Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

large end-grain bowl hollowing...

Posts

large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#1

large end-grain bowl hollowing...

GaryG in MD

What is your favorite tool/technique for hollowing "large" (say 11") end-grain open-form bowls or vases? I don't want to use hollowing scrapers -- I want a cutting tool that leaves a very clean surface with no tearout.

I guess this would be a good place for a hook tool, but I don't have one. Should I buy one for this purpose?

What about gouges?

What about carbide circles (Hunter, Eliminator, etc.?)

My usual approach on small end-grain items is to drill a hole down the middle and use the gouge with the flute at 9 o'clock, cutting with the bottom of the tip, from the hole outward. (I'm going to work on "backhollowing", but not for something this large.)

Have I missed anything? What's the simplest and safest way? I'm not interested in anything approaching professional speed, but I don't want it to take all day either.

Thanks, Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#2

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

Mike Foster

Gary,

This wants to be hollowed from the center to the rim and requires the right tool to do it. As you mentioned, it can be scraped using one of the scraping systems, however it is much more fun to use a cutting tool. You posted most of the options. I'm one of those guys who has collected a lot of tools and have most of them. For an open form I would probably use either the Hunter tools or the Munro tool. The Munro is more expensive, but is really hard to get a catch or take too deep a bite. It can tend to clog some. The Hunter tools are great but require a little more attention and care with the cut in order to control it. I would probably use the Hunter in your case.

Have fun

Mike

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#3

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

The Hunter #5 carbide tip tool has changed my hollowing life. Hollowing is now fun, quick, and smooth, not a prolonged dreaded chore.

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

Lyle Jamieson

Essentially, you are using your bowl gouge as a scraper when the flute is directed at 9:00. So why not use a scraper on a boring bar?? I use my supported boring bar with laser and the carbide cutter assembly. The advantage I get from the swivel assembly is huge here. I can swivel the carbide cutter around to the side and slice through the fibers from bottom to top of the vessel (down hill to the grain). With the additional capabilities of the swivel it acts like an adjustable ring tool with bevel support the whole way.

I did a workshop in Maine that was all about lampshades and we had the worst, punky poplar, you could imagine to work with. All the students did it successfully with the carbide cutter to less then 1/8 inch thickness. Very little sanding was necessary.

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#5

Steven Antonucci

Buy a hook?!  Make one!

Steven Antonucci

making a hook can be done in most shops with the stuff you have lying around.

If you have a boring bar, take a small scrap of tool steel (2") that will fit the boring bar. In a pinch, cut nails can be used.

I usually start with round stock. If you have a plumbers torch, heat about 1" or so to as hot as you can get it and pound it "flat". Quench it in water until it is cool. Take this to a belt sander to grind the backside flat and then grind a cutting edge. You should have a small knife edge on a short round of steel.

Back to the torch. Heat the knife edge and give it a slight bend to the left at the bottom of the knife edge. Perhaps 10 degrees. I do this by lightly clamping it in a vise and just pushing on the round. It will bend very easily. If it is still glowing, grip the tip with pliers or a vise grip, and bend it to the right to complete the hook.

Should take about 5 minutes, and if you don't like it, you haven't spent any $$$...

Steve

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#6

Ellis Walentine

Need pix

Ellis Walentine

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#7

Steven Antonucci

I'll do one better- I will shoot a video

Steven Antonucci

As soon as I have a few minutes. I want to try out the new camera anyway.

S

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#8

Re: I'll do one better- I will shoot a video *LINK*

Bob Macgregor

Here's one version:


http://aroundthewoods.com/hooktool.shtml

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#9

Steven Antonucci

Exactly what I do

Steven Antonucci

Although I also show it without the 'blacksmithing' using only a grinder...

and I use a short length of O1 instead of a nail.

S

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#10

Re: Exactly what I do

Lance Kanaby

I personally like the Andre Martel Hook tool for doing vases and open type hollow forms. This tool shaves the wood and leaves an incredible surface. You can start sanding at 220 grit. There is a learning curve to using this tool, but it is amazing what you can do with it.

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#11

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

john lucas

Gary You said a bowl. Consequently I'm going to ask you about the shape. If it is an open form you can use a gouge to turn it because you will be cutting down hill with the grain when cutting from the lip down. If it's more of a straight sided or closed form then you can hollow from the center out and finish with one of the tools your asking about.

For the finishing cuts I would go down the sides with a bowl gouge. For these cuts I have the flute up and rub the bevel on the left side. The very nose is doing the cutting not the wing. This is a very clean cut. As you progress to the transition point where it starts to curve in rotate the flute clockwise but be sure and stop the cut before the bevel quits rubbing. That's the point that I pick up the Hunter tool. A #5 is my favorite for these type of deep bowl cuts. You can rub the bevel where the bowl gouge would not because of the steep angle of the front of the tool.

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#12

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

Peter Hyde

At a recent hands on club night we allowed members to try out a variety of hollowing tools, including scrapers, hunter tool, ring tool and martel hook plus the Soren Berger tool. The most popular for ease of use speed and finish was the Berger tool. We were hand hollowing to about 7" in fresh cut maple and most who tried were hollowing for the first time.

Sold at Craft Supplies for around $30 for the bit.

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#13

Thanks Mike...

GaryG in MD

I like my Hunters too. They only reason I asked about using them for bulk hollowing is that they are often described as "finishing" tools -- better suited for taking a fine cut, not hogging. I'll do a little with one and see how it goes. Might be a little on the slow side... ...Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#14

Thanks Emmett...

GaryG in MD

Yeah, with the caveat in my reply to Mike above, I agree completely. I love my #5, and I guess this will be a good way to get my money's worth out of it!

I'm now coveting the little Hunter "back hook" designed by Mark St. Leger. I saw Mark use it in Hartford -- sweet. It's perfect for getting up under the rim of Mark's small "boxes" made from random chunks of wood or his little "cube" types. ...Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#15

Thanks Lyle...

GaryG in MD

In retrospect, I guess I should have attended that lampshade demo in Hartford. I'm not planning to make one, but, you're right, this is the same thing.

I certainly see your point about using a big, constrained system like yours -- I'm sure it would be perfect -- but I don't have one (yet), so I want to do this with just normal hand tools, at least this first time. I might change my mind after this experience -- or not, we'll see.

You're the expert, not me, but I think when I do the tip cut with my gouge (let's say 10 o'clock rather than 9) I'm cutting, not scraping. I certainly get decent curls that way. I suppose it depends a lot on the shape of the flute and the grind.

Thanks for your comments, Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#16

BUT...

GaryG in MD

Thanks John; I appreciate your input, but it sounds to me like everything you describe is for side-grain. All of that is the way I normally work. This question is about end grain. I've done small end-grain pieces before, but never a big one like this. Going down the side from the outside inward is cutting "uphill" right into the end's of the fibers. Instant catch.

Please think through this with me one more time... ...Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#17

Thanks Peter...

GaryG in MD

You know, it's funny -- I've been looking at that Berger tool in the catalog and thinking it might be a good thing to try. I think now I've got my reason. Thanks for the connection and the ringing recommendation. More tools! ...Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#18

Thanks Steve...

GaryG in MD

I've watched Alan Lacer do just that. I have to admit that it looked a little more difficult and dangerous than I'm willing to do right now. I don't have much of a workshop. OTOH, I was going to look at a Martel hook when I was in Hartford and somehow missed it. I know that the hook tool is one of the traditional standards that has recently fallen a bit out of the mainstream eye. Might not be a bad time for me to buy one to try out. ...Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#19

Thanks Lance...

GaryG in MD

That's just what I wanted to hear. I can't wait to compare the Martel hook with the Berger. This is going to be fun. ...Gary

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#20

Steven Antonucci

Andre inspired me to make my first hook

Steven Antonucci

I saw him a few years back, and I was dumbfounded how well it worked. I made one within a week. Even a "bad" hook works pretty well. I have never been able to get his "crook' in the hook right. It puts you in shear cutting mode by default.

S

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#21

Come to IndyFest, we will make one

Ray - Middletown, IN

or several. We will have a forge or two for heat treat and will make several different tools.

Ray

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#23

Re: BUT...

john lucas

Gary Your right. I misread the shape of the vessel. Must have been tired today.

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#24

excellent -- thanks again...

GaryG in MD

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

#25

Re: large end-grain bowl hollowing...

jim miles - charlotte n c

Second the motion on Berger tool. I used termite - ring tool for years- they clog up- and break

had a Berger and never liked it. Spent some time learning to use it. Love it now. As you said- drill a hole in center and then you can cut into side grain - which is much easier than cutting end grain.