Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

Posts

Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

#1

Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

charlie belden

Growing Pains and Merely Impressions of Impropriety

Associations often start out small and informal � a group of folks with a shared interest get together to exchange ideas and information to the benefit of all. After a while �members� bring in other interested folks, and other folks who find out about the �association� ask to be a part of it . The informal association grows. And as it does, things begin to get complicated � just in terms of the space needed for meetings and the need to communicate with members.

Then things like newsletters and rent and utilities become and issue � and dues are often necessary. And once you introduce money into the process things like Fiduciary Responsibility and Liability come up. That�s when setting up some type of Legal Entity gets looked into � which typically involves a lawyer � and a lot of documents and forms to fill out and file with someone. � and fees to be paid for services.

A corporation gets set up � a non-profit, not-for-profit or for-profit legal entity. INC., LLC and LLP letters rear their heads, each with its own set of rules and regulations � and the scrutiny of �regulators�.as well as �share holders�. Bylaws and Mission Statements must be developed and �filed�, a Board selected or elected � all sorts of details need to be put in writing � meeting minutes, letters of intent, memorandums of understanding � the list goes on and on.

Should the Association, now maybe with Inc. connected to it, be successful and grow large enough, significant amounts of money get involved � revenue AND expenses. Now there�s probably a need for some paid specialists � an office manager, and a bookkeeper � at the very least. And someone must be designated to write checks and make deposits. Authorization requirements for check writing has to be worked out � and written down � part of the Public Record.

At various points along the way, two areas of possible contention come up � one having to do with money � and the other about direction (where do we want to go?).

Resource Allocation and Direction � two frequent sources of potential conflicts/ disagreements.

It�s the former that �regulators� keep an eye on � watching for Misallocation of Funds. It�s the latter that dues paying members are often most interested in.

Now �regulators� are suspicious folks by nature and by training. Their job is to be watchdogs � to look for potential impropriety � and possible prosecutable violations of the laws governing corporations � and for potential Conflicts of Interest � by the Board and the Executives of the corporation � EDs, CFOs, CEOs and a host of other letters for job titles.

Once you start spending member�s money (dues) you never want to give these folks even the impression of impropriety, even if NOTHING IMPROPER is actually being done. The mere impression of impropriety can trigger investigations which can be very time consuming and expensive to deal with � even if , in the end, the investigation is dropped because no actual impropriety occurred. And a rumour mill amongst members can quickly create a problem even if there actually is no problem to begin with.

Lets look at an example of how the Impression of Impropriety might come up.

A CEO or CFO awards a competitive bid contract to a relative and writes and signs a company check to that relative upon satisfactory completion of the contract with that person. And let�s say that relative � has the same last name as the CEO or CFO. And let�s say that the person with the same last name even underbid everyone else who submitted a bid for the contract � because he or she knew some of the glitches that can come up, having dealt with such things before � and had already worked out solutions to those problems so Contingency Costs weren�t in her or his bid.

And let�s say he�s also an altruist who believes in the organization that�s hired him. He wants it to succeed and therefore willingly donates some of his time and energy to that end � over and above what he must do to meet his contract obligations.

For an outsider, be it a regulator or a dues paying member of the incorporated Association, and with little if any of the facts, nor any idea of the intentions, the Impression of Impropriety could be reached. The dues paying member(s), lacking any details of what ACTUALLY happened and why, could jump to an unfounded conclusion � given the mere Impression Of Impropriety.

When you�re In The Public Eye, you have to be almost overly cautious when it comes to giving even the Impression of Impropriety. It goes with the territory, like it or not. When it comes to potential Conflicts of Interest, the maxim �When In Doubt � DON�T� is a prudent choice. It�s sad, but true.

Then there�s the Direction Thing.

What may have started as a loose affilitation of folks with a common interests, who might also be or become good friends, changes as the affiliation / association grows in membership. At some point the mere size, both in membership as well as spatial distribution of members , can begin to present �challenges�. � one being diversity of interests and focus.

While diversity is, in general, a very good thing, it can also be a source of potential conflicts � one group wanting to go in the direction of their personal interests, perhaps to the detriment of the interests of other members. One group may want to branch out and build the organizations reputation amongst other similar organizations while another group may want to keep things as they are. One may want to focus on K.I.S.S. (Keep It Simple Stupid) while another group may want to make the organization pre-eminent in its field of interest.

One of the critical periods for an organization is the transition from Start Up to Mature Established Organization , especially if one or more of the founders is still actively involved.

It�s understandable that a Founder, having been there for the birth of the entity, and been an active participant in the raising of that entity, might view things as a parent who wants only the best for their offspring. And anyone who has been a parent is probably aware of some of the pitfalls of trying to do what you think is best for your child � even when he or she is in their mid twenties, or little closer to thirty.

At some point a parent has to Let Go, or deal with the consequences of NOT letting go. Like it or not, kids do grow up � and become independent of parents � to a greater or lesser extent. How the transition from Parent/Child to Equals goes often determines the future of both the parent and the �child� and their relationship. It can be a knife edge situation for the �parent� � a fine line between guiding and suggesting and dictating and controlling � as a change in the balance of power occurs.

It isn�t any easier for the former child � now adult son/daughter � wanting to start making his/her own choices/decision. Getting advice from someone who is older, with more experience � and perhaps wiser � is usually a good idea. But ultimately the New Blood must learn to make decision and live with the consequences � good or bad. And some of those decision may not be the best, or may not initially be seen as good ones. Time will tell � and regardless of the outcome, something of value can be learned from the experience � so subsequent decisions may be better.

The alternative? The Founder or Parent dies � the company/family breaks up and stops being � a company or family.

No company/ association/ family should rest soley on one set of shoulders. After a while, it ultimately isn�t good for the person with the shoulders, nor the company/ assocation/ family.

Growing up often involves growing pains. Just a part of the process. But they pass and we grow up � and hopefully everyone gets wiser � and better.

Just something to consider - or not.

Re: Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

#2

Ellis Walentine

If I might paraphrase...

Ellis Walentine

... I think this is the condensed version of what you said, Charlie.

As associations grow, they get more complicated, legally and administratively. Strategic direction and allocation of resources are two of the main concerns of large organizations and their elected leaders. Allocation of funds must be carefully controlled and not present the appearance of impropriety.

As organizations mature, they need to cede oversight responsibility to new stewards, who may or may not embrace and/or embody the founding vision of the organization, but who, nonetheless, are vested with the responsibility for defining and directing the way forward. Mistakes and false starts are to be expected and should be instructive.


Like you, I prefer to wait and see how the board will react to the recent controversy, which is why I have not ventured my opinions one way or the other. I have known Mary Lacer for a long time and think very highly of her. As to whether she is the executive that the organization needs going forward, I must defer to the custodians of the direction of the group to make that determination.

Personally, as a longtime member and an interested observer, I would think this episode might spark a review of the corporate mission statement and how it coincides with the makeup of the organization and the personal interests and objectives of the members, with the understanding that those interests may evolve over time. Ultimately those interests and objectives should form the guiding principles of the organization.

I've given a bit of thought to the AAW's mission, and its complexity continues to astound me. This is a group of people bound by a common love of wood and the craft of turning, in all its forms. The local chapters serve perhaps the most important function for members, by providing local, hands-on sharing of experience and demonstrations of basic technique. At the national level, the organization seems to be more concerned with professional development, collector relations, and the more advanced techniques associated with production, embellishment and sculptural extensions to the basic craft of turning. I'm not sure where else it *can* go. Once you've mastered the basics of bowls and vessels and spindles and such, there's not much left under the sun of conventional turning. For the craft itself to proceed, it almost necessarily must extend beyond the basics, into the realm of sculpture, beyond function and form and into fine art. It seems to me that the AAW is a clearinghouse for turners and collectors to converge in their exploration and appreciation of new and novel forms of decorative art that continue to emerge from the primordial soup of lathe turning. The question is, when is it no longer woodturning?

A lot of turners don't identify with anything beyond "brown and round," perhaps because they don't have the kind of artistic/creative vision or the adventurous personality needed to delve further into the sculptural possibilities of the turned object. That's okay, and the organization needs to acknowledge and support these members' interests as well, with the understanding that they may admire a lot of the more fanciful and advanced techniques, but they might never be interested in pursuing them. Frankly, after witnessing the Instant Gallery's progression over the years, I am more intimidated and awestruck than inspired by a lot of that stuff. I don't have the patience or the motivation to go that far past the lathe.

I have not been privy to the history of the mission dialogue of the AAW, so I'm probably just repeating things that have already been hashed out ad nauseam in the past. That's part of the reason I don't usually feel compelled to jump into these conversations. But, in light of the divisive talk of the past week, I don't mind adding my plea for a frank and open dialog among and between the members and the board of directors, to try to recapitulate the overall mission of the group, define the role and the qualifications of the executive director, and move ahead with an agenda that meets all the design requirements -- not a coup, not a mass exodus, not a lynching, just a reasonable conversation about where we are and where we want to go from here and a restoration of confidence in the people we've chosen to direct the group.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

#3

Barb Siddiqui

AAW Mission Statement, evolving?

Barb Siddiqui

I agree with Ellis whole heartedly. Here is a copy of a post I put up in answer to Andi Wolfe's subject line 'Professionalism vs. Elitism' on the AAW messageboard:

Being a rank amateur at wood turning, I'd like to add an idea into this mix Andi has brought up, and that is that I consider there is some responsibility on the part of new members and beginners to find and utilize all the resources our professional members have made available, both on the website and in person, through affiliation with the AAW.

It is only natural that those professionals, who have been around the club for many years, will take the lead in doing what needs to be done to run the organization. It also seems reasonable to believe they would want to advance the organization and move it forward step by step into a more and more professional vision. What is overlooked by critics of this movement is that they've already left a long trail of provided resources to guide and bolster new members and beginners.

One of the first things I did as a new member a few years ago was purchase the paperback book collections of previous articles from the Journal, both to my benefit in learning a new craft, and to the club's benefit in adding to the coffers to run it. I am ever thankful for those collections of information. Nick Cook, John Lucas, Russ Fairfield, all these 'old guys' have done beginner's articles for years, and they are still available and being added to all the time.

I also think the criticized 'movement toward elitism' is a natural progression of turners developing new ideas and pushing their skill sets after mastering the basics. We don't all have to follow their direction, and probably shouldn't, but it sure is fun to see where their creative minds lead them next.

The new look of the Journal is an improvement, and its focus is to cover what is current among its active members. I think Betty Scarpino is doing a wonderful job of balancing both sides, the practical and the 'over-the-top' as some see it. American Woodturner is one of the few magazines I receive that I'm inspired to read cover to cover, as every article presents at least something of interest. If a reader is only interested in pen-turning, then they may have to look elsewhere, but seeing what is currently popular in galleries world-wide is a sure inspiration to push me into techniques I wouldn't have thought to try otherwise.

So, I don't see this as 'elitism.' I see this forward movement as a natural progression of advanced creativity. It is up to the beginner or amateur, even an advanced amateur, to make use of all the resources so generously made available by our professional members. I, for one, appreciate them very much!

Re: Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

#4

You Might Indeed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Whats the line "A little revolution is good now and then"?

Looking at the AAW's operating plans, it does appear that the original set of rules, well enough suited to a group of several hundred in the pre-Internet era, are due for some serious reconsideration given the size and expanded scope of the organization's efforts. As I've told a number of my clients, you can't run a $150 million-a-year interstate wholesale business like you would a push cart selling apples on the street corner.

A big challenge will be finding people with the knowledge and commitment to move the enterprise into the next stage while retaining its essential character.

Re: Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

#5

Ceramics Made The Craft To Art Transition

charlie belden

Ceramics, having already made the transition from "craft" to "art", may be a model to look into. I suspect that some of the issues ceramics dealt with are similar to what "turning" is coming up on. And they were dealing with three major approaches - slab, coil and thrown. Ceramics of course already had an existing collectors demand, initially for antiques - probably Chinese porcelaiins - and likely Euro pieces - created for the Hapsburgs. And antique ceramic pieces were already in museums and galleries.

The transition to acceptance of, and a market for, contemporary works must've had some challenges which they seem to have overcome. Ceramic has also expanded to include "surface treatments" beyond just glazes - non-functional objects

The Studio Furniture Movement is in the processes of expanding beyond function and could be another model to investigate if the AAW were to transition towards "art".

Re: Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropriet

#6

Re: Growing Pains & Merely Impressions of Impropri

Bill Neddow

Charlie, Ellis, Barb: Your comments are so wonderfully expressed!