A tribute to my friend and teacher, Russ
Dinyar Chavda
Russ:
Like all the others, I am sorry to see you go, but I respect your decision, and it is your decision, even if some may not understand it. Anyone's right to freedom of speech carries with it your equal right to not go to the place where they have their soapbox set up.
This whole series of events illustrates the best and the worst of the internet. The best is that information can be spread instantly, and people can react to it. The worst is that misinformation can be spread quickly, and people can react to it. There is no vetting. And it also exemplifies one of the very common occurrences on the internet, which is "fingers in gear, mind in neutral".
You have said repeatedly that "words and actions were not without consequence". Certainly, your leaving WC is a consequence of words and actions. I'm not a lawyer, (although I've studied the law), but it seemed to me that some of the statements that have been made could elicit consequences that are far harsher, in the form of libel and defamation of character suits. Mark Mandel is more qualified to talk about that, but, from the outside looking in, a completely legitimate firing of an employee would not look very different from the actions of the BOD, and so a lot of the harsher accusations about the character and motives of the BOD may not be substantiable. Further, their silence may be a requirement by law. And, no, I am not going to debate the issue with anyone who disagrees with me--you may be right, and all I am saying is that you may also be wrong, based on what we can tell.
Finally, it is supremely ironic that one of the issues that somehow seems to have gotten wrapped up in this is that of the Journal, and how it should be made more novice-friendly. I don't get the journal, as I am not a member, so I can't judge the validity of the accusation (although I might become one as I just found out that one can then get access to past issues online, which would make membership worthwhile, at least for a year),. What is unfortunate is that these actions have driven away a person who is one of the best sources of information for any novice (and many experts also). It will affect us old-timers much less. Those of us who have known you from before will just e-mail/call/visit you when we have questions (although even we will miss out on the learning we got from eavesdropping on other peoples' questions). But those who would have benefitted the most from you, the future newbies, will be the poorer for your absence. The Law of Unintended Consequences strikes again, and it is a powerful force indeed.
I am grateful to WC, and, before that, to rec.craft.woodturning(?), as they allowed me to get to know you on both a professional and a personal level. I am proud to call Gerry, �Mom�, and to call you my friend (although we still have to work out the pie issue the next time I�m in Idaho). And I am sorry to see you go, as your absence will be felt, my friend.
P.S. Well, I posted this, and then saw your message about your sticking around a bit longer. That's great news! But, I'll let it stand, as it does express how I (and others) feel about you.





