Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

need new tool and new measuring gauge

Posts

need new tool and new measuring gauge

#1

need new tool and new measuring gauge

John Lucas

I tried to turn a small hollow form the other night but wanted a little different shape with a recessed top and small opening. The tool I used to hollow just under the rim won't reach far enough to go to the upper corners. The tool I used to do the bottom and part way up the sides won't reach any deeper than you can see. Unfortunately it will reach deep enough to cut through the bottom. This vessel is about 4" wide and about 2" thick.

That's where I found out that I needed new measuring gauges. I simply could not get in and read the wall thickness on the sides at all. Consequently after I ruined it I cut it in half and will sit down in the next week or so and design some new tools and measuring devices that will get into those areas.


Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#2

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

John, This is an excellent photo and a great learning opportunity. I looked at this picture carefully and for a long time...thinking about the strokes, tools, and approach that might have been used to avoid the "breakthrough"...(making me think is no easy task! :) ), so here I thank you and encourage you (and others) to continue posting these learning opportunities as well as your successes.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#3

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

Stanley Townsend

John this is the kind of turning I had in mind when designing the Elbo tool. It has a rotatable cutting tip as well as depth control along with careful setting of the laser you can turn this kind of and size of vessel with precision. Take a look at www.elbotool.com

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#4

Steven Antonucci

Bottom is easy- use a bowl gouge!

steven antonucci

If I can reach it with a gouge, that's what I do! I like the positive registration of the bevel on the inner wall. Getting the curlies out can be a little tricky, but it's pretty hard to cut through the wall at a point like that.

As for the undercut, I use smaller diameter rods because I have more clearance in the entry hole and I can get them in very steeply. A slightly longer cutter helps too.

steve

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#5

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

John Lucas

Stanley I could do this shape on a larger size using my captured bar system and a laser. I suppose I could build the small tools and adapt them to the captured bar system and do it but I don't do these often enough so I just tried using my homemade hand held tools.

I have made boring bars down to 1/2" in diameter that all fit the big system. I keep looking at the Elbow tool, Monster tool, and Kobra. They sure look great and apparently do a good job. So far I'm able to do all I do with my system.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#6

I didn't think about my Hunter tools

John Lucas

I have some curved hunter tools with small shafts that might reach into a space like this. I'll try them on my cut in half version and see if they would work.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

Lyle Jamieson

Great outside shape. I have built many tools with Michael Hosaluk adapters to reach any shape I want. Like for my Christmas ornaments. I can hollow out a Christmas ornament ball to 1/16 wall thickness in 42 seconds. When you are doing 100 of them its nice to have the laser and supported system. Makes it easy on my body. Here is a photo of a piece I did in 1996 after first designing my system. I wanted to prove to myself that I could get into a small hole and undercut a shoulder that came back onto itself. This is 9 inches tall, 5 inches diameter and a uniform 1/16 inch wall thickness. Sorry Im not going to cut it in half to show you�trust me :-)


Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#8

Re: But Lyle, now show us the tools!

JamieDonaldson

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#9

Joe Fleming

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

Joe Fleming

The trick with any of these endeavors is not having a tool with the correct orientation to perform the cut. It is having a tool that can successfully enter and exit the vessel and still do the cut. I still wonder how David Ellsworth makes undercut tops through that tiny opening. There just is not much room for tool articulation.

I'll be interested in your Hunter tool experience per our previous conversation.

Joe Fleming

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#10

Steven Antonucci

Start and stop the lathe with the tool inside

steven antonucci

If you place the tool inside so that the straight part is in the opening (whatever bent shape is already in space), you can turn the lathe on and off with no risk of blowing things up from an entry mistake. Patience is the key.

From what I recall, David has a bent rod that is less than 90 degrees for the undercut. Doesn't take much of bend past 90 degrees, but it probably takes a few different lengths and bends to accomodate every situation.

Measuring is a lot harder...

S

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#11

Steven Antonucci

trust me on the bowl gouge

steven antonucci

once I get the transition point in the curve hollowed, I do the entire lower form with a bowl gouge. It's so fast in smaller forms, it's funny.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#12

Hunter "back hook"

GaryG in MD

John, The area under the rim is exactly what the new Hunter "back hook", designed by Mark St. Leger, is for. I almost (and should have) bought one in Hartford. It has a hook shaped shaft witha #1 cutter set at just the perfect angle for doing this. ...Gary

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#13

Re: trust me on the bowl gouge

john lucas

Steve I've used a bowl gouge for that but the Hunter tool has a steeper bevel that allows me to reach into the bottom easier. Of course I'll use whichever one works for particular project.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#14

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

john lucas

I have an idea about both hollowing and measuring but won't have time to try it out until Sunday. I may be able to rig up a mock piece out of cardboard to see if the idea has merit.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#15

Re: Start and stop the lathe with the tool inside

steve worcester

Davids measuring tool is a "C" shape (sort of) bent piece of soft rod, copper or brass, that gets rebent for each spot you want to measure.

Cutting the hemisphere hollow forms, I have found that it make take two or three tools to cut the underside of the top (I have a Hunter small swan neck and it won't work) and lately have used a torch to bend McNaughton tools around into a question mark sort of shape. The 3/8" ons when are easy to bend, but the cutter head splits when heated (not a big deal) but chatters alot hung off the tool rest real far.

I would love to see the new Hunter, but I don't see it on his site.

I have modified many of the Jamieson swivel heads, but with all of them you have to take a light cut because the tip being bent back towards the tailstock causes a lot of vibration. The other issue with them is the swivel is just too big if you want to manipulate around holes under 3/4" in diameter. The tools end up looking like contortionists.

If you come up with a measuring device, I'm in.

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#16

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

Wood Spinner

I have used Stanleys tool for years and love it. I have made special tools for it and find it to be very flexable in use. YOU MEST KEEP ALL OF THE BOLTS AND NUTS SNUG OR YOU WILL GET CHATTER.

I find the longer I turn the better I get at visualizing where the cutting tip is.The sound of the wood as it cuts, the just seeing the cutter in your minds eye and the feel of the cutter in your hands all come with time.

Patience Patience and more patience. If the balance ot the finished product feel good and you can not see or feel into the piece it is well done. Only ones personal satisfaction of the piece determines its quality to you

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#17

Lyle Jamieson

Re: But Lyle, now show us the tools!

Lyle Jamieson

The main advantage comes from the swivel assembly. With the infinite range of movement you can reach any shape you want. Its just a matter of patience. Put the cutter in and cut a small section. Take the cutter out and move the swivel to another angle and cut another small section and repeat, and repeat, and repeat. The smaller opening tools are just a series of smaller boring bars with a HSS cutter CA glued in at different angles. Dedicated angle cutters are a pain. They work most of the time but there is just that one shape you want to do that they will not reach, as John experienced. That is where the swivel advantage comes in.

The photo is a sampling of some of my boring bars. All are used in the supported system with the laser measuring aid. The three on the right are my standard boring bar with the three possible configurations of my swivel assembly. The 1st is straight in, the 2nd is the small bent tool holder, and the 3rd is the big bend configuration. All three of these use the same boring bar with different tip options. The rest are not commercially made but easy to make, home built. The one on the left is actually a file tang bent and sharpened for a specific project. The 4th from the right is my main tool for Christmas ornaments. Note the Hosaluk adapter is still on it. With a drill and the CA glue you can make any shape, any size, boring bar you can imagine.


Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#18

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

Ralph E Watts

John,

That looks like some of my early attempts at a similar shape. ;-) The Munro Hollower fixed the problem. Now I can mount it in my Kobra hollowing system and set the laser for any wall thickness and the Munro will reach around the corner.

(another excuse for a new tool?)

Best regards, Ralph

Re: need new tool and new measuring gauge

#19

If you are going to make a tool

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I would suggest that you give up the idea of shaft diameter, and think instead of width and height of the approach angle into the opening, which is an ellipse.

The stiffness of a tool shaft is squared by doubling its height. It is easy to knock off the corners of a rectangular bar, and get close enough. I found that my smaller rounds tend to resonate with the changing grain directions then snag, which is less likely with a stiffer shank.

My feeler gage is like a figure 8, but each of the 4 legs out from the pivot is shaped different. One leg is almost straight, with a little kink at the end. The next a little more bent, and so on. If you are feeling for the thickness of any point along the side of a sphere, both tips need to touch each side at a perpendicular to a tangent to read the same on the opposite end to be accurate.

Also, each leg is marked off with 1" increments, as are my tools that I stick into the openings. This way, if I feel a small rib at 4.5" in from the opening, when I stick the tool in after feeling the sides, I know I am on the exact rib at 4.5" in that I was feeling with the gage. I feel the rib with the tip of the cutting edge, then move pivot the tool over the rest, then touch the foot switch with my toe, and pivot right back over onto the rib knowing exactly where I am.