: icing test

john lucas

Durhams is the green one on the bottom right. I've been using it but any sharp edges are fragile and it's tan so it's hard to get light pastels or whites.

Re: icing test

#19

Re: Metal glaze instead of bondo

Dick Coers

Maybe flowout is too strong of word. I'll whip up a little spot tomorrow and take a pic for you.

Re: icing test

#20

Re: icing test

Janet Bequeaith

Google--Home made play doh or play dough.

Basic ingredients: Flour, sugar, water, cream of tattar.

Christmas tree ornaments are made out of this stuff. Lots of craft shows have these.

I'll bet your wife has even made home made play doh. It can be tinted.

Re: icing test

#21

Re: Oops, I mean "salt"

Janet Bequeaith

Oops! Make that: Flour, Salt, Water and Cream of Tattat.

Re: icing test

#22

Re: Oops, I mean "salt"

John Lucas

I'll have to try that. Does it get very hard? Of course your asking someone who can barely cook in the microwave to mix these chemicals together. With my luck I'll create a bomb and be on the terrorist watch list, or dead.

Re: icing test

#23

Re: Icing

Janet Bequeaith

Also, Google--homemade Modeling clay.

My mom made the play dough 40 years ago, crafted clusters of grapes with vines and all, they are still hanging on her wall.

She slow baked in oven and after painting some highlights, she sealed everything with deluted white glue. What about using spray shellac or thin epoxy to coat icing?

Good luck!

Re: icing test

#24

Re: icing test

Dick Strauss

John,

Have you thought about mortar? It is pretty tough, can be dyed, and it has the sugar texture you want...