Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

Posts

Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#1

JL

Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

JL

Every once in a while I want to turn something with a little more "thickness" - or diameter. I've got some Shaker pedestal table patterns which require a finished diameter of about 2.375".

I typically turn legs, stretchers and the like so I have a reasonable amount of fat maple (3"-3.5"). I have some nice boards of 10/4 maple. What I don't have is fat (or thick) cherry and black walnut - I do have thinner stuff.

So - I was thinking about gluing. I can try to "reasonably" match the grain - but that has problems. So - how about "flaunting" the difference? Putting in a contrasting wood or a different grain?

Any thoughts? Sentiments? Objections?

TIA.

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#2

Re: All options are open, just be....

JamieDonaldson

....very sure of good glue joints. Where you will get into trouble is when the process demands Rube Goldberg solutions to achieve your purposes, like joining 2 lathes together to turn bed posts in 1 piece, etc. ;)

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#3

Re: All options are open, just be....

Matt Overton

you mean I shouldn't do that?

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#4

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

John Lucas

My opinion is you have to be really careful when using contrasting woods. It starts looking amatureish really quickly. I don't mean that as an insult (I've certainly done it) it's just things like cherry and maple or walnut and ash are very typical of new turners work because "we" had a tendency to glue up whatever we had available.

My thoughts would be to add veneer strips to the glue ups to not only help the contrast but make it look more professional. You could large cherry pieces then maple veneer, a little thicker cherry and then the maple spacer to give you the thickness you need. This would look like you did thin cherry banding into the maple which would look nice.

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#5

JL

I'm going to be doing Shaker pedestal (sewing)

JL

tables. I typically have a 2 3/4" diameter at the greatest part of the bulb. The bottom area for the leg attachment is 2 3/8" or so.



I can always turn the pedestal in maple and then dye it - but I typically use the table top and drawer wood for the legs and the pedestal.

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#6

Leo Cuellar

Re: I'm going to be doing Shaker pedestal (sewing)

Leo Cuellar

It is my limited understanding that the Shakers typically used different species of wood in one piece of furniture. Not just where it wasn't visible either. Some of their design criteria appears to be aesthetic as well as durability of material. There are pine table tops on walnut bases and other actually kind of horrid things. So mixing it up would be historically accurate. That being said, I would try for a book matched look if I had to build up stock. I might also consider a hollow segmented/staved form to turn down, or perhaps 3 diamond segments as are used for inside out turning. I haven't personally tried the last two, but hope to get some time to try it out someday, because thick stock is just way too expensive. Hope that helps some :\

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#7

JL

I hadn't considered "quarters" or "thirds".

JL

That idea has merit. I've glued up legs for flat work to emulate 1/4 sawn on each side of a leg before. Quartering would be easy. For thirds, I could set my table saw on 30 degrees (it is a left tilt) and cut some trial pieces and give it a shot. Thanks - I'll try it.

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Questions about wood and gluing spindle stock

Mike Stafford

I seem to remember an episode of New Yankee Workshop where he did what you are describing JL by using quartersawn stock to wrap two sides of the legs he was going to turn. By using quartersawn stock he disguised the glue up pretty well.