Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

Posts

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#2

Steven Antonucci

Worth reading

steven antonucci

And along the lines of what I posted before (which was an educated guess)

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#3

Re: Nice to see..

Bill Neddow

the positions of the two actually posted side by side. It makes it a lot easier to understand.

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#4

Getting back to the point of this forum

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We moderators generally don't intervene in the subject matter of threads, unless they violate forum guidelines. Still, I'd like to make some observations:

*The American Association of Woodturners (AAW) is an important professional and craft organization for woodturners in this country.

*The AAW is not woodturning.

*I'm willing to bet that not every turner here is a member of AAW.

*I spent a couple of minutes touring the turning messageboards of the two other woodworking fora that I frequent. The AAW issue is either not present at all or is minimally present.

*The AAW offers its members a forum that appears to work well for discussing the issues that have consumed several threads here in the last couple of weeks. As best I can tell, it's not being censored by anyone, and some comments very critical of the board and the actions it's taken are posted there.

All of which leaves me thinking that these conversations should be happening on the AAW forum or, if that doesn't work for some AAW members, on an AAW-specific forum.

I fear that continued discussion of this issue here is going to interfere with the point of this forum, which is the delicate, entrancing interaction of turner, lathe, tools, and wood, to produce objects that take the breath away; and that it's going to chase some interested and interesting members who aren't AAW members away.

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#5

Re: Getting back to the point of this forum

Colin

Thank you Bill, I live in Europe and am not a member and fed up with seeing all the posts on this sorry episode particularly when the post header doesn't say anything about AAW so you have to open it to find if it is of interest.

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#6

Bill Blasic

Re: Getting back to the point of this forum

Bill Blasic

You know there are 13,000 woodturners who are members of the AAW. I always seem to see Ellis at the symposiums, at least on the East coast. I find it hard to believe that a site that has advertising that helps it stay afloat wants people to go to the AAW website instead of spending time here. This site is my second stop every morning the AAW is the fourth and it would be very easy just to jump over to number four. I do not understand as each entry has a subject line and if you don't want to read just skip over it but don't say hey don't post here. Why cut off your nose to spite your face?

Bill

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#7

Yes, please give it a break.

Norm Smith

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#8

Ric Taylor

Re: Getting back to the point of this forum

Ric Taylor

I agree. This is an issue that applies to dues-paying AAW members. Anyone (myself included) who is a member should have those discussions on the AAW website.

Let's get back to friendly wood turning around here.

Ric

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#9

Re: Back to Where It Belongs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Bill,

If you've been following the several threads on this board, you should know that the AAW situation is a highly charged emotional one, and that Ellis, a usually laid back host here, has taken the unusual step of removing some of them. Time and again, posters here have demonstrated their willingness to devolve into name calling and behaviors on and off this board that are antithetical to why WoodCentral, in all of its various subjects, was founded.

But the issues between the AAW Board of Directors and Mary Lacer and all the good folks lining up on each side of the battlefield, have absolutely nothing to do with turning wood. Those issues are purely internal AAW matters, properly the concern of AAW members, past present, and future. The AAW has established a very sophisticated set of web forums and has dedicated at least one entire section of its site just so AAW members and non-members can discuss, debate, 'opinionate,' comment, and even rant and rail about the entire situation. You should note that posts having to do with the Board/Lacer issues have been banned from the AAW site's "Main Forum" to allow people who wish to actually discuss turning wood (remember that ;) ) to do so.

If you are truly interested in what's going on with the controversy, make the AAW's "AAW Information" forum your third internet stop of the morning; there's a huge amount of stuff being posted there in various threads.

It's one thing to post a neutral notice here about a development, but discussions of the whole thing belong on the AAW board, not here. Ellis and the WC moderators have enough to do on these boards. It's very unfair to put them in the position of having to mediate arguments about internal AAW matters.

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#10

Re: Worth reading

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Please don't ban this topic. There was an early fear that the strife on the AAW forum would be shut down. Although I think that the BOD has made serious mistakes, I congratulate them and their forum moderators for allowing the discussions to continue. The truth still needs to be determined.

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#11

Ellis Walentine

AAW matters

Ellis Walentine

I think we've pretty much aired every possible side of the story by now. I would really prefer that any discussion of the latest developments be handled at the AAW forum. It's okay to post links to important updates here, but every time we get into debating these topics, it turns into a food fight, with erstwhile friends lining up against each other. I'm not sure anyone is equipped to have the last word on anything, certainly not at the present timewith .

When all is said and done, we're all turners here, and the overwhelming majority of you would rather talk about turning than politics, which is what the AAW discussion has become.

Thanks to everyone for your cooperation and understanding. If the AAW site shuts down all discussion, maybe we'll open up an off channel board where concerned parties can resume the debate. Until then, if you want to post a link to a thread on the AAW site, please identify it as such so people who have no interest in this can pass it by.

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine

Host

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#12

Ellis Walentine

It's about politics, Bill

Ellis Walentine

Regardless of how many members the AAW has, only a small percentage of them are regular visitors here (that's too bad) and fewer care about the current controversy. I'm interested but bored to death with the bickering. I'd just as soon see our board go back to its roots and let the AAW handle its public relations issues on its own forum.

Our sponsors are interested in folks who come here for turning discussions, sharing triumphs and failures and being part of a friendly turning community. We have never allowed political discussions on WoodCentral, and the AAW mess has descended to a political debacle. I respectfully submit that it really belongs someplace else. If I thought we could help the situation or inform each other better by debating it ad nauseam, I'd be the first to join in. For now, let's give it a rest. Our advertisers respect us for the way we handle these situations.

Ellis

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#13

Re: It's about politics, Bill

Bernie Weishapl

Ellis a couple of forums that I belong to besides this one has banned any mention of the AAW. If someone starts one it is banned and moved. They feel it is a AAW problem and not theirs. Theirs is to provide a place and atmosphere for woodturning.

Re: Malcolm's response to the board *LINK*

#14

completely agree...

GaryG in MD