Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Do you know who you vote for?

Posts

Do you know who you vote for?

#1

Do you know who you vote for?

Clay Johnson

From what I have been told the AAW only had a minimum of nominees for the 3 positions. They were out begging for people to run for a board position.

One thought....well ok maybe 2 or 3 thoughts...... I know that most boards if not all, have the power to fire the ED, but this BoD is nothing but a bunch of woodturners with their own agenda.

Ok, they may have back grounds in different areas, but are they in area's that qualify them to make decisions that they do make. These 9 people have the power to change the lively hood of a single individual then in 3 years (or 6 if they do a second term) are off the board.

The board makes decisions that sometime do not reap the repercussions or praises for years down the road. Example, symposium locations, polices, hiring a new director then firing one that cost thousands because he didn't know what he was doing.

Do we know enough about the people we vote for? Did you ask questions to the people running for a board position? I did. Got some very interesting replies to my questions. Some people love to talk about themselves and their so called accomplishments. If every one of us just pick a name or see how pretty they are and vote....well you can't complain.

Ask questions....find out what they are wanting to do as a board member. Ask them what they think of your agenda's or what you think is best for AAW and see what they say. Don't like the answers....don't check their name.

Listen, I am not for sure why people want to be on the board of the AAW. Power? Change? Or any other reason that you can think of. But make them work for it. Hold them responsible and get involved. If you hear of a decision that was passed and you don't like it, let'em know. Give them your input. I do, that is why most of them know me. Good or bad but they know me.

Ok, Im done

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#2

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Barb Siddiqui

Clay, that's quite a challenge. But your "Power? Change? Make them work for it," idea seems off-base to me. I don't personally know the board members of the AAW, but I believe (yes, believe) they are there more for a sense of giving back to the community in which their successes rose so high, than on a personal power-grab agenda. It sounds like a thankless job.

I agree we should try to find out for whom we are casting a vote, but I don't agree with vilifying them. The work they do for the organization is hard enough without that. Let's seek the changes of the framework within which they operate, and let's please, avoid questioning their personal integrity. We don't know enough about the last year's events to justify that.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#3

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

john lucas

I agree with Barb. I really think that all involved are trying to do the best for the organization. I really don't think there are any power grabbing things going on. These are good people who volunteer their time and I think they truely want to help the organization. They may not have made the best choices based on what we have heard so far. I know we haven't heard every detail which makes it difficult for those of us outside to justify what happened.

I think the Board members work very hard for us with little thanks and the way they were run through the mill on this decision will make it hard for other people to even want to run for the board.

I definitely agree with you on the need to know more about the candidates. I suggested we have some sort of input from their local clubs because that's the only way I really know how to find about a candidate. They could be the brightest kid on the block and built up a run a very successful company and I've known people like that and they were jerks. I've also known a lot there not. Consequently reading the Bio doesn't really tell me much. I don't know of better way to do it for now. Even calling a club member may not work. It becomes too much like a site called Rateyourprofessor.com. All it takes is for one or two students who don't like you for some petty reason and rate you low to make it look like your a bad professor. People who like the professor generally don't bother to post.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#4

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Lance Kanaby

Have you ever met an honest politician? I haven't. It is up to all of the AAW members to question motives and backgrounds for anyone seeking election as we would for any politician. I am aware that unpaid jobs for clubs are thankless and those elected never seem to do the right thing or never enough. I know all of these things as I have been an officer in AAW chapters for over 10 years. It's kind of like the 80/20 rule, 80% do nothing and the other 20% seem to do it all. This is common in all clubs or groups.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#5

Outside look'n in....

Marv

Been reading the various posts regarding what's going on with the AAW.

Generally speaking, anytime a person takes on responsibility to serve on any kind of board where there is membership involved, that person will soon learn that it is impossible to satisfy everyone no matter what decision is made. With every group with numbers in excess of 5 will include at least one who will stir things up when ever a decision is made. It's just the way it is, folks. Have you ever met three people who can agree on everything? Just doesn't happen.

Realizing this fact, and responding accordingly might help the membership to be more understanding. However, I would never hold my breath and wait for it to happen. No doubt a certain number of you reading this will voice your disagreement and it wouldn't matter what I write, it will still happen. But I'm ok with that. It's just the way we are.

Hell, I'm lucky if I can get my wife to agree with me even 10% of the time...so there ya go. :D

Marv

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#6

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Clay Johnson

Barb

Vilifying them? What part? I have said nothing vicious or defamatory against the existing board. This is for the future. This really wasn't meant for the existing board....

My Comment:

"Listen, I am not for sure why people want to be on the board of the AAW. Power? Change? Or any other reason that you can think of. But make them work for it. Hold them responsible and get involved. If you hear of a decision that was passed and you don't like it, let'em know. Give them your input. I do, that is why most of them know me. Good or bad but they know me."

I know that they work hard for little praise. I am on our club's board and I can assure you it is not for power. But I can also assure you it WAS for change. Many years ago I was not happy with some of the boards decisions so instead of complaining about them, I did something. I got to know them. I then ran for a board position to change what I didn't feel was correct. What I am saying is that we do not ask enough questions of them. I know they can not return 13000 e-mails from members that ask them questions. But, they don't get 13000 e-mails.

When I wrote each nominee, some said I was the ONLY one that took the time to ask them. I ask 3 easy questions. These issues were issues I wanted to know how they felt about. They were generalized and it was info as easy as "in the past 5 years how many symposiums had you been to". One person had only been to the previous one, but he had a lot of comments about how the symposium should be changed. How could he really know enough after attending 1(one) symposium?

Make them work for it? Yes! BUT! This was not intended to mean they do not work. NOT AT ALL!!!!!. I mean that they must explain to me why they want to run for the board. Why they think they are qualified to deserve such a, (and I mean this) honorable position. I feel it is an honer to be on the board of the AAW. They should feel it as well. If they don't, they are on it, in my opinion, for the wrong reason. They need to work and answer my questions to get my vote. (We also should do the same in government). They should also have to explain their decisions on a particular agenda. They represent US, not them.

I know a person that didn't do anything for our club, but when the AAW came to Louisville they were wanting to be in the spot light. On the board, walking around the symposium chest puffed out and everything. After the symposium they were not to be found and really didn't help while they were on the board or during the symposium. I am not saying there is ANYONE on the existing board that is like that. But you have to get to know these people before you vote. Because they are out there

Lance, Wow 20% thats great!

Marv, you are my hero, 10% I wrong all the time. Just ask her...

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#7

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Barb Siddiqui

Sorry if I misunderstood, Clay. I guess the early paragraph with the line, "this BoD is nothing but a bunch of woodturners with their own agenda," kind of set the tone for the whole post. Thanks for clarifying it.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Mike Stafford

Altruism is a virtue I don't believe in. Altruism is based on self-deception which is the root of all evil. People seek power for their own reasons and it is almost never because of an overwhelming sense of wanting to give back. If for no other reason it is so they can say they gave back and feel good about themselves. All of our so called political leaders profess to being altruistic, giving back to the community, and most are scoundrels with whom I would not trust any money equivalent to my AAW annual dues.

With the exception of a couple of people I have never known any BOD member to routinely participate in the on-line community we frequent. I have never heard of any of the 6 candidates running this year. Very few people with the exception of their home clubs and state organizations will know them and if the club and home state vote in a large enough block they will be elected. I wish more of the people who actively participate in the various forums were candidates because folks do know something about them.

Think about it, when was the last time you heard from a member of the BOD on a forum except during the current brouhaha. Most of them have never participated even in the AAW forum. There are a few exceptions but they are indeed few.

All most of us will ever know about most candidates is a position statement and photograph that will appear in the journal. That position statement will provide no substantive information except that which the candidate wants to provide. We will still know nothing about the candidate. It is no wonder when it all said and done we end up with a pig in a poke.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#9

Barb Siddiqui

Altruism?

Barb Siddiqui

Jeez, Mike. That's one of the darkest interpretations of humanity I've seen in a while. Please don't forget, we are talking about what is now a Large, Non-Profit Organization and Somebody has to run it! Somebody has to Step up to the plate and put Their Time and Interest on the line. This is the AAW, not Enron. Why in the world would you assume a power grab and evil, selfish agenda? That attitude about the current board is just not warranted.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#10

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Mike, I have known a number of past board members, and a long time friend is on the present board. Any that I have known, with a couple of exceptions, are people who have volunteed to put in a lot of their time and effort to help see that AAW is operated the way it needs to be. Without these people, and what they put into the organization, AAW would not even exist. My friend is a full time turner. He has given up a significent part of his income to spend the time necessary to do the job. He volunteered to head the committee to oversee the Hartford symposium. Can you imagine the time and effort that went into that? For no personal gain at all.

Without the people who have served on past and present boards who are willing to give their time to the organization, we would never have had an AAW.

Some of the people who have been trashing the present board for making a decision that was unpopular with some of them, and without knowing most of the facts, have lost a lot of credibility with me. Very few of them have ever put in a nickels worth of their own time to support the AAW.

Wally

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Altruism?

Mike Stafford

I don't believe my comments were addressed to the current board. My comments were about altruism in general.

The fact is I don't know any of the current board members and I don't know their motivations. I don't think many of the members of the AAW know much about the current BOD or the people who are nominated. I just see a lot of unhappy members based upon the posts on the various forums. I, for one, am becoming increasingly disenchanted with the yearly uproar that happens as a result of some action of the AAW.

I have become increasingly skeptical of anyone who wishes to "give back". Invariably it is done with other people's money.

Enron has nothing to do with altruism. That was a bunch of crooks.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#12

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

john lucas

Mike In reality most people don't visit these boards. I belong to 3 clubs with over 200 total members. I don't think I'd be far off if I said no more than 20 or maybe 30 visit these boards regularly. Only 2 of the officers do. Consequently I think the board members could easily fall in the majority who don't visit the sites. I have seen posts by several on the AAW site. Remember they might also be lurkers. They might feel they don't have anything to offer that hasn't already been said so why post.

I also would not put them in the same sentence with politicians. Not trying to chastise you. I know over half the board and these are good honest people who are doing this to help the AAW. They don't get anything out of it and have made their own careers in turning and or other fields. As was stated above only 10 percent of the club members actually do the work and the board members come from that 10 percent.

I'm not trying to hassle anyone. I just think people are assuming the worst from the board and based on the people I know I both sides of this argument I don't think that's the case.

Anyway, back to the voting. I don't know any of the people running for the board in the next election. I've never seen a post by them or at least don't remember the name. Consequently it will be up to us to find out who they are and then tell our friends. Thanks Clay for bringing this up.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#13

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I got a personal e-mail from Stan Wellborn Wellborn@rff.org a candidate for the BOD. He thanked me for posting a "cooler head" message during this trouble. He invited me to ask him questions about his vision. He answered all six,I liked his answers. They were in private so I will not post them here. I invite you contact him and to have a little conversation.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#14

Just a thought....

Marv

Ya know? From where I sit, on the outside look'n in, it seems to me that it would be better for a whole lot of wood turners to just abolish the AAW as a membership type organization. Keep the forum so all you turners can share ideas and skills and learn from each other. Isn't that what it's all about? For ego food, when you make something you are proud of, post pictures and explain what's special about it, etc., etc. I often like to say..."if'n ya cain't gloat, it's not worth do'n"

Actually, come to think about it, you have the WoodCentral forum right here where you can do all of that without even keeping the AAW forum. And it's pretty much free too, except for donations as you wish. And as a bonus, if someone starts stiring the pot, Ol Ellis will kick their arses out.

What's that old saying?...."if'n yer right eye offendeth thee, pluck it out and cast it aside". No need to become a one-eyed-jack, but the old saying does make a point.

Just say'n, :|

Marv

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#15

Ex Board Member Responds

Malcolm Tibbetts

Clay, now that I'm an ex-board member, I have all this extra free time to visit WoodCentral.

In response... I didn't seek my board position. I was recruited to run by a past board member and fellow club member and I eventually said "yes". My motive was indeed, �to give something back�. I had great passion for woodturning and for the AAW�s role in jump starting my woodturning career. I had a background in running a large business and I thought that I might have something to offer. I gave over five years of time and probably many thousands of real dollars. Did I have any hidden agenda? Maybe a tiny one� I wanted to see �segmented turning� receive a little more attention. I served to the best of my ability without pushing any personal agendas.

Regarding the current AAW mess, I�m not going to rehash a lot of what I�ve already said. Most of it�s on the AAW Forum. Bottom line, in my view, some very good people made a very big mistake.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#16

Rob Wallace

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Rob Wallace

Same thing here with me Bill too - in offline e-mail discussion with him it seems he is really interested in making the AAW better and contributing his expertise in publishing and non-profit management to the AAW.

It would be good to have scheduled on-line "chats" with each of the candidates prior to the election - perhaps Woodcentral can help in that regard?? I don't think the AAW forum boards are set-up for chats......

Even if a small percentage of AAW members were to participate, they could inform the non-Internet savvy turners of the outcome of these chats.

Rob Wallace

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#17

REALLY?

George Guadiane

Mike,

Seriously, this is a puzzle to me. I know it becomes far flung, but Gandhi, Mother Theresa and the like not altruistic? If there is even one that you can accept in that way, couldn't there be more? And I agree, looking at "politicians" is almost certainly like looking for a needle in a freshly mown hayfield.

Have you NEVER done anything without expecting an acknowledgment, a response or reward? I'll give you that the "feel good" we get is often a reward of sorts, but seriously, never done ANYTHING just because you knew it was "the right thing to do?"

If you have, or if you can allow for the possibility that someone could, then can you reasonably limit the size of what another could do as an act of altruism and not just in its name.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#18

Re: Ex Board Member Responds

Clay Johnson

Malcolm

The message I wrote was not intended about you or even the existing board members. I assume what you have said to all the forums is the truth. No need to think anything else. But we still haven't heard everything nor will we. Thats fine if that is what Mary wants.

I agree with you 100% about good people making bad decisions. That is what has happened with the AAW now.

What my initial comment is that we need to make sure we know, to the best of our ability, who we are voting for. What is their agenda? They need an agenda!!!! Agendas are good in most cases. Ask questions so we know what they are about.

I have followed the AAW forums from the start. Amazed at what has happened to Mary, I have only known here for 19 years and had some very intense discussions with her. Maybe she will be able to tell here side of the story some day. I have not checked the AAW forums for a day or so, so if something else or new has happened I will have to read up on it. Just have been a little busy.

Always good to hear from you and look forward to more of your comments.

Clay

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#19

Walt Bennett

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Walt Bennett

"From what I have been told the AAW only had a minimum of nominees for the 3 positions. They were out begging for people to run for a board position."

This seems odd to me - I personally know someone who said recently that he'd applied in both the last two years and was turned down. He said he was never contacted afterwords either. Since I've known him for several years, I really wonder why anyone would claim they only had a minimum of nominees (unless they were 'suitable' ones according to the committee).

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#20

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Malcolm Tibbetts

Walt, you are correct. At the board meeting prior to the start of the Hartford symposium, it was reported by the norminating committee that they could only convince 6 people to run for election. Six people for six ballot slots for three positions. Not many members "apply"; most candidates are recuited by other board members. As for your friend, I don't have an answer; I was not on the norminating committee. You (or he) could always contact Dale Larson, the norminating chair.

One of the sad parts of the election process is the terribly low percentage of voter turn-out - not much more than 10%.

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#21

Re: Ex Board Member Responds

Bob Rosand

As an ex-board member, I simply don't know what happens to some people when they get on the board, but so many of them seem to change, and not for the better. It bothers me greatly because I am at least partly responsible for getting some of these people nominated (nominating committee). I really think that one of the mistakes we made was in the transition from a working board to a governing board. I realize that the organization is bigger than when I was a board member, but I honestly think that many of the board members have lost contact with the membership and have forgotten why they sit on the board. When I went to my first board meeting, I almost quit on the spot because I was so overwhelmed. Charles Alvis pulled me aside and asked me if I had the best interests of the AAW at heart. I replied "of course I do". He just smiled and said "You'll do fine." It just seems to me that we have to many personal agendas and not enough focus on the membership, beginners, intermediate and studio turner alike.

On a total aside, I was talking with another former board member who was on vacation and just becoming aware of what this board did to Mary. His response total shock, and he reminded me that in the earlier days of AAW, mary ran the organization out of her living room for a significant period of time just to keep the organization alive (and was never reimbursed to the best of my knowledge). How many of us would have done that and how many of us even know that fact or appreciate it? This board certainly doesn't. Sorry for the rant.

Bob Rosand, former board member

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#22

thanks, bob. you did a great job

bob davis

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

#23

Re: Do you know who you vote for?

Buddy Riley

I have sat in the background and read all of the posts here, on WOW and the AAW. Several years ago I decided I wanted to heop the AAW more, after the Louisville Symposium, my feelers about being on the board were warmly received by several BOD members. in the process I was interviewed by phone, from 3 members of the nominating committee, several questions were asked about my views, direction the AAW should take in my opinion, and several others, when I stated that the AAW should pay more attention to the Joe average woodturner, which most of us are, I got the phone call back saying I was not BOD material, this is how members not meeting the criteria are eleminated, so yes I believe there are alot more members out there willing to help but are never given the chance. And for the record, I stand for Mary Lacer or anyone treated the way she has been, she is the lifeblood or was of the AAW.