Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Second Lathe

Posts

Second Lathe

#1

Second Lathe

Nicholas Tuzzolino

All this talk about a second lathe, vortex, etc got me to thinking.

I have a Powermatic 3520 and am looking at the Penn State 10" variable speed Commander just for pens, stoppers, etc. Any Variable Speed Commander owners out there? It is $299. It has a 1x8tpi headstock thread so I need no extras. Any pros or cons?

Re: Second Lathe

#2

Re: Second Lathe

Allen Neighbors

Two of my friends here in town have TCPs. One is VS one is not. The friend w/the non-VS wishes his was. The guy with the VS is happy with his lathe. The slowest speed on the vs is slower than my Little Vicmarc, but is still not really slow.

Re: Second Lathe

#3

As an option

Jack Savona

Won't some adapters allow your 3520 to do everything the smaller 10" lathe would do? A few hundred extra dollars would permit a few more exciting new tools, pen kits, pen mandrels or accessories in the budget, wouldn't it?

Unless, you really want a second lathe....

Re: Second Lathe

#4

Re: Second Lathe

John Lucas

I have a 3520 but like to turn my small items on my mini lathe because it's so much easier to move the tool rest, banjo and tailstock. I have a Nova Comet which they don't make anymore. The reason I bought it was because it could be ordered with 1 1/4"x8 or 1" x8 thread. My big lathe then and now has 1 1/4" x 8 so that was really nice.

I think some manufacturer who makes good quality mini lathes should listen and offer that again. they could sell quite a few to people who have larger lathes but like the small ones for traveling or doing small work.

I'm going to build a custom adaptor for my Carbo-tec will change it from 3/4"x16 to 1 1/4"x8. This would fit right over the other thread and not increase the length of the spindle like a 1"x8 to 1 1/4"x8

Re: Second Lathe

#5

Re: Second Lathe

BillJacksonville, NC

I bought a 6" comfort rest 16-18" swing for my jet 16-42 from packardwoodworks. Sold my Jet 1014 mini! I needed room in my shop.

Re: Second Lathe

#6

Re: Second Lathe

bob davis

i think the commander would fit thr bill. i use my mini a lot

Re: Second Lathe

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Second Lathe

Dick Hines

I have a PM 3520 and a Jet mini. I can't remember the last time I used the Jet. Everything I turn is on the PM. Bottle stoppers,pens,small boxes, large bowls and hollow forms. The height of the PM makes my back feel better after a day in the shop.

Before someone ask, no I don't want to get rid of the Jet. The guy with the most tools wins.

Re: Second Lathe

#8

don't ask me, I have three

Ralph Lindberg

A Nova DVR, a Jet 1014 and a Treadle.

But I do agree with the idea of (room and budget allowing) to have a big lathe and a small one.

IMO, you really don't need a VS for the small one, if all you are going to do is pens, bobbins, etc. As you just are turning those fast any way.

Re: Second Lathe

#9

THANKS

Nicholas Tuzzolino

Thanks for all the input and food for thought.

Re: Second Lathe

#10

Look at the new Delta

Jerry Hall

I found the Penn State VS on my Jet Mini prone to overheating, and having to be reset. They replaced the controller once. Took 30 days. But it still overheated when worked hard.

I am very happy with the new Delta 12" 46-460 as a companion to my Powermatic which replaced the Let and Penn State VS. I use it all the time when doing multiples that require different setups, and for teaching and traveling. At $600 I would get the Delta in a heartbeat over the Penn State. All that said I doubt pen turning is going to overheat Penn State lathe.

Re: Second Lathe

#11

Re: Second Lathe

Greg Burnard

I have a Commander 12" variable speed on order. Been taking the Jet mini south for a couple years and leaving the rest in the shop. I think I'll be happy with the 12".