more bowl critic
John Lucas
This bowl was from the other half of the log I used on the last critic. Box Elder, about 6 1/2". I cut away more from the pith area so it wouldn't warp as much but it still bothers me. I guess I'm a twice turned guy. Dry bowls don't move.
This is a much more user friendly shape and shows the spalting better. The inside is perfect but the outside flattens just a hair as round the corner going toward the foot. You can feel it more than you can see it.
I left the lip sort of undefined and rounded over to just see how it would look. Your eye definitely doesn't go there so if you want a lip to not distract from the rest of the piece this would probably work.
I think the foot is too long although it only looks that way when you get down this low. I'm not sure about the size of the foot compared to the lip. It's probably about right for a user bowl, might be a little large for an "art" bowl.



