Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Bowl critique for fun

Posts

Bowl critique for fun

#1

Bowl critique for fun

John Lucas



I was donating some wood to our club and some of it had checks so I thought I would turn a piece to see if it was good enough to give away. This piece had the worst checks. I turned away all the checks to see what good wood was left. That left me with more or less this shape. I did this in a hurry and wasn't picky about several things so I thought it would be fun to critique it so others can learn from it.

On the shot on the right you can see that I didn't quite nail the curve. There is sort of a flat area in the middle that starts about an inch from the top and the bottom. Also the lip went somewhat straight up instead of continuing the curve. This happened because there was a defect in the lip are and when I turned it away it changed the shape. I should have gone back and changed the shape of the whole piece at that point or simply cut the lip away.

Looking at the shot on the left you can see where I left the heart in. Bowls always raise up there. In this bowl it looks terrible and should have been cut out. I would have ended up with a shorter bowl but it would have been better looking. I would have solved 2 problems, the heart raising up (and having to seal some defects in the pith area) and the rim having a funny tilt. If you leave the heart in design your bowls like Bill Luce. He uses this lift in the rim to his advantage.

I think the foot is about right compared to the size of the top lip. Assuming the rim is not cut away what do you think about the thickness of the rim detail and also the downward slope of the rim toward the inside.

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#2

There's two things I like with nice "curves"......

Greg Haugen

...............and Bowls are one of them. :-) That being said, I don't turn this style of bowl much.

I do see the flat that you mentioned on the side and the sudden change in form at the "detail" just before the rim. There's so much character in this wood, I don't think it needs any "detail" on it. Without that detail, one or two more cuts and that upper curve would flow better. The foot, I'd say, is at the biggest I'd go with on this form. It could be a little smaller but it works where it's at. It's close to the size, compared to the largest diameter, that I'd say would be good for a utility bowl, decorative bowls being a little smaller footed. The rim, I like. I like inward rims. It doesn't interrupt the form and when you look at it, your eyes easily follows to the inside of the bowl. As far as thickness for the rim, that can be misleading. I like thicker rims on a bowl, that's under cut, so the bowl looks more substantial than it is. A thicker rim is also an excellent location for some embellishments, beads, texture, etc. Or to showcase the face grain character of the bowl. Bowl thickness? For my tastes, it's a bit thick. But that's subjective. I have a local gallery whose owner recently visited me. She saw my rough turned bowls and asked for them to be sanding and finished-no more turning. I looked at her and chuckled. She likes that thicker look.

It's a great piece of wood. A lot of character. The form is very, very close. We'd all see it differently. This is only my opinion.

Greg

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#3

Re: Bowl critique for fun

GaryG in MD

John,

You already ID'd most of your own problems. Here's my 2�:

First, that's great wood! Wonderful features.

I agree that the shape of the curve could be a better "fair" curve.

One of my main problems with it is that the slope transition below the rim is "soft". I think it would look better if it were crisp -- or eliminate it, one or the other.

I like the downward slope of the inside of the rim. I use that form a lot myself.

I like the ring around the top, with the caveat that I'd like to see it integrated (somehow) with a sharper transition.

I'd make the foot a lot smaller -- more like a Phil Brown "flare" shape.

Richard Raffan would love that rim.

...Gary

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#4

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Barry L Elder

Doesn't matter how many things you mention, it's just "wunnerful"! :D

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#5

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Peter Lamb

John.

I think your being hard on yourself. Yes the curve could be a very little bit better, however, given the piece and its problems far better your bowl than firewood !

Peter

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#6

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Texian

Rim tilt/slope is fine. Like the bulgy rim, but not the flat spot. Usually like the bottom edge radiused/rounded into the base to give a bit of lift. Size of the foot looks good to me.

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#7

Re: Bowl critique for fun

john lucas

Peter your right. Most people would have thrown that piece of wood out. The checks were deep but by repositioning the wood and cutting away until the checks were gone I had something to work with. Customers aren't as picky as me. I do this critic with each project so I can learn and chastise myself for not spending a few more minutes to get it perfect or at least as close as I can.

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Lyle Jamieson

Hi John, You nailed the issue HERE. Time!! In my July newsletter I will talk about slowing down and making the best piece I can, not the biggest piece. My message was to slow down and smell the roses. I even quote you from a previous post about having fun. Its all about the fun. The satisfaction from a job done right is tremendous, it just takes time.

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#9

Re: Bowl critique for fun

john lucas

Lyle your dead on. There are 2 big issues that I see in woodturning and probably woodworking as a whole. Trying to get the biggest piece you can out of a block of wood, and not taking the time to do the best you can. I'm as guilty as anyone.

We get a piece of wood, perhaps it's already cut into a bowl blank. We try to turn it round removing as little wood as necessary to get a bowl out of it. This often leads to bad shapes, funny grain alignment, and odd warping of the bowl.

The best way to do it is to plan from the start. Where do I cut it from the tree and how does this affect the figure in the wood, how will it warp, and what shape am I after. By then you already have a pretty good idea of how it goes on the lathe.

Mount it between centers and then start turning. Stop often and look at the wood, the grain, any defects and any figures that appear. Readjust the centers if necessary to use these details to your best advantage.

In photography the saying is Less is more. You take away anything in the photo that doesn't add to the whole. Remove any distractions that will lead your eye away from the center of interest. This is just as true in woodturing. Sometimes you have to remove an inch or so of height to get rid of distractiing elements such as the pith area in my bowl. If the grain is way off center or detracts from the shape it may require a radical shift in the way the bowl is mounted on the lathe and may result in a bowl quite a bit smaller than you had planned. However this small bowl will be much prettier because all of the elements will work together.

In the case of this bowl. A few more minutes looking really hard at it would have told me to change that outside curve. By not trying to save the lip and ending up with an odd shape I should have simply remove it. What it boiled down to in this case was I had about an hour I could spare and put this wood on the lathe and rushed the whole project. With just another 30 minutes it could have been much nicer. Oh well, that's the life of a working Joe.

However since we are doing this as a hobby the main goal is to get some satisfaction out of it. Whether it was just playing with the tools or trying to turn the best bowl you can as long as you have fun that's all that really counts. I did enjoy turning it ( not so sure about cleaning up the mess however).

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Lyle Jamieson

Thanks for expanding the thought. I am guilty of rushing through a project in the guise of efficiency. But it is a lot more fun to slow down. I wish you had written your long advice before I took all my time to write my newsletter this month. I could have just copied yours. It is exactly what I wanted to say. For those that want to read my version, it will be posted on my web site in about a week, I hope. And, you can sign up for future mailings if you like what you see. I get great feedback on my Q&A section.

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#11

THanks, I'll check it out.

john lucas

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Steve Kubien

This thread is making me re-think one particular rough-out I have which is ready to go back on the lathe. My original thought was some sort of tall calabash shape. The rough-out is around 14" diameter and 8" tall. I'll play with it but I suspect cutting off and inch or two from the rim will be its best fate.

Thanks!

Steve

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#13

Mike Peace

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Mike Peace

You said, "A few more minutes looking really hard at it would have told me to change that outside curve."

For me it is taking the time to stop and feel the curve as well as look at it. Seems like I can feel problems better than I can see 'em, sometimes.

Re: Bowl critique for fun

#14

Re: Bowl critique for fun

Matt Overton

John,

Simplicity is your strong suit. You make a number of great points here and I will rethink a number of pieces of wood as a result. Most people would have not been happy with this piece and just moved on. You get the most out of your limited time at the lathe, and we all appreciate that more than you think. Thanks for sharing!