Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

turning rules and philosophies...

Posts

turning rules and philosophies...

#1

turning rules and philosophies...

GaryG in MD

Broke one, was saved by two, and reconsidering one...

Rule 1: Don't make a tenon out of punky wood -- wishful thinking does not help! Sheared that sucker right off.

I was saved by Rules 2 and 3, which I did obey -- keep the tail stock up as long as possible, and stay out of the line of fire! No drama, just an "oh sh**".

I'm reconsidering the "Life is too short to turn bad wood", in its favor. I love "interesting" wood, but this hickory has been down for too long. Some of the heart wood is sound, and I'd better just use that if I insist on not tossing the whole thing. Before the excitement, I wasted a lot of time and trouble trying to get a clean cut through punky wood (a good learning experience if nothing else). The net result is that after a lot of effort, I don't have much more than I started with an hour earlier except some lessons and a shorter bowl form. Call me dumb, but now I have an "investment" in this piece, so I'm going to give it one more try -- with a new tenon that is hopefully much sounder than the first one. And it has been soaked with wood hardener, for what good that will do.

Hopefully, tomo will be more rewarding. As an exercise, I think I'm going to try making the end-grain potato chip I saw Pascal Oudet do on Thursday in Hartford. Should be exciting! ...Gary

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#2

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

Fred Holder

Hello Gary,

I've been using Turner's Choice (originally called Cedar Shield) made in Texas for a number of years to treat wet wood or dry wood and in the last year to treat some spalted (shall we say rotten) wood. All with very good results.

We have a collaborative group with six or seven members that meets each month and exchange partially finished pieces. We draw one and finish it. The next month the person who submitted it get it back.

A couple of times, I've received a piece of partially turned wood that was so rotten that you could not get a clean cut no matter how sharp the tool. Each of them I soaked in Turner's Choice overnight and let them dry for at least three days. Amazingly, they cut clean and I was able to finish each piece. One of them I finished into a Chinese Ball or a pedistal.

I have no connection with the company that makes this stuff, just a happy user.

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

Lyle Jamieson

Fred asked me to respond for More Woodturning:

Id go with your first thought. Trash is trash, throw it away. There is so much good wood out there that there is no need to put ourselves in danger turning cracked or punky wood. Why spend the time and energy to soak, glue, patch, re-glue, etc. The result is a piece that looks like its been patched and glued etc. I certainly would not be using a chuck if the wood was questionable.

Just yesterday I had a piece of beautiful spalted, maple burl given to me. It looked spectacular til I started to turn it. The more I turned the deeper the cracks went. The colors were unbelievable. I repositioned it twice before I gave up the ship and put it in the burn pile. Life's too short. I don�t care how many rules you have, when a piece of wood lets loose you can get hurt, no mater where you stand, even if you have your face shield on, even with the tailstock. One of the guys in my club showed us the dozens of stitches up his arm and his bruised chest from a double turned bowl coming apart. AND, He didn�t do anything wrong. The cracks were in the piece before he started. He wont do that again. How do you want to learn the lesson??

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#4

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

GaryG in MD

Hi Lyle,

Thanks for your comments. I hear you loud and clear. That thing would have HURT! I'd need an umpire's chest protector or a bullet-proof vest if that thing had hit me. Scary prospect. I've always been a very "safe" turner. I recognize the dangers and try to follow the safety rules. When I do anything even slightly "questionable", I stay way out of the line of fire AND behind the tool rest so it deflects the thing in another direction. Best to avoid all danger, of course, but, as you point out, sometimes we don't suspect danger. That's what the common sense safety rules are for. Beautifully nature-decorated wood is hard to resist, but one must learn to draw the line.

I'm happy to hear about the recommended wood hardener from Fred, and I'll probably get some for cosmetic purposes (only!), but I'm NOT going to be doing punky tenons any more!!

Regards, Gary

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#5

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

GaryG in MD

Thanks Fred,

I'm glad to hear your reco. What's a good source for Turner's Choice? Sounds like great stuff.

With full consideration of Lyle's comments (below), I think this sounds like a valuable product for fixing cosmetic problems. But NEVER again will I try to turn with a punky tenon. Is that STUPID or what? That could have been bad. I was in the right place at the right time, but that would have HURT.

Nice to hear from you, Gary

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#6

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

john lucas

Right you are Lyle. When I went to John C Campbell to each Marsha showed me 3 holes in the ceiling. The gentleman turning it had 13 stitches in his forehead. This was a piece of Norfolk Island pine that was already completely turned. He had taken off his faceshield to sand it. The bowl not the faceshield. :) Most of us, just like him, would assume that since it held up to the turning it's safe. Apparently not so.

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#7

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

Fred Holder

Hello Gary,

I get mine from www.cedarcide.com. I think they are the manufacturers. I don't know of anyone who distributes it. If you lived close to me, I could sell you a gallon, since I have several gallons on hand. They are in Texas. Incidentally, it is expensive, but you can use it over and over again.

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#8

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

GaryG in MD

John, I would NEVER consider working at the lathe without a full face shield. I would literally feel naked without it. The problem is that your throat is still exposed. The shields should really be longer than they are. I don't think a dangling protector (like on a catchers mask) would work -- our pieces of wood tend to be a lot heavier than a baseball. ...Gary

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

#9

Re: turning rules and philosophies...

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the link, Fred. Yeah, at $50/gallon, it becomes a financial value judgment as well as a safety issue -- is that punky wood really worth the investment? That's a tough choice.

I note in their literature that they say you can't use water-based finishing products over it. Another comment was that it gums up sandpaper. Have you run into these limitations? ...Gary