Bowl critique for fun
John Lucas
I was donating some wood to our club and some of it had checks so I thought I would turn a piece to see if it was good enough to give away. This piece had the worst checks. I turned away all the checks to see what good wood was left. That left me with more or less this shape. I did this in a hurry and wasn't picky about several things so I thought it would be fun to critique it so others can learn from it.
On the shot on the right you can see that I didn't quite nail the curve. There is sort of a flat area in the middle that starts about an inch from the top and the bottom. Also the lip went somewhat straight up instead of continuing the curve. This happened because there was a defect in the lip are and when I turned it away it changed the shape. I should have gone back and changed the shape of the whole piece at that point or simply cut the lip away.
Looking at the shot on the left you can see where I left the heart in. Bowls always raise up there. In this bowl it looks terrible and should have been cut out. I would have ended up with a shorter bowl but it would have been better looking. I would have solved 2 problems, the heart raising up (and having to seal some defects in the pith area) and the rim having a funny tilt. If you leave the heart in design your bowls like Bill Luce. He uses this lift in the rim to his advantage.
I think the foot is about right compared to the size of the top lip. Assuming the rim is not cut away what do you think about the thickness of the rim detail and also the downward slope of the rim toward the inside.




