Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

Posts

A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#1

Aage Rendalen

A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

Aage Rendalen

For those of you who haven't tried the big Easy Rougher "gauges", here's a quick review based on using them to turn a 12 inch green gum bowl yesterday.

First the conclusions:

1. At more than $140 a piece they're too expensive for my budget

2. They perform well and leave a superb surface

3. I still prefer my 1/2 inch Crown gauge

I used the square cutter to shape the outside. You can use three sides of the cutter head during the process, cutting sideways as well as straight on. It leaves a very smooth surface, although I noticed a tendency to fray the rim of the bowl, which led me to use my gauge to smooth it out.

I switched to the round cutter head for hollowing out the interior of the bowl. Although it cut wonderfully and left a great surface, I kept missing my gauge as I progressed down the side of the bowl. With no bevel to ride it was harder to get the interior profile right. With a gauge you can you "see" both sides of the wall; I lost that double vision with this cutter. On the other hand, it seemed to work equally well with push and pull cuts, and I was unable to see evidence of tear outs. I did, however, experience a couple of "catches"--or should I say involuntary dig-ins--that left grooves that had to be shaved away.

The round-headed cutter is great for cleaning up the interior surface of a deep bowl. If I owned one, that's what I'd use it for.

The round cutter head stayed sharp to the end of the bowl and produced streamers of wood, just like a real gauge. The square cutter seemed to dull somewhat by the end of the process, although I could be wrong about that.

All in all, good tools, especially for those who struggle with tear-outs, but pricey and unlikely to sway those of us habituated to a good gauge to abandon it. A gauge delivers a degree of control, especially over wall thickness, that I could not match with these tools. But then again, I've barely used these tools. The bowl, though, looks good.

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#2

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Steve C

I have been using the round cutter for about a year and I am very happy with the tool. I use it mainly for finishing cuts on the interior of bowls and find it a great advantage for when fighting with difficult grain.

I would use it more often but I do not like the fact that I have to replace the cutters when they get dull rather than sharpening a gouge or scraper. Therefore, I tend to save the CiO for special situations or difficult cuts.

I will say that the customer service from the folks at Easy is exceptional. I had a minor problem with a stripped screw and and responded immediately and above my expectations.

Steve

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#3

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Eduardo Sarmiento

Well I have one also I made it myself,the bar is easy to make and the cutters are $1.40 each from world tooling(10 minimum) also they are easy to sharpen again with the diamond stone(woodcraft)also see the video of captain Neddie in you tube there you will see how to make and sharpen the tool,I ussually use the tool to make straigth boxes and it sure does the job very well,my2cents

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#4

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Larry

Do you have the web site for the Video?

Thanks

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#5

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Eduardo Sarmiento

Ill check on it and post the link here in a while ok?

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#6

Eduardo Sarmiento

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Eduardo Sarmiento

Go to youtube and look under capneddie you will find some videos in there he is pretty sharp for tooling and to find cut-ways lol

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#7

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Fred Holder

I've been using the Easy Rougher and the Easy Finisher for over a year. Do I use them exclusively, no! However, for a beginning turner these tools would be invaluable. The learning curve is very short and they do a good job. They do not cut as smooth as a skew or a sharp bowl gouge, but they do it quickly and with a minimum of skill required to do some pretty complex things. For someone who has problems sharpening they are a godsend. So you have to replace the cutter after much use. The cutters are fairly inexpensive and they do last a long time if you don't treat them badly like turning the chuck or dropping them on a concrete floor.

I purchased my Easy Roughers at the desert woodturning roundup in Mesa, Arizona last year and the Easy Finisher at Craft Supplies later in the year. For a skilled woodturner, they may not add much. But I believe for beginner woodturners who have trouble sharpening and less than perfect tool control that they are worth every cent they cost.

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#8

I think I'm missing something

wilbur

I haven't had a chance to try out the Easy Rougher or similar tools, but based on the photos and the info on their website, they seem to be a sharp narrow scraper that holds its edge for a very long time since it's made out of carbide.

I also find that for me, all things being equal, a gouge will leave a smoother finish with less tearout than the scraping tools I've used.

So what is it about the Easy Rougher tools that allows them to do so well with leaving little tearout, as Aage reports?

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#9

Aage Rendalen

Re: I think I'm missing something

Aage Rendalen

Wilbur, this is not a scraper tool. It cuts like a gouge, and the round-headed cutter produces long streamers in green wood. The engineers among us would be able to explain that part better than me. When I looked at my bowl today, after letting it dry for a day, I was less impressed with what I saw immediately after finishing it. In the end grain area there were some torn fibers I didn't see last night. It probably indicates that you can't entirely forget about grain direction, the way I at first thought.

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#10

Re: I think I'm missing something

wilbur

What is it about the tool that makes it cut like a gouge? In the videos on the Easy Rougher website it certainly looks like it's being presented to the wood like a scraper might, and from my understanding of what the cutter is, it has a similar geometry. It would be a very small scraper, like if I took one of my normal sized scrapers and ground down the business end so that it would be 1/4" wide or so, but a scraper nonetheless.

Sorry if I'm being really dense here, but clearly there's something probably really simple that is zooming right over my noggin.

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#11

Re: I think I'm missing something

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Not to start an argument, but they do cut like a scraper, because that is what they are. A well sharpened scraper will produce shavings on spindles as well as bowls. A well handled gouge will do a better job though. The problem is, a well handled gouge takes longer to learn than a scraper.

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#12

Re: I think I'm missing something

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I agree Bill...I've used the tool. The mfgr. sent one to our club and I had it for a month. Yes, it peels off wood, especially wet wood, but it's still a scraper and does not leave a surface like a gouge will.

Wally

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#13

Re: I think I'm missing something

john lucas

I agree with Wally and Bill. It is just a scraper with a sharper angle on the edge than most scrapers so it cuts a little differently, more like laying a skew on it's side.

The cuts still aren't as clean as a well sharpened bowl gouge and certainly not as clean as a detail gouge sharpened at 35 or 40 degrees.

The biggest advantage of a bowl gouge, control. You can get the arcs perfect with the bowl gouge and some skill. With the easy rougher you sneak up on the shape. In skilled hands you can still get there with the easy rougher but I find it much easier with the bowl gouge.

The advantage of the easy rougher. No learning curve whatsoever. You don't have to learn to sharpen and you don't have to learn tool control. Personally I think that's sad because sooner or later you will need the bowl gouge or spindle gouge to do certain cuts and you will not have developed the skills for tool control or getting a good edge on the tool.

It's kind of like riding a 3 wheel motorcycle. Anyone can do it and they will have the fun of getting out on the open road. However they miss leaning into the curves and the ability to go fast around corners or what we used to call "walking the dog" which is swerving left and right in your lane kind of like your dancing. It's not just beating out a bowl with a course tool. It's more about the whole experience of dancing with the tool and feeling like your in control.

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#14

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Clay Johnson

Hey guys

I think the thing that Easy Wood Tools are trying to do is make a tool that is "EASY TO USE" Not all people have the knack of riding the bevel, shear scraping (oops I used that word) But we as woodturners need to get more people involved in woodturning.

This is not a sales pitch even though we sell them here. But if we can get more people, young kids or anyone else excited about turning then we have started the process. Let'em scrape, scrape, scrape. Let them get the feel and excitement that we did the first ugly bowl we made. (I still make some every now and then). But the main thing is they are turning. Once they get hooked on turning then show them how to ride the bevel. Make them ache to turn the next bowl and see the difference from the first one they turned.

Rude Osolnik got me started in woodturning 20 years ago and thank God for him. What a treat to take a chunk of wood and actually make something beautiful out of it. Put on that first coat of finish and the grain jumps out and makes you want to slap your grandma.....

I love to turn what I want to turn and if I can get a person excited about turning like I first was then MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!!!!!!

Thanks for reading

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#15

Steven Antonucci

Can you rub the bevel?

steven antonucci

I'm not sure it can't be used cutting, guy? I think that if you presented it properly that you might be able cut with a supported bevel? I'm not sure which one is which these days, since there seem to be a bunch of knock-offs of every tool on the market, but the cutters with the 'lip' make me think of a hook or a ring tool...

The flat ones are scrapers, though.

S

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and Ci1

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: A one-bowl review of the Easy Roughers Ci0 and

Mike Stafford

I recently had the opportunity to try both the Easy Rougher and Easy Finisher. I concur with what Fred said; they are great tools for beginners to use who have no skills and want a quick and dirty introduction to woodturning.

I recently had a student who was too stubborn and too afraid to learn to use a bowl gouge and I was afraid the student would get injured. No matter what I did this person would not introduce the gouge is a sensible manner. I introduced the Easy Rougher and Easy Finisher and the student had immediate success. Within a few minutes the student was turning with a big smile on their face.

After a few sessions I was then able to reintroduce the gouge as they had actually learned something about tool presentation and feed rate. And they had done it without injuring themselves.

I would never suggest that either of these tools are going to replace a good bowl gouge or even a scraper in skilled hands but they do provide an alternative for the beginner.