Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

BOD election suggestion (strawman)

Posts

BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#1

BOD election suggestion (strawman)

Ray - Middletown, IN

Perhaps if there were a list of questions that could be presented to the candidates then invite them one at a time to a moderated chat session for their response. A group of people who create an agreed upon list. Range of topics. Group made up of both sides of the isle. Agreed upon time limit.

Have at it guys.

Ray

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#2

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

Ed Davidson

Ray, that was kind of tried last year on the AAW forum. Some candidates responded and some did not. Not everyone is comfortable with a keyboard, internet use or forum posting. Guess that makes me a nerd :\

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#3

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

George Guadiane

It seems like a good idea, why not ask the candidate to find a computer savy volunteer to do the typing for them?

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#4

An unwillingness to participate online

Ray - Middletown, IN

speaks volumes to me. Like it or not the internet is the mass communication media of the day, get used to it. The bio's that are usually posted is simply inadequate to make an informed choice. I don't know any of the current board nor any of the proposed candidates. If I have to make a choice based on the posted bio's I will just toss the ballet.

Ray

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#5

Re: An unwillingness to participate online

Ed Davidson

Ray,

In regard to your comment "Like it or not the internet is the mass communication media of the day, get used to it." Here's a fact to consider - at any given time, about 40% of the email addresses AAW has on file from its membership, are invalid, probably due to the members not keeping their personal records up to date. Another 20% or so do not have an email address listed. To say "get use to it" ignores AAW demographics, and is not a realistic view of the world we live in...just my opinion.

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#6

Sorry Ed

Ray - Middletown, IN

I didn't mean to come across as that big an a-hole. (Wife read it and gave me double hockey sticks) But I still think there has to be a better way for candidates to put across their thoughts and ideas besides a short bio. I have no doubt your numbers are very accurate but that still leaves a very large segment of folks online to participate in some kind of dialog.

Ray

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#7

Re: An unwillingness to participate online

Juergen

You're probably right about technology use and knowledge of the typical AAW member. The point is to be an effective executive/leader/manager in todays environment, knowing how to leverage technology is as basic as communication, inter-personal, and leadership skills. These skills should be a an essential component in the search for a board member or an ED. This is especially true in a situation where a board meets only a few times a year and there is a small supporting staff to take up the slack.

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#8

Re: An unwillingness to participate online

Sean Troy

If someone is running for the board and they use the EXCUSE they are not computer savvy, they have no business running for the board. A lot of board work is done on the computer. It also speaks volumes about them and not in a good light.

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#9

Re: An unwillingness to participate online

Ed Davidson

Sean,

IMHO, that's just not right on so many levels - if a new AAW Board member needs help, we (the staff and volunteers) do everything we can to help them get it. And, to exclude those who are not computer or internet savvy, or just not comfortable participating in a forum like this, would leave out 60% plus of the membership from participating in the process. All AAW members should be welcome and encouraged to run for office if they are inclined to do so.

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#10

Re: An unwillingness to participate online

Sean Troy

Hi Ed, I was a Board member and know how much work has to be done on the computer by each board member. Each board member is a committee member of at least two different committees and they have to be able to do a lot of e-mailing, reports and use AAW software. How can someone who refuses to learn computers be able to do the job they ran for? Once on the board is not the time to start learning how to use a computer. That is not fair to the other board members or general membership.

Not using a computer is an excuse or just plain lazy in this day and age. My mother is 86 years old and uses a computer every day. My daughters were proficient at computers at 4 years old. How can a board member who is not comfortable participating in an online forum be of any use to anyone? Using a computer is a huge part of being a board member. I just don't see your point. Some people are just not cut out to do certain jobs. It's not putting them down; there are lots of other ways to be involved without computer savvy, just not on the board if they are to be the least bit effective. Sean

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#11

Re: An unwillingness to participate online

Juergen

Ed you'll notice it said "technology" not a keyboard. It is essential to understand what tech is available and how it can be used to your or the organization's benefit.

Re: BOD election suggestion (strawman)

#12

Re: Computer Savvy

Ron McKinley

I have to agree with Sean. The Presidents of two clubs I belong to are not computer savvy and they are left out of the whole process. The Vice-Presidents run the meetings and the Presidents look confused the whole meeting. They are completely ineffective...Ron