Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Bowl hollowing problem

Posts

Bowl hollowing problem

#1

Bowl hollowing problem

Starry S Chan

I notice that my bowls are out of round after hollowing the inside. The rim thickness is not the same and the difference can be as much as 2mm.

These are 6" to 8" green bowls. I use face plate to cut the outside shape and use a tenon and a chuck to reverse mount the bowl for hollowing the inside. The tenon is 3/16" and I do make sure that the chuck jaws rest flat on the tenon shoulder.

What can be the possible cause of this?

TIA for your answers and tips.

Starry

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#2

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Green bowls can warp as you turn them. Wet them as you turn them to slow down drying.

Bill

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#3

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

Fred Holder

When turning bowls from wet wood, you will have a constant problem with warpage, which can cause the problem that you describe. However, I should note, that when you turn the outside of a bowl on a faceplate and then reverse it onto a chuck or even another faceplate, it is always necessary to re-turn the outside again even if the mounting seems perfect. This is necessary even if the wood is dry.

In fact, on wet wood it is a good idea to work both inside and outside together until the final thickness is reached at the rim. Then, you move deeper and repeat the process, but you do not go back to the rim area. A fellow in one of the clubs that I belong to turns all of his bowls from wet wood and final turns them at one setting. He turns bowls in the 14 inch to 36 inch size. He does the shaping and hollowing by turning outside and inside as he moves down the bowl wall. This is what you need to do to prevent your problem.

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#4

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

robo hippy

Only 2 mm of movement? Not extreme in any case. I turn green to final thickness. Turn the outside first, then reverse for the inside. I turn to about 1/4 to 3/8 inch thick, wrap the rim in some stretch plastic film (compression and rounding the rim edges is a great help to prevent cracks), and let them warp. I have had madrone bowls end up being like footballs (13 by 9 inches, and height varying an inch or two). I seldom retrue the outside when I reverse. I can usually get it to less than 1/16 inch of wobble (last cut on the recess or tenon is a whisper cut where you just barely touch the wood), and that amount isn't visible unless you are trying to turn less than 1/8 inch thick. A 3/8 inch bowl can have that much variation in thickness as it drys (very little movement end grain, a lot side grain). I usually turn the inside in stages because it will move as you turn, and you can't go back. So, turn down an inch or so, finish it, then another inch or so, blend in and finish, all the way to the bottom. On smaller bowls in the 8 to 10 inch range, you can go back for one final cut, if you really want to.

robo hippy

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#5

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

GaryG in MD

Starry,

You have received good advice above. Here's my "take" on it...

I rough the outside first between centers and add a tenon for chucking.

Then I reverse into the chuck for hollowing. No matter how carefully you cut the tenon, the chuck jaws will crush it unevenly and lead to a slightly crooked mount. One way to help alleviate this is to bring up the tail center into the hole made by the spur center or steb center before you tighten the chuck jaws. That helps get as straight a mount as you can possibly get.

Some people even do some of the hollowing with the live tail center in place and work around it as long as possible before removing it and the big nub. I've done that in the past, but I find it frustrating and quit, just getting the most out of the centering before going on.

Even so, you'll probably find the need to slightly adjust the shape of the outside before (and possibly during) hollowing. Wood that you think is "dry" seldom is. I made a bowl out of a piece of cherry I had drying for years, and had to wait a day or two between turning the outside and the inside. The outside went oval, and I just left it that way -- with an oval outside and circular inside -- gives it some "interest" -- call it a "design feature" if asked! ;-)

Just remember the rule -- as Fred said -- once you have the rim thin, NEVER GO BACK (DAMHIK!).

...Gary

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#6

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

robo hippy

I heard once that when you use a tenon, especially on green wood, if you line up the jaws so that one pair is on the long grain, and the other is on the side grain, you will get uneven crushing of the fibers. There is little crushing on the end/long grain, and quite a bit on the side grain. Rotate the bowl 45 degrees so you are around the end grain rather than on it and that will solve a lot of that problem. I do this when I use a recess. don't know if it really works or not, but looks good on paper.

robo hippy

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#7

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

Allen Neighbors

All good info, above, and all will work for you. Here's what I do, that works for me. When I finish turning the outside shape, I do use the tailstock to make sure I get the bowl reversed evenly in the chuck. Then I make the finish cuts on the outside, because it is almost never perfectly rounded to the chuck.

Then I begin turning the inside, and spray the outside with soapy water, from an old 409 spray-bottle. The soapy water helps to keep the outside from drying while I'm turning the inside. When it begins to look a little bit dry on the outside, I spray it again.

When finished turning the inside to thickness, I allow to dry a little bit while still in the chuck. Then I remount the chuck and bowl and sand. The soap makes the wood sand better, it smells nice, and it works for me. HTH.

Cheers, Al

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

#8

Re: Bowl hollowing problem

GaryG in MD

Excellent idea -- I'll have to give that a try -- thanks. ...Gary