The board's response is up *LINK*
David Walser
I haven't read it yet. Here's the link:
http://www.aawforum.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=7596
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
The board's response is up *LINK*
David Walser
I haven't read it yet. Here's the link:
http://www.aawforum.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=7596
Tom Wirsing's statements from the AAW BOD
AndiWolfe
Here is the text of Tom Wirsing's two posts that begin this thread on the AAW forum:
From the AAW Board of Directors
On June 21, 2010 the AAW Board of Directors requested the resignation of Mary Lacer, our Executive Director. This was a difficult decision, and has resulted in some controversy.
Mary Lacer�s Contribution to the AAW
Mary Lacer worked for the AAW for twenty years. She served as the AAW Administrator, and since September 2008 she served as the Executive Director. She is widely known within the woodturning community as a spokesperson, collector and teacher.
The characteristics which make Mary widely known and respected do not necessarily qualify her to be the AAW�s Executive Director.
What were the issues?
The issues which resulted in the Board�s June 21st decision fell into three categories: financial management, business acumen, and clear and complete communications with the Board. Following is one example of an issue in each category:
Financial Management:
The Executive Director is an employee of the AAW and is responsible for the day to day financial management of the association. Members of the Board of Directors are elected by the membership, are volunteers, and are charged with the responsibility of overseeing the financial management of the AAW. The Executive Director produces a monthly financial report for the Board. The reported financial situation has varied from month to month and the Executive Director has frequently been unable to explain the variations to the satisfaction of the Board. Indeed, when our Certified Public Accountants performed their annual audit of the AAW�s 2009 books, their findings showed the ED�s end-of-year report to the Board had understated the AAW�s net income by $182,411. The CPA�s Management Report, which accompanied the audit, stated ��we identified certain deficiencies in internal control that we consider to be significant deficiencies.� These were not the findings of the Board of Directors. These were the findings of Harrington Langer & Associates, Certified Public Accountants, St. Paul, MN. While there was no implication of wrongdoing, the CPA�s findings made it clear to the Board that the Executive Director�s financial management of the AAW was seriously inadequate.
Business Acumen:
On January 18, 2010 the Executive Director signed a Group Sales Agreement with San Jose One Connection for hotels and facilities for the 2012 AAW Symposium in San Jose. AAW Policies and Procedures require the Executive Director to gain approval from the Board of Directors before signing the contract, but the Executive Director signed the contract without Board approval, a violation of the AAW policy. Furthermore, this contract imperils the AAW financially. It requires the AAW to fill a greater number of hotel rooms than we have attained at recent symposia, and imposes penalties on the AAW if we fail to perform. It further authorizes commissions be paid to the AAW�s Conference Coordinators of 10% per room. This means that when an AAW member pays $140 per night for a room within the AAW�s room block, $14 of that $140 goes to the Conference Coordinators. Furthermore, the San Jose Convention Center has two unions which vendors in the Trade Show will be required to deal with, increasing their costs and difficulties in moving lathes and other trade show equipment. The Executive Director, when asked specific questions about the contract, repeatedly misrepresented its terms to the Board of Directors. The contract has placed the AAW in a position in which, if we do not perform, it could result in losses exceeding $100,000. Decisions made by the Executive Director, without the approval of the Board, and in violation of AAW Policies, have made it clear the Executive Director�s business acumen was seriously inadequate. The Executive Director has placed the AAW in considerable financial peril.
Clear and complete communications with the Board of Directors:
The AAW Policies and Procedures state ��the Executive Director may not cause or allow the Board of Directors to be uninformed or misinformed.�
In May, 2009, Alan Lacer, the Executive Director�s husband, applied to be a candidate for the Board of Directors. On May 19, 2009, the Board of Directors held a telephone conference, during which the list of all Board applicants was presented to the Board. Several members of the Board expressed a concern that the membership might regard Alan Lacer�s candidacy as a conflict of interest. Board members are allowed to comment on any applicant, but are not allowed to remove an applicant from the list. Only the Nominating Committee has authority to screen applicants and select candidates. Following the Board meeting, the Executive Director removed Alan Lacer�s application, but did not inform the Board or the Nominating Committee, and apparently did not inform Alan Lacer. After the Nominating Committee screened and interviewed all applicants, Alan Lacer accused the Board of Directors of violating AAW Bylaws by voting to remove him from consideration. The Board was subjected to criticism from the membership. During the AAW�s face-to-face Board meetings in June, 2009, the Board questioned the chairperson of the Nominating Committee as to why the Committee had not processed Alan Lacer�s application in accordance with AAW Bylaws. The Nominating Committee Chairperson stated that the Committee had not received Alan Lacer�s application. The Board then questioned the Executive Director, who admitted she had removed Alan Lacer�s application on her own initiative, and had failed to inform either the Board or the Nominating Committee. The Executive Director knowingly subjected the Board of Directors and the Nominating Committee to criticism from the membership. This seriously compromised the Executive Director�s relationship with Board members, some of whom found it impossible to trust her after such inappropriate behavior.
Other Issues:
There were many other issues. But the issue the Board of Directors found most difficult to deal with was that the Executive Director often declined to take responsibility for her deficiencies. She instead blamed the Board of Directors and others for problems. It is difficult to correct performance problems when the responsible person fails to accept responsibility.
Did the Board of Directors act legally, in accordance with AAW Bylaws and Minnesota law?
The Executive Director, several former Board members, and many AAW members have asserted that the Board�s actions were illegal. The Board of Directors, and the six members of the Board who conferred amongst themselves to plan the transition to a new Executive Director, acted in accordance with the AAW Bylaws and Minnesota law. There is nothing in the AAW Bylaws which prohibits Board members from conferring amongst themselves. Indeed, frequent and continuous conferences amongst board members are characteristics of well-functioning boards of directors. The AAW Board is no different. It has always been this way. The Board meets face-to-face only three times per year. If Board members did not confer continuously amongst themselves, the Board would never get anything done.
Responsibility of the Board of Directors.
The Board of Directors is elected by the membership of the AAW. Directors are volunteers and are not paid for their service to the AAW. Your Board is comprised of intelligent, compassionate and dedicated people. Many have been long term friends of the Executive Director. The Board would not have taken this decision without compelling justification. The Board is charged with the responsibility to protect the interests of the AAW and its members. It carried out that responsibility to the best of its ability. The Board deeply regrets the divisions within the AAW its decision has brought, but the Board stands by its decision.
Tom Wirsing
President
American Association of Woodturners
Please see the following post which contains supporting documentation.
*****
From the AAW Board of Directors
Supporting Documentation:
Minnesota law requires that an employer, when requested to do so, provide, in writing, the reasons for an employee�s dismissal. Following is the document which the AAW provided to the former Executive Director, through her attorney, on July 14, 2010:
Financial Reporting
The American Association of Woodturners� (�AAW�) Bylaws charge the Executive Director, (�ED�), who is a paid employee, with the day to day operation of the AAW, and charge the Board of Directors, who are volunteers, with financial oversight. As the ED, Ms. Lacer was required to provide a monthly financial update for the Board. Ms. Lacer�s reported financial condition of the AAW varied from month to month, with variations in many categories which Ms. Lacer had frequently been unable to explain to the satisfaction of the Board when requested to do so. The AAW Treasurer and another Board member familiar with the AAW�s financial accounting system worked extensively with Ms. Lacer in an attempt to elicit the true state of the AAW finances.
When Harrington Langer & Associates, Certified Public Accountants, St. Paul, Minnesota, performed their annual audit of the AAW�s 2009 financials, they reported differences of $100,000 between what had been reported by Ms. Lacer and their audited financials. There was no implication of any financial wrongdoing, but the realization by the Board that Ms. Lacer�s accounting was seriously inaccurate. Ms. Lacer�s financial reporting failed to meet acceptable standards.
Business Acumen
Ms. Lacer approved a contract for the 2012 national Symposium to be held in the convention center in San Jose, California. She did not gain approval from the Board of Directors to approve the contract, a violation of AAW Policies. The contracts with the convention center and hotels which Ms. Lacer approved without authorization, collectively commit the AAW to performance levels substantially higher than the AAW has attained at any recent symposia, and the contracts include penalties if the AAW fails to meet the performance requirements. As one example, the contract commits the AAW to filling substantially more hotel rooms than it has filled in the recent past. Should all the performance requirements not be met, the AAW could suffer major financial losses.
As another example of numerous other problems with the San Jose contract, Ms. Lacer failed to inform the Board that there are two different unions which the AAW and the vendors will be required to deal with, which will result in higher-than-usual costs for both the AAW and the vendors.
In addition, Ms. Lacer also signed a contract for the Atlanta symposium without the Board�s approval. The Board believes that Ms. Lacer has demonstrated a lack of business acumen in committing the AAW to these contracts.
Inappropriate Actions
In May, 2009, Alan Lacer, Ms. Lacer�s husband, applied to be a candidate for the Board of Directors. On May 19, 2009, the Board of Directors held a telephone conference, during which the list of all Board applicants was presented to the Board. Several members of the Board expressed a concern that the membership might regard Alan Lacer�s candidacy as a conflict of interest. Board members are allowed to comment on any applicant, but are not allowed to remove an applicant from the list. Only the Nominating Committee has authority to screen applicants and select candidates. Following the Board meeting, Ms. Lacer removed Alan Lacer�s application, but did not inform the Board or the Nominating Committee, and apparently did not even inform Alan Lacer. After the Nominating Committee screened and interviewed all applicants, Alan Lacer accused the Board of Directors of violating AAW Bylaws by voting to remove him from consideration. The Board was subjected to angry criticism from the membership. During the AAW�s face-to-face Board meetings in June, 2009, the Board questioned the chairperson of the Nominating Committee as to why the Committee had not processed Alan Lacer�s application in accordance with AAW Bylaws. The Nominating Committee Chairperson stated that the Committee had not received Alan Lacer�s application. The Board then questioned Ms. Lacer, who admitted that she had removed Alan Lacer�s paperwork on her own initiative, and had failed to inform either the Board or the Nominating Committee. Ms. Lacer subjected the Board of Directors and the Nominating Committee to criticism from the membership. This seriously compromised the Ms. Lacer�s relationship with Board members, some of whom found it impossible to trust her after such inappropriate behavior.
Ms. Lacer therefore interfered in the nominating process, and failed to inform the Board of her action until directly questioned by the Board.
In May 2009 Ms. Lacer became aware that the editor had removed the stylized AAW logo from the cover of the American Woodturner. Ms. Lacer interceded with the editor�s associates at the printing company and ordered that the press run of the Journal be stopped. There was no prior discussion or consultation with the editor. Ms. Lacer had no authority to stop the presses. She then ordered that the cover of the American Woodturner be re-designed, an action which again she had no authority to take. The contract which she signed with the editor expressly states the editorial independence of the editor. These actions by Ms. Lacer were highly inappropriate and generated substantial controversy within the AAW community.
After the Board had made its 2009 decisions regarding the offices of Treasurer and Nominating Committee Chair, Ms. Lacer lobbied the Board to change these assignments. This was a clear interference in the Board�s role as the governing body of the AAW, and highly inappropriate behavior for a non-Board employee.
Misinformation to the Board
The contract approved by Ms. Lacer for the San Jose Symposium entitles the Conference Coordinators to receive commissions. The contract contains a clause which commits the AAW to paying the Conference Coordinators (Meetings a la carte) a 10% commission on each hotel room in the AAW block. Based on the $140/night room rate which AAW members will be required to pay, this commission is estimated to be in the range of $32,000 to $40,000. When asked about this clause, Ms. Lacer repeatedly informed the Board that this commission would be returned to the AAW, in clear disagreement with the stated terms of the contract. When the Conference Coordinator was asked to clarify the terms of the AAW�s contract with them, they informed the Board that their contract with the AAW authorizes them to retain the commissions, which, in fact, it does.
Thus, Ms. Lacer misinformed the Board and misrepresented the financial compensation which the Conference Coordinators would be receiving.
In addition, the contract signed by Ms. Lacer which gives the new Conference Coordinators a commission based on the hotel room rate is hardly an incentive for the Conference Coordinators to negotiate the lowest rate possible for AAW members attending the symposium. It was also learned that the Conference Coordinators would receive a 10% commission on any penalties if the AAW failed to meet performance requirements. These two facts reflect a further lack of business acumen on Ms. Lacer�s part, which may lead to higher-than-usual costs for attendees and for the AAW.
In a second example of misstatements, Ms. Lacer advised then-President Haskell in 2009 that there were insufficient funds to support a face-to-face Board meeting in the Fall of that year. President Haskell, following this advice, attempted to cancel the meeting. It was subsequently determined that there were indeed sufficient funds, and the meeting was reinstated. Ms. Lacer misstated to the Board the AAW budgetary situation.
Working Relationships
Ms. Lacer has had poor working relationships with people important to the AAW, including the editor of the Journal, Board members, the former Conference Coordinators, and other woodturning organizations. On several occasions Ms. Lacer displayed insubordinate behavior towards members of the Board during Board meetings.
Conflicts of Interest
When former Board Director Genender resigned from the Board in 2008, Ms. Lacer recommended to then-President Iafrate that her friend, Linda van Gehuchten, be appointed to serve out the unfinished term of Dr. Genender. Ms. van Gehuchten was subsequently appointed to the Board, becoming one of Ms. Lacer�s �supervisors.� This represented a conflict of interest for both parties, as it led to a Board member being beholden to Ms. Lacer for her position on the Board.
Ms. Lacer offered a Board member, one of her �supervisors,� a contract worth approximately $4000. This is inappropriate behavior and also a potential conflict of interest. It is in violation of Board Member�s Code of Conduct and the AAW Conflict of Interest Policy.
Ms. Lacer gave contracts to her husband, Alan Lacer, without Board approval. This gave the appearance of a conflict of interest and violates AAW Policy regarding Asset Protection which states that the ED may not award purchases or other contacts to family members without prior approval of the Board.
It is the Board�s position that Ms. Lacer repeatedly violated AAW Bylaws and AAW Policies and Procedures, acted inappropriately on a number of occasions, repeatedly misstated information to the Board, had some real and apparent conflicts of interest, had poor working relationships with a number of key people, failed to provide satisfactory financial information, displayed poor business acumen and potentially jeopardized the financial health of the AAW.
Supplementary Message from the BOD
David Walser
Since Andi posted the entirety of Tom's message to AAW members, I thought I'd post the text of Malcolm Zander's Supplementary Message from the BOD. It's interesting reading:
Supplementary Message from the AAW Board of Directors
On Friday, July 16th former Executive Director Mary Lacer posted an open letter to the membership on the AAW Forum, describing her view of the events leading up to and since her termination.
There are a number of omissions of fact in this letter, including
-A failure to mention that the former Executive Director was also given a severe warning a year ago, last June, well prior to her January 2010 warning.
-A failure to mention that the former Executive Director demanded two years' salary and benefits as a condition for signing, a demand valued at approximately $150,000, and which the Board rejected as an unacceptable financial burden on the AAW membership. This demand should be weighed against the former Executive Director�s claims of concern for the AAW finances.
-A failure to mention that there is no bylaw giving the executive committee an exclusive right in the evaluation of the Executive Director.
-A failure to mention the closed non-competitive process by which the former Executive Director was appointed to the Executive Director position, a process in which the two resigning members of the Board played a key role. In contrast, this Board intends to hold an open nationwide search and competition for the highest qualified person for the Executive Director position.
-A failure to mention that President Wirsing offered on several occasions to change the wording of Paragraph 13 of the legal agreement presented to the former Executive Director which constrained her employment with the AAW, and that in fact he guaranteed her a demonstrator role in the 2011 St.Paul symposium. It was never the intention of the Board to prohibit her from demonstrating at chapter meetings or regional symposia. Our intention was to prevent her from seeking future employment in the AAW office or on the Board, and this was made clear to the former Executive Director, who still rejected the Board offer. In fact Charles B. Watson has pointed out that the AAW administration has no control over what the chapters wish to organise by way of demonstrations. Please see his two posts on the link at http://www.aawforum.org/vbforum/show...?t=7578&page=8
President Tom Wirsing has now posted an explanation of the reasons for the Board�s actions. In addition to these reasons, subsequent to the dismissal of the former Executive Director, it has been found that the AAW office personnel files frequently lack offer letters, documentation of wage rates, completed I-9 forms, complete job descriptions, annual objectives, development goals or performance reviews. There is no centralized tracking of vacation and sick time used. The human resource management of the former Executive Director does not appear to have met acceptable standards.
The members of the Board have been subjected to a number of misinformed and abusive letters. The membership has been inundated with a series of half-truths and untruths from the former Executive Director�s supporters. Until now we have been unable to present the other side of the story. We endeavoured to manage a dignified quiet retirement process for Ms. Lacer, but this was rendered impossible by the inflammatory postings of her two principal supporters. We are unpaid volunteers, we work long hard hours for the benefit of the membership, and we have no personal or financial interest in the outcome of this event. A number of us have lost some good friends over this decision, but we firmly believe that it was the correct decision and in the long-term interests of the AAW. We have chosen to place the AAW above these friendships. Our only agenda is to make the AAW the best possible organization that it can be. If you have not already done so, please read the other side of the story, now available in President Wirsing's letter of July 18th on the AAW Forum, subsection AAW Information, titled From the AAW Board of Directors.
Re: The board's response
Barb Siddiqui
Well, that has thoroughly ruined my Sunday. My fists are unclenched, my stomach is upset, and now that I'm about ready to launch a wood turning career, I feel like walking away. My only reaction right now is one of depression, and sympathies for all involved.
WHO CARES-JUST LET THE BLASTED THING DIE
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
I am sure there are many that feel the way I do about this. Please end it all. Nobody is going to be a winner. GROW UP!!!
Here because it needs to be somewhere
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I'm not a turner, and know nothing of the issues at AAW; as a moderator, I rarely visit the turning board, focusing on the other boards instead.
But some of the messages on this thread have been demonstrating that not everyone understood Ellis' message of a day or so ago, and I needed to take some action. I've deleted several messages from this thread because, in my judgment, they were personal attacks or likely to lead to a resurgence of the argumentative tone that this subject seems to have created for folks.
Normally, WC is open to conversations related to our craft. But this particular subject seems to call up emotions that make it hard for some people to maintain the civility that is a hallmark of the WC community. It may be an important discussion; perhaps someone who feels strongly about having a setting in which to discuss it can create a Facebook group for the discussion, or find some similar alternate venue.
Re: The board's response is up
Fred Bond
Tom's letter was excellent in clarifying the causes for terminating the administrator. I believe that any board in business or in a not-for-profit organization would have taken similar action under the circumstances.
The board might have handled it with less shock value but their action seems to have been justified.
Let's move on and not allow AAW to suffer because of this unfortunate incident.
agree...
GaryG in MD
SO WHY DID YOU LEAVE THIS POST ?????
LGuthrie
GROW UP ????
Many of us care -- a LOT.
Brad Vietje
Ken,
I know everyone wants this issue resolved, but resolution it will take. Unfortunately, it won't just blow away like a leaf in the wind, and there's a lot of passion out there because these are people --real people with feelings as well as the human imperfections we all have. There is a lot of healing yet to happen, and only those directly involved can make it happen, so we should let them do their work and get back to turning wood. It is not helpful to hurl insults about -- there are many on this forum that care deeply about the Lacers and the other people involved, who may feel awful about what has happened. Their grief is real, and it's only human to express it.
I agree we don't need to hash and re-hash every move, motion, vote, and phone call here, but the actors in this drama will all have their work cut out for them to resolve this before the anger and the distrust subsides.
Like Ellis says, let's hope cooler heads will prevail.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
...wishing I had some free time to turn something...