Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Board of Directors

Posts

Board of Directors

#1

Board of Directors

Jim Rutten

Interesting. Ed was kind enough to provide me a link to the AAW by-laws and, if I am reading them correctly the only entity capable of removing a board member is board of directors. Talk about job security!

Re: Board of Directors

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: Board of Directors

Steve Kubien

Sounds as good as a Canadian Senate gig!

Re: Board of Directors

#3

Steven Antonucci

It's even worse than that

steven antonucci

Just read the bylaws and it turns out that ANY member in standing can submit themselves for consideration as a Board Member, however, the Nominating committee reviews those candidates and puts the slate that is available to the vote together.

Current nominating committee is:

1 Member who voted against Mary

1 non board member

1 replacement for Bill/Malcolm

Basically, they can put whoever they want and disqualify anyone for any reason.

We've got some governance issues, for sure.

Steve

Re: Board of Directors

#4

why is this so?

Ken Grunke from SW Wisconsin

Just read Alan Lacer's post and his point revealing the same thing. Here is the major flaw in the bylaws that allowed all this nonsense to happen.

But did anyone show any concern or outrage about this in the past? Couldn't this and other similar previous events have been prevented with more proper bylaws?

I don't get it.

Re: Board of Directors

#5

Re: It's even worse than that

Stuart Johnson

What happens now? The bylaws say:

1 director

1 former director

1 member that has never served as a director.

The nominating committee has 2 directors.

Re: Board of Directors

#6

Re: It's even worse than that

Fred Bearman (Port Huron, Michigan)

In reading the bylaws it is apparent that the membership of AAW no longer has any control over their organization, other than paying their dues. There is no means specified for removal of any of the directors by the membership, but rather the only way a director (or officer) can be removed is by a vote of the Board of Directors. Even worse, the bylaws may be changed at the whim and "wisdom" of the Board of Directors, such amendment only being required to be submitted to the membership if the majority of the board of directors feel that is necessary. Under similar circumstances, and with similar bylaws, a local nonprofit health organization made the most frightening change - they changed the way the board of directors was to be elected, from the membership voting to only the board of directors voting for any future directors. Is this the future for AAW?

I'm not a lawyer, didn't play one on TV, and did not sleep in a Holiday Inn Express last night, but I would hope that there may be some violation of the bylaws in how it seems that certain directors met privately to arrange all of this, which does not seem to be allowed by the bylaws, and in that may lie any hope that the members have of reclaiming their association. (I know, there is no proof of a private meeting, which doesn't seem to be allowed in the bylaws, but it seems that the majority came into the meeting for the vote to terminate Mrs. Lacer fully prepared, including apparently contracts with a search organization, a temporary executive, and replacements for the dissenting board members. If all that can materialize instantaneously, then maybe they have some advice for industry in this country.)