Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

Posts

Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#1

Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

RussFairfield

If you don't like the content of the AAW magazine, complaining about it on an internet site does absolutely nothing. I suggest that you do the following -

1. Join the AAW so you have a ligitimate complaint.

2. Tell the Editor what you, AS A MEMBER, would like to see.

Complaining about the magazine here does absolutely nothing except PO those of us who are writing articles that are of general interest to the readers.

3. Write your own article on the topic you want to see.

You don't have to be an expert to write an article. The Journal has a very capable editor who is capable of making anyone look like a seasoned author.

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#2

Re: see, this is why we all want you to stay here

Matt Overton

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#3

Barb Siddiqui

You know what I miss in the Journal?

Barb Siddiqui

Something like a brief Q&A from Nick Cook or another knowledgeable turner. I learn things from other people's questions. Even if it were (gasp) fabricated as a column with questions made up to be answered, I'd still like to see one.

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#4

Good response, send it to Betty.  I'd like it also

John Lucas

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#5

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

Ralph Lindberg

Russ

Smack on

and more

Don't like what the AAW BoD did, run, work to get people you like and trust to run

(#$*$, get Mary and Alan to run (I'd vote for both)

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#6

Barb Siddiqui

Done.

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#7

Nope

Ron Sardo

I think it has greatly improved since Betty took over.

And I do owe her a "for beginners" article, I dropped the ball on that one.

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#8

Steven Antonucci

like skewing a turnip :-)

steven antonucci

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#9

Careful

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

with the Cold Water, Voice of Reason stuff, Russ. You'll be accused of impairing First Amendment rights.

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#10

You didn't stay gone long

jimmy edwards

Heck, we all get puffed up at one time or another

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#11

Re: He's back!

JamieDonaldson

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#12

Re: Welcome back!

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Russ: As I have stated before, here and on other forums I am a less art kind of guy, I stiil believe that I do not know enough to be a turning author. I have written technical journals and SOPs for years. My wife is a newsletter editor for two turning clubs. So writing skill is not a problem. It is the lack of basic knowledge that is my concern.

I desire to read articles from more experienced people like you. I am going to write an article on basic motor repair, but not turning.

Thanks,

Bill Turpin

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#13

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

Bill Neddow

Excellent comment, Russ.

I was a magazine editor, and a publisher responsible for a raft of magazines for many years. I have been both an editor, and the shoulder on which editors cried.

It is a tough job.

In this case, you only have only 72 pages in which you satisfy all the need and whims of almost 14,000 people with a wide variety of interests.. It is even tougher when you realize that many articles take several pages and that even with "News and Notes" and"Chatter" pages, you are hard pressed to touch on 72 topics in an issue, even in passing. Room also has to be made for advertising (to pay some of the bills), the table of contents, etc. etc.

I think Betty has done an excellent job in her role as editor. She packs an incredible amount of variety into every issue and there is definitely lots of "meat". The design is also much better than it used to be -- more modern, clean and appealing. I know some people have objected to the loss of the logo on the cover and there were some weird stories going around about that. But, the logo had a really dated feel to it. Removing it was a definite improvement.

So if YOU think something is lacking, rather than complaining, send Betty an e-mail and offer to write a story for her -- that story you think has been missed and that you really want to see in the magazine.

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#14

Dissatisfied with AW? Not this brand-new member!

Chris Hoehle

I'm in my 30's, been turning wood for a little under two years and I just joined the AAW in April of this year. I'd been thinking about joining for a while and the thing that really made me decide to finally do it was when they decided to put all the past issues of the journal online.

So far, using the PDF index of the online journals, which is really easy to search, I've found help on everything from pepper mills to tool handles to using 2 part wood bleach to looking at what kinds of things Christian Burchard and Al Stirt had done & written about to help me decide which class I was going to take at Anderson Ranch this summer.

The latest issue was the first one I got as a paper copy and it had the great article about Mark Lindquist. I hadn't heard of him yet (other than seeing some of his pieces in David Ellsworth's book) and it was a great introduction for me to him and his work.

All in all, I think the journal has a great mix of articles and as someone who doesn't really describe himself as a beginner anymore but is still pretty new, I wouldn't change a thing.

Also, Russ, I'm glad you decided to stay. I haven't been around here long either, but long enough to know your posts are full of good information!

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#15

Re: You didn't stay gone long

Bernie Rose

Afterall those great eulogies, how could Russ not come back from where-ever ?

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#16

Barb Siddiqui

Re: You didn't stay gone long

Barb Siddiqui

Ha! He's one of those lucky few who now know what his funeral's going to be like.

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#17

Re: Welcome back!

Lan Brady

Bill,

As always, Russ has made a good point. Actually I prefer articles by people with less than amazing skills.

The reason: you would not make the assumption that my skill levels are very high. You would include important details.

I have read some of Netties Editorial reviews. I think she could punch up a telephone book.

If you write it , I will read it!

Lan

Re: Dissatisfied with the American Woodturner??

#18

Re: Dissatisfied with AW? Not this brand-new membe

cliff

one of my encouragments for joining was the american woodturner, i think betty is doing a great job, moving to 6 issues a year was a great idea. i notice a wider range of articules now than in the recent past. i would like to echo the idea of a question and answer colum, maybe by a experienced turner or a panel of turners.

cliff