Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Posts

My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#1

My opinion on the AAW controversy.

RussFairfield

You can call me a crazy old man if you wish, but this is my opinion of the present AAW controversy.

I have nothing against either of them personally, but I am getting tired of the continued ranting and raving by the two former AAW Directors who lost to a majority of the Board who had the intestinal fortitude to take them to task and take control of the AAW. And, I am getting tired of listening to those of you who want us to believe everything they have to say. So far we have only heard one side of the story, and so far you have proven yourselves to either be totally ignorant of AAW history, refuse to admit your part in making that history, or you have a hidden ajenda that you aren't sharing with us.

Where were you 2 years ago when these same two Directors were among the minority who fired the professional who had been the Executive Director for the previous 3 years during the most rapid growth in the history of the AAW, and then appointed Mary Lacer to the job? Two years ago you said nothing of an action by a minority of the Board, but now you are the loudest of those who condemn an action of a 6 to 2 majority of the present Board. This time it was their turn to lose to a majority of the Board who had reason to believe that the AAW had lost its direction and was floundering its way towards destruction. Maybe the previous guy needed to be fired, but it wasn't done by a majority of the Board at the time, and it wasn't done very professionally.

I see you as trying to destroy the AAW as we have come to know it with your continuing campaign of half truths and outright lies. That makes me wonder what your agenda really is.

And this is the last that I will ever say about this topic. I will continue to support the present Board of Directors in their efforts to save the AAW and continue its growth as an organization that serves all of its members.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#2

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

bill crommett from Seneca

Russ: If this means that you will be following your own advise, GOOD !

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#3

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Malcolm Tibbetts

Russ, I am very surprised at your one-sided view of the Mary Lacer termination. You are certainly entitled to form your own view, but I have to strongly disagree with a few of your assertions.

First you say, �I am getting tired of the continued ranting and raving by the two former AAW Directors who got caught with their hands in the cookie jar.�

Are you publicly accusing me of some wrong-doing? What do you mean by that statement?

You wrote, �Where were you 2 years ago when these same two Directors were among the minority who fired the professional who had been the Executive Director for the previous 3 years during the most rapid growth in the history of the AAW, and then appointed Mary Lacer to the job?�

For the record, President Bill Haskell and V.P Malcolm Tibbetts were members of the Executive Committee (pres, vp, treasurer, sec). That committee has a long standing responsibility to review employee performance and make recommendations to the entire board. Larry Sommer was incredibly ineffective as an ED; he had almost nothing to do with the growth of which you speak. Yes, I was part of a committee that recommended his dismissal, but that action was put before the entire board and if I�m not mistaken, his dismissal was supported the entire board. You have presented a very gross distortion of the situation. Regarding the appointment of Mary Lacer, it was thoroughly discussed by the entire board and the entire board agreed with the decision. Again, let me state, I did not appoint Mary Lacer; I was but one board member who supported the decision. Unfortunately, the Executive Committee was kept �out of the loop� regarding the decision to fire Mary Lacer � a clear violation of association procedures and past practices.

You wrote, �Maybe the previous guy needed to be fired, but it wasn't done by a majority of the Board at the time, and it wasn't done very professionally.�

How do you arrive at this opinion? Larry Sommer was not blind-sided by a conspiracy. He was given very poor performance reviews. He simply failed and should not have been hired in the first place (I opposed his hiring). With hindsight, this hiring mistake cost the membership possible as much as $200,000 and a lot of wasted time in our association�s development. There was nothing unprofessional or unethical about his dismissal. I�ve heard that this comparison is currently being promoted during phone calls by current board members as a way to defend their actions. It�s a very weak attempt to do so.

Russ, I don�t know who has poisoned your mind with regard to the current AAW situation, but as I�ve heard many times, there are three sides to every story. Do you really feel okay with looking the other way? Are you okay with sweeping this under the carpet? I have no personal agenda in this and I�ve never been caught with my hand in the cookie jar. A dare say that I was in a much better position to report on the recent behavior of the AAW board.

You can say that this is the last thing you have to say in the matter, but I and others are far from going away quietly.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#4

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Stuart Johnson

Why did you feel the need to make one final statement on the issue that did nothing but show your bias toward the current BOD and their decision. In my opinion your message is nothing more than sticking your head inside the door and yelling fire.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#5

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Bob Rosand

If you want to talk about the history of the AAW, maybe we should look at some of the contributions Mary has made over the 20 years plus that she has been involved with the AAW. As I pointed out in another post, Mary ran the AAW out of her living room for a period of time when the AAW almost went out of existence. How may of us would have done that? Board members float in, serve their terms and then disappear. Mary has been a constant and in my opinion a positive one. Even if it was time for her to retire, she deserved much better treatment than this.

Malcolm and Bill, you have my full support. Thank you for all you are doing.

Bob Rosand, former board member

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#6

You Crazy Russ?

Stephen Mushinski

Russ,

You certainly are not crazy!

One thing about the constant posts that is ironic - the information that has come out changed my mind 180 degree's. Post meant to sway me in the opposite direction.

When I first read the announcement I thought to myself I do hope Mary is OK and there is no health reason for stepping down. Yes I know - boy am I naive. Then I get a phone call to look at Malcolm's post on the AAW forum. Then I was thinking - this is not right Mary is such a wonderful lady.

Then the posts start flying.

The rumors I heard, about Larry being removed and not resigning, as the AAW membership was told, were true. I can only imagine that the reasons I was told at the time were also correct. He was out spoken about the way things were being run and about how the BOD were chosen and eliminated before they were even allowed on the ballot. Seems conflict of interest charges are placed upon some but not all AAW members that might benefit from being on the board. Basically, good luck running for he board unless you are connected in the first place.

I didn't know that only 4 of the board members became the majority instead of 5. So unless I am mistaken a majority of 6 of 9 have committed a terrible mistake but a minority of 4 of 9 were just looking out for the best interest of the AAW.

What I see is a very caring thoughtful person in Malcolm coming to the aid (rescue) of a very dear friend. He hired Mary to the ED position and there is no way that was a mistake no matter what anyone else has to say. Mary's has ran the AAW for all these years and for Malcolm there is no one else capable to do so. But as things have grown from 5000 to 14000 much has changed. It was deemed at some point an independent Director was needed, void of friendships, influence, and history (good and bad). With what is happening right now this might be a good thing!

If I had a time machine Mary would be back looking after the day to day operation of the AAW. A independent Executive Director and the BOD would deal with the politics of running a 1.6 million dollar business. Mary could have said when asked to take the ED position - no thank you I prefer to say doing what I am doing.

I also believe that no organization should have the same person running it for almost 20 years no matter just how good and wonderful they are.

This is my first post on this issue as members of WC and the AAW that I think so very highly about differ on what I think. Their wisdom and experience trumps my 10 fold which makes me question my thinking. I could be wrong but just maybe I am not to far out to lunch. As with everything the truth lies somewhere in between.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#7

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

RussFairfield

If I am wrong, then I am not alone, and the reason is that the lack of communication with the membership is something that the BOD has been ignoring since the beginning of the AAW. The only time we ever hear from a Director is after they have lost an election, quit for personal reasons, or retired.

Controversy on the Board is nothing new. I have always complained that too many of the Board were quitting immediately after the election, and that the remaining BOD members were appointing their replacements. Some were quitting for personal reasons, but several were asked to quit by the other members of the BOD because they were caught using their positions for personal gain. The others may have had ligitimate reason for their resignation, but their timing was terrible. Sometimes those appointments to fill the vacancies were from those who had lost the previous election, but all too often they were prior Directors who had either quit, retired, or were voted out of office, or someone who had never run for the position.

Something has to be done. The AAW may have to consider compensation for its Board. Their doing nothing has made the elections a joke for most of us. The present Board is the first in many years that I know and have voted for 3 of it's newest members.

I may be mistaken, but I see the present BOD has having the most professional managerial experience of any that I can remember. Prior boards were always controlled by well known woodturners who were elected because the larger number of the members knew who they were. This one has experience in management. Whether we agree with them or not is a personal option.

Someone said that only 10% of the membership bothered to vote in the last election. How many of you who are doing all of the complaining were a part of that 10%, or are you among the 90% who didn't bother to vote. I suggest that you vote for those who agree with you for the next election. Maybe you should run for office if you are serious about changing the AAW to your way of thinking.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#8

Re: You Crazy Russ?

Malcolm Tibbetts

Steve, I�ll �copy and paste� from my previous posting, �Regarding the appointment of Mary Lacer, it was thoroughly discussed by the entire board and the entire board agreed with the decision. Again, let me state, I did not appoint Mary Lacer; I was but one board member who supported the decision.�

Once more, this is not personal. Of course I know Mary Lacer; as a board member, I worked with her for over five years. Even it there was justification for the termination by �the six�, which in my opinion there was not, their method of orchestrating her removal, is indefensible.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#9

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Malcolm Tibbetts

Russ, just to make it clear, I was not recruited to run for the board because of my woodturning skills or woodturning reputation. I did however have 30 years of managerial experience with over 1500 employees under my wing. I have a lot of experience with the hiring and firing of employees.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#10

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

RussFairfield

I said what I did because not everyone agrees with you, and I thought that I was still entitled to express my opinion on WoodCentral. Please tell Ellis if you don't agree with that..

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#11

Re:It is true that for too many.......

JamieDonaldson

...years the AAW membership has delegated surrogates to tend to the business of running the AAW, but when something goes terribly wrong it is time to jerk our heads out of the sand and cry foul! This whole sorry episode is detrimental to all parties, and when elements of the BOD secretly act to exceed the mandate of the membership for personal agendas, then it is time for the membership to take action, and resolve the errors and injustices for sake of the good name of the AAW.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#12

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

George Guadiane

Not everyone agrees with you either. In fact, it seems like many more people think that this was poorly handled, REGARDLESS of whether the firing was righteous or not. And of them, most (if you want to count) feel like Mary might have, probably, almost certainly and undoubtedly got railroaded. Things were starting to quiet down, we are getting closer to the time when Mary will have made a decision on how to proceed with her life. Your posts have really done little more than fan the glowing embers back into the raging flames of the same fire.

As I started telling my sister (who I know loves me); "Sometimes helping isn't helping" and "Do you want to help? ... Then don't help. You're not helping.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#13

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Stuart Johnson

Russ, you have every right to your opinion plus a good number of WC member stated they want you to post your opinions. I agree. I also feel I have a right to state my opinion and that opinion was stated in my prior post. I fail to see why you feel there is a need for me to contact Ellis about your right to post.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#14

Say What!

Ron Sardo

Russ

There has been rantings and insightful posts coming from both sides of this story. Reading the last few threads you started on this topic I'm a bit surprised by your comments.

Russ said:

AAW Directors who got caught with their hands in the cookie jar

I'm hoping you mean something entirely different by this because where I come from it sounds like you are accusing someone of stealing.

I think it would be best if you clarified yourself.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#15

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Ron Sardo

George Guadiane wrote:

Not everyone agrees with you either. In fact, it seems like many more people think that this was poorly handled, REGARDLESS of whether the firing was righteous or not. And of them, most (if you want to count) feel like Mary might have, probably, almost certainly and undoubtedly got railroaded. Things were starting to quiet down, we are getting closer to the time when Mary will have made a decision on how to proceed with her life. Your posts have really done little more than fan the glowing embers back into the raging flames of the same fire.

I hate it when I agree with George :D

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#16

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

RussFairfield

For some reason I cannot bring up the original message to make a correction or delete it, so this one will have to do unless Ellis can erase the original.

Many have taken my "hands in the cookie jar" statement the wrong way, so I am removing it. I am not accusing anyone of doing anything for personal gain or stealing from the AAW. I am only disagreeing with all of the BS that has been posted by those who would rather destroy the AAW than correct a problem.

The way I meant the message to read is as follows.

You can call me a crazy old man if you wish, but this is my opinion of the present AAW controversy.

I have nothing against either of them personally, but I am getting tired of the continued ranting and raving by the two former AAW Directors who (removed phrase) lost to a majority of a Board who had the intestinal fortitude to take them to task. So far we have only heard one side of the story, and so far the most active writers have proven themselves to either be totally ignorant of AAW history, refuse to admit their part in making that history, or they have a hidden ajenda that they aren't sharing with us.

Where were you 2 years ago when these same two Directors were among the minority who fired the professional who had been the Executive Director for the previous 3 years during the most rapid growth in the history of the AAW, and then appointed Mary Lacer to the job? Two years ago you said nothing of an action by a minority of the Board, but now you are the loudest of those who condemn an action of a 6 to 2 majority of the present Board. This time it was their turn to lose to a majority of the Board who had reason to believe that the AAW had lost its direction and was floundering its way towards destruction. Maybe the previous guy needed to be fired, but it wasn't done by a majority of the Board at the time, and it wasn't done very professionally.

I see you as trying to destroy the AAW as we have come to know it with your continuing campaign of half truths and outright lies. That makes me wonder what your agenda really is.

And this is the last that I will ever say about this topic. I will continue to support the present Board of Directors in their efforts to save the AAW and continue its growth as an organization that serves all of its members.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#17

Ellis Walentine

Let cooler heads prevail

Ellis Walentine

>Why you couldn't delete your earlier post is a mystery, Russ, unless you checked in with another identity. Editing messages is only available for two hours, as currently configured.

In accordance with your wishes, I have removed the offending phrase from your original post. Thank you for helping us to keep this conversation a little more civil.

I do take issue with your other assertion, though, about Bill and Malcolm having hidden agendas to "destroy the AAW." I think it would be good to refrain from all accusations regardless of how logical they seem to you. For one thing, you're speculating, and for another, being alarmist without facts is only provocative, not useful in any meaningful way.

For what it's worth, I suspect that all the directors, past and present, have an abiding interest in seeing the AAW continue to grow and prosper, though they may not view things the same way. Disagreements and resignations are as common as personnel decisions in the world of business, and for-profit or not, the AAW is a business, constituted with an executive committee and a board. If the bylaws need to be changed and better communication and transparency instituted, so be it. But, vilifying any of the parties involved isn't getting us any closer to a frank and open discussion of the underlying issues, including the AAW's mission and strategic plan.

I am happy to lend the auspices of this forum to an airing of the issues, but unless we tone down the vitriol, it's going to be difficult to get constructive discussions going. Maybe we need to have a moderated chat or something, though I hesitate to intercede in what the AAW may consider their proprietary business. Obviously, these issues mean a great deal to our visitors as well, since most of us are AAW members, too.

I'm just trying to do anything I can to give these issues some breathing room. If you have any suggestions, please let me know.

Ellis

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#18

ynank you mr cooler head!!!

bob davis

ellis

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#19

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Malcolm Tibbetts

Russ, you seem to continue to want to have the last word in this. You make statements like," I see you as trying to destroy the AAW as we have come to know it with your continuing campaign of half truths and outright lies. That makes me wonder what your agenda really is.�

What �half truths� and what �outright lies� are you referring to? It seems to me that it is you that has been filled by someone with half truths and lies. You�ve decided to accept the board�s actions and don�t seem to accept that there�s another side of the story. A closed mind is a sad thing.

You've now called me (indirectly) a thief and a liar. That's okay, I'm a big boy. And now you question my motives. You just can't accept that someone such as me would go out of their way to expose and try to correct something so wrong. My agenda is simple, "I witnessed unjust and unethical behavior and I believed that the membership was entitled to be informed." I�ve always detested back room deal making and I�ve always tried to promote transparency, both in my role as a board member and in my personal life. I don�t want to promote an association that treats one of their own with such malice and wickedness as I witnessed on June 21st. If by exposing this sham, I can change future board behavior, then I�ve achieve my goal. I think a lot of members agree with me. Believe me (I know that's hard for you to do), but I'd much rather being producing something in my shop right now than debating with you. It�s not like I�m fighting for a return of my high paying job as a board member.

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#20

thank not yank

bob davis

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#21

Steven Antonucci

Frankly, who cares?

Steven Antonucci

We're all adults, capable of looking at the situation and making our own decisions. Whether we agree with you, you agree with us, or whatever- who really cares?

You are certainly entitled to your opinion, or to howl at the moon if you want-it's your call. I don't think you are crazy, but I don't agree.

S

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#22

Re: Frankly, who cares?

Barry L Elder

Why doesn't everyone read some of Russ's info on sanding, lacquer, finishing in general, and any other info posted on WC?! Please wait two more weeks before you break out your incessant potshots. Please!

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#23

Steven Antonucci

Is it a potshot to disagree with Russ?

Steven Antonucci

Pretty sure that he thought it was ok to reiterate his opinion on the situation, which I don't think anyone was unclear about. Some of us feel as strongly in the opposite manner.

Whether or not Russ knows a lot about woodturning doesn't really matter, since the issue at hand has very little to do with woodturning. It is about people, and how we as an organization value people. The nuances of whether or not the board acted legally, ethically, or in the best interest of the AAW membership have all been lost in the way they treated someone who had a lifetime of service.

If Russ doesn't see the 'human aspect' of this situation being the dominant topic, then it doesn't matter what agenda he thinks the others may have. If the AAW can throw away Mary Lacer, then anyone can be thrown away...including Russ.

Steve

P.S. and no, I did not send Russ the prior e-mails

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#24

Re: Frankly, who cares?

gary clarke

until the dust settles, yada yada yada. three sides to every story, yours, mine , and the facts, back to the shop and let the chips fly. :)

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

#25

Re: My opinion on the AAW controversy.

Bart Leetch

Just stepping in from the side lines here.

If I understand what the 2 former directors are saying the difference between what was done in the past & what has just transpired is not so much what was done but how it was done.