Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Rats!

Posts

Rats!

#1

Rats!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Okay. You face-grain hollow form turners chime in here.

I did a closed calabash-type jar in maple. Had a good time getting the curve "fair" as the piece spread out and then nicely tucked in for the base. Hollowed to less that 1/4".

So now the piece has gone oval (face grain always do) but my lovely curve, while still nice from the face, looks like crap from the end grain sides, the form having flattened and distorted (quite evenly though).

How do you guys deal with this? Turn heavy then return when dry?

Re: Rats!

#2

Re:Start to finish in 1 operation Mark,....

JamieDonaldson

...but I don't hollow wood wet enough to spit at me. And 1/4" may not be quite thin enough to be as stable as a 3/16," or slightly thinner on a good day! ;)

Re: Rats!

#3

Re: Rats!

John Veerkamp

Mark,

FWIF I let nature have her way. My experience on this type of orientation, there will always be some warping even if the wood was dry when turned or double turned after drying. The second turned process will have less distortation but still some. Of course the selection of wood also has a large effect.. OO and mesquite almost never move, cherry always does.

John

Re: Rats!

#4

Re: Rats!

Carole Valentine

I almost always do end-grain HFs for that reason. If I am going to do face grain, I either use really dry wood or rough turn, let dry and return. Even then I find that it will move some.

Re: Rats!

#5

Re: Rats!

GaryG in MD

Mark,

John Veerkamp is right about mesquite -- that's why Paul Fennell likes it.

Making them super thin does not necessarily stop the distortion -- but it helps reduce the probability of cracking.

John Jordan is the guy to answer this question -- he turns a lot of green, side-grain forms and lets them oval. Also, in addition to the species, I think the part of the log you take your block from does have an effect. If I remember correctly, you want to stay as far away from the pith as possible -- that certainly helps reduce cracking too.

...Gary

Re: Rats!

#6

Steven Antonucci

Turn them oval and they warp to round

steven antonucci

You could start by going a little thinner, with your laser Kobra and all that gadgetry it should be doable :P

You can also try gently restricting the expansion along the end grain. If I can encourage it in a hat (and get it to stay), reason has it that you should be able to discourage it with similar results.

I just squeezed my hats in a plain old clamp.

S

Re: Rats!

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: Rats!

Steve Kubien

Mark, if I am making an urn-to-be then yes, I rough turn and hollow then allow it to dry. Once dry, I re-turn it.

I wonder if wrapping it tightly in plastic film like saran-wrap or pallet-wrapping-platic-stuff would help?

Re: Rats!

#8

Interesting Concept

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Another tool opportunity! An oval-turning jig for hollow forms.

Have to admit that I probably left the piece a bit thick towards the bottom.

Ah well, "it's only wood."

Re: Rats!

#9

Re: Rats!

Russ_Fairfield

Some of these have already been posted, but here is everything I do for turning green-wood bowls to finished thickness, and the reasons why I do it.

There are advantages to turning a green bowl or other shape to final thickness while it is still green. It takes less time, there will be fewer losses from cracking than when leaving the wood thick enough to re-turn after it is dry, and there is no chance of not leaving enough wood to turn it round after it is dry. The turned wood can also dry in a matter of hours rather than waiting the months required for a thicker rough turned wood. Besides all of that, there is always the possibility that the piece will look better than the perfect uniformity of wood that has been shaped when it was dry.

Some things that might help.

Accenting the curve while it is still green will leave more of the curve after it dries and warps. Yes the shape will be different in different directions, but both shapes will have a good curvature.

As has already been mentioned - Turn it thin. Something between 1/8" and a thin 3/16" is good. A uniform thickness is more important that the actual number, but the thinner it is the less it will warp as it dries.

Make sure to make a smooth and tapered transition into the thicker bottom.

Reduce the thickness on the bottom by cutting the chucking spigot or recess back to the minimum that is required for finish sanding after the wood is dry. Plan to return the chucking spigot because it will no longer be round.

Warping can be reduced,and almost eliminated in very thin wood, by

wrapping rubberbands around it.

Be prepared to power sand the dry and deformed piece at a lathe speed of 100 RPM or less. If the lathe won't go slow enough to sand under power, plan to do the finish sanding with the lathe off.

Re: Rats!

#10

Thanks, Russ

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Several suggestions are doable. I knew the red maple I'm turning would be squirrely as it's coming out from just below a crotch.

Re: Rats!

#11

Once again...

GaryG in MD

Russ,

Thanks for your usual excellent coverage of this subject. Sure glad you're still around. ;) (pun intended)

Even though I'm pretty familiar with these tradeoffs and techniques, you didn't fail to add a new tidbit to my knowledge base (the rubber bands!).

It's always a pleasure to read your thoughtful, detailed, and very knowledgeable commentaries.

Thanks, Gary

Re: Rats!

#12

Re: Thanks, Russ

John Jordan

Well, as you pointed out, the grain was wild because it was near the crotch. If you want to avoid those problems, you have to avoid that sort of wood, too. :) Straight-grain, carefully oriented, in moderately stable woods will generally keep a pleasing curve even though they go a bit oval. I orient my carving/texturing to work with the movement, so it simply is part of the piece. Since I carefully orient/center the wood, the movement is symmetrical.

Avoid getting it too thin, as there is some mechanical strength to a bit of thickness. An otherwise stable wood may "collapse" in spots if made too thin.

John