I am setting up a shop and hope to be turning soon. I need some advice on dust collection. Do you generally run a dust collector while turning, or just sanding?
As $$ is a huge factor, I was thinking of the less expensive (and less effective) Harbor freight 2HP, 5 micron, then putting it in a bump-out on the outside of the shop. That way the stuff under 5 microns is outside my work area (if I ever air condition the shop this obviously wont work ).
Or would I be better off to put the cash one of the air helmets.
I only run my DC (my old 1Hp model) when sanding and when I remember, turn on the shop air cleaner. The large chips have too much energy to be redirected into the DC pickup. My dust pickup is the 4" hose stuck in the end of a small cardboard box positioned behind the workpiece but there are more elegant solutions.
When turning I always use a faceshield. I should say if the lathe is spinning a piece of wood I have the faceshield on no matter what is going on. I also wear a LV dust mask ( http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=62066&cat=1,42207,43647 ) under the shield as a minimum. I also have a Triton respirator which provides forced filtered air into the helmet which protects your head as well as your face from flying blanks (it does happen) and also has hearing protection. This is my preferred protection particularly when starting with an out-of-balance blank. Another risk are mold spores some of which can cause nasty lung problems and these are more prevalent in bark.
Personally, I would not rely on just a DC when sanding without a mask/respirator as well. Some exotic woods such as cocobolo can easily trigger allergic reactions.
I have been using the Harbor Freigth that you mention for about 5 years. I try to watch my expenses on hobbies. I retrofitted a furnace filter from Lowes on the inside just before it enters the bag. I have it fatened withs screws to the sheet metal. I believe that this really helps. I am coming out of the collector with a 4" hose to the lathe into a hood. I use it during turning along with a face shield. During sanding I can move it almost on top of the work. I try to remember to use a dust mask, but many times forget. I have an additional hose that I use as a vacuum going into the collector for clean up. I also have a Jet air filter that I try to remember to turn on. Someday I hope to move the dust collector outside as you mention.
I have an Oneida cyclone unit and an Airstream. I use both of them when I turn. The Airstream is the primary defense against dust, and flying objects and I don't turn the lathe on without it. I use the Oneida for turning and not just sanding, there is as much dust coming off your gouge as your sandpaper.
I have a bag unit and they are good at moving the dust from one location and blowing it out at another, so placing the unit outside would be the right move. They don't stop the dust that harms you, only the particles that your body would stop anyway.
If you want more reading than you care for, you can do a search on this forum and find a wealth of responses to this question. It has been asked more than once. But, it sounds like you are moving in the right direction. When you start looking at scrimping (i.e. cheaping out) on dust control and going with the low end units/helmets, check the price of a lung transplant and that Oneida or Airstream is not so expensive.
If I had to choose between my Oneida and my Airstream, I would go with the Airstream.
I would only use the dust collector when sanding. I have an Onieda, but the HF will also serve you well. The dust collector won't be effective with turning chips so I wouldn't bother with it while turning, just sanding. I also use an full face mask whenever the lathe is on. As mentioned previously, stuff does fly off of the lathe. When sanding I use a Resp-o-rator under the face mask. It's inexpensive and filters the air down to about 1 micron, has no batteries to run down and is lightweight. I don't have any affiliations with any of these companies, just like their products.
I use a Delta DC that's probably very similar to the Harbor Freight model that you mention. I have a 6" diameter main run of sheet-metal piping for about 12' and then I branched down to 4" for another 10' to the lathe. I removed the "Y" from the dust collector inlet port which reveals a 6" diameter inlet. I use it only when sanding, and it does a great job and seems to eliminate the vast majority of sanding dust.
I would highly recommend using a 2' run of Loc-Line (2.5" diameter) at the end near the lathe as this will allow you to position the vacuum hose directly near where the dust can be collected best. I've been using this setup for several years and it works great.
1. Forget about the large shavings. They are a clean-up problem, not a health problem.
2. Regardless of its size, there isn't a home-shop dust collector made that will move enough air to pick up enough of the large shavings and debris to do any good
3. Dust IS a health problem. I will invite anyone who wants to argue this point to come back in 20-years and tell me again that it isn't.
4. A Shop-Vac or similar vacuum-cleaner doesn't move enough air to be of any value.
5. Any dust collector with a 4" suction hose and at least 700 CFM capacity will do a reasonable job of picking up the airborne dust. The more CFM's, the better the job it will do.
The volume of the dust collector will be better utilized by however you choose to collect the dust with the hose. Some kind of an enclosure collects a lot more dust than just holding the end of the hose somewhere near the wood. Go to the link for a picture of how I use licquor boxes to collect dust on the end of the collector hose.
When deciding what to purchase, remember that quality remains long after price is forgotten. Too many times, I have purchased a tool that I thought would be "adequate," to later purchase what I should have gotten in the first place. In the end, I spent more than I would have if had gotten the right tool to start with.
If possible, go with 6 in. ducting/hoses as opposed to 4 in. Strange as it may seem, a 6 in. hose or pipe will carry about 5 times more air at the same pressure pressure as a 4 in. hose (Poiseuille equation).
I have an older HF model, came with 30 micron cloth bags. I would not be happy with 5 micron bags, think you want no more than one or two micron bags. I bought this DC knowing would be replacing cloth bags with canister filter from WYNN Environmental. You can see specs at their web site, very nice people to deal with.
You can Google: Wynnenv.com/35A series cartridge kit.htm
Since live in a humid area bought the #35A100SBOL Cartridge & 10 pack 4 mil poly bag # 1940PB for about $140. Lots of people happy with the less expensive cartridge. Easy set up, putting on lower plastic bags can be a P.I.T.A. but can reuse these bags. I am just now getting into the 10 bag pack. I�ve tried using 32 Gal. Hefty trash bags because someone said could be done. Hefty bags worked well too!
At the time this set up gave me biggest bang for the money. I am not sure this is still true. Only con, DC is loud in a small shop. Had to replace the on-off switch after five years, shipping cost more than the switch.
I use DC both turning and sanding. Am not worried about collecting shavings only the dust generated when turning & sanding.
A better solution to a dust problem is to work on your skills with using the turning tools and using the grinder to get better and sharper cutting edges. And, don't be afraid to use a stone to get a sharper edge and keep it sharper.
There will be less tear-out and smoother cuts when the tools are the correct shape, they are sharper, and you know how to use them properly. That will mean a lot less sanding and starting with a finer grit.
Another factor is the speed of the sander. A slower sander and a slower lathe speed while sanding will mean less dust in the air. This makes it easier to collect the dust and most of it will fall straight down rather than be thrown into the air at high speed where it is more difficult to collect.
And you thought the solution to a dust collection problem was a simple one.
Thank you all very much for you help. Doesn�t look like this will be easy or cheap. I think I may look at the upgraded canister filter for the HF unit , but still vent outside unless running AC.
Also looking at the Trend Airshield pro, looks like its comparable to the Airstream, but not paying for the certifications needed in the workplace. Tying to be safe as possible, within my limited means.
One day my skill may reach the level of producing less dust, but I think dust will be the primary result of my time for a while
Jim, I agree with pretty much everything you have been told.
I have a similar DC made by Delta. A couple of thoughts to add to what you have already read.
I did not realize the fundamental difference (to me) between difference between a Cyclone and a "regular" Dust Collector is that the debris goes through the impeller of the DC and does not in a cyclone. What makes this important to me is that I turn a lot of green wood and get long stringy shavings. On more than one occasion I have had them mat up on the impeller of my unit and have to remove the inlet pipe and pull out a clump of shavings. So, I don't use the collector while turning and use a homemade trash can separator to collect eh stringy stuff before it goes into the DC.
But, I have made no effort to set up the DC to collect the shaving as I turn, because I can't figure out an effective way to do it. I do use it while sanding. I have a four inch hose on the DC that is my general purpose pickup and I bring it up close to the work and hook it up on the banjo, while I sand.
My unit is located outside the shop in a little pump out so that the dust is outdoors, whatever the filter is or is not. Not mentioned by others, I find the impact on the heat and AC to be much less than I expected, but I turn the system on and off as needed. I have a cat door in my shop and when I turn on the DC I see the door get sucked open. My premise is that the air moved from the door, across the work and into the hose, leaving the balance of the air in the shop relatively undisturbed.
And, No matter how Good your DC is or whether you have an air cleaner, none of it is as good as using personal protective gear such as the pressurized mask you mentioned.
I have the HF DC with the Wynn filter system on the advice of Bill Pentz. It is .5 micron cannister and plastic bags below. I also wear the Airstream AS 400 with a air cleaner hanging from the ceiling. Like Russ said it can and will be a health hazard. After several sinus infections and this last winter a bronchial infection which my doc said could lead to emphysema it didn't take me long to change a lot of things as far as dust collection. It isn't fun and won't happen again. The HF DC doesn't do much good as far as chips but it does a really decent job with dust.
There have been a lot of good comments about dust collection strategies. I just wanted to add two points.
First, don't underestimate the value of an air cleaner system. Even the best cyclone system will have a hard time capturing all the dust from your lathe at the source, which means that some dust particles will be floating around your shop. Having a respirator is very good, but unless you leave that respirator on until you leave the shop, you'll still have to deal with the residual dust that is in the air. That's where the air cleaner comes in.
Second, consider this when trying to figure out how much money to budget for your dust management. If you cut corners now, and wind up with a less than optimal dust management strategy, you'll save some money now and can enjoy your hobby. But later on, you may be paying much much much more money for health care, and you won't be able to enjoy your hobby.
..heating/AC system inventory that can be easily adapted to a dust collection system for a small investment. Here is a return collector box that made a great dust hood at the lathe, and is has a screen across the return vent opening to keep out the shavings that would clog the fan housing.
Thanks again for the great advice. I appreciate everyone�s input. From the little turning I have been able to do, I believe I will be doing this awhile (20-30+yrs if I�m lucky) so I want to be smart about it. I think in addition to the DC and Trend Airshield pro mentioned earlier I may look at building a air cleaner to hang from the ceiling. I have a large squirrel cage blower that has been sitting on the shelf for a few years��
Going to pull the 220V to the shop this weekend, one day I may actually get to work in the shop instead of on it
The Trend is not really comparable to the Airstream. It is comparable to the 3M Powervisor, which I also have. Both are rated for nuisance dust, which is what your body will stop. Neither is rated for the submicron level, which is what does the damage.
There is also more than just the filtration level. To get the ratings like the Airstream and the others in that class, the PAPR has to maintain a minimum of 6CFM for the duration of the duty cycle. Both the Powervisor and Trend start off around 6 cfm and drop within a few minutes. This has to do with the size of the nicads they both use and their discharge curve. The Powervisor/Trend use 3 AA and the Airstream uses 4 C size batteries. The Airstream AS400 starts off at 10cfm and takes 9-12 hours to drop down to 6 cfm, which is the end of the duty cycle. The extra CFM is also nice in the Texas heat.
Aside from the filtration, there is also the added benefit of the helmet. After having some pieces of wood explode, I don't think you can have enough body armor around a wood lathe. It is not a matter if something will go wrong, only a matter of when. Neither the Powervisor or Trend offer much protection to the skull.
Thank you, I will have to look more closely. The Lady at Airware America hinted that the �pro� version was comparable in filtering capacity, but could not say so due to the lack of official testing.
...mounted on a piece of conduit, and the base is a steel disc of unknown origin, so it can be easily moved as desired. I have also used lifting weights with a piece of pipe welded in the bar hole, disc brake rotors, all kinds of Rube Goldberg options available there!