See Alan Lacer's Post On The AAW Forum!
Barbara Gill
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
See Alan Lacer's Post On The AAW Forum!
Barbara Gill
Definitely Worth A Read!
George Guadiane
copy of Aaan Lacer's letter
Matt Overton
Mary Lacer�s Conflict of Interest
As my name has been brought into this event I have to bring things out in the open, into the sunshine. One of the �charges� against Mary that is now being recounted to those contacting the board is that of conflict of interest with me. At her dismissal session of approximately 3 minutes she was told nothing. Here are the facts, you decide.
1. In 2009 I was asked by the Chair of the Exhibitions Committee to submit a bid to transport a show to a venue in Oklahoma. Linda VanGehuchten was that chair. She obtained three bids, with mine (as I recall) being significantly lower than the others.
2. I rented a UHAUL, paid for hotel room, gas, meals, and my commercial insurance�and two days (at least) of my time. I was paid an amount that led to a loss of approximately $400. I was only paid a rate that did NOT include any pay for my time (my shop rate is $65/hour). Also, costs were only for a one-way part of a round trip 1800+mile event. Is it a conflict of interest where I lost money?
3. At last year�s symposium in New Mexico, Linda VanGehuchten was forced to resign from the board. One of the charges against her was this same issue�she should have taken this before the board. Linda thought she had done it correctly with multiple bids. Is she guilty of corruption or in bad faith---or just not understanding all the rules? Did her actions hurt the AAW? Interestingly, the same core board members that terminated Mary also put out that Linda V. �stepped down� from the board�same language as describing what happened to Mary on the AAW home page. See a pattern? Mary was fired, Linda was forced to resign or �they would vote her off the board.� Did you know that the AAW is the ONLY major craft organization in North America that allows board members to remove duly elected or appointed board members? See the risk for politics and corruption? Same is true of the AAW bylaws: the only major craft organization in North America that allows boards to change the by-laws: the norm is that ONLY the members can change the bylaws. It would be as if the US Congress could readily change the constitution as they see fit�boy, would we be in even deeper stuff if that were the case. Both of these situations need to be rectified.
4. The board is trying to get a two-for-one with this event, using the same situation to remove Linda and now Mary.
5. Mary DID NOT hire me to transport the show. She probably signed the check (the check was written by the bookkeeper) after the work had been performed. I did not ask for payment though until many months later�shows my greed does it not?
6. Binh Pho was fully aware of the details of this situation. I called him after the NM conference to set the record straight. Binh, why did you not clarify this to the board? You can breach ethics and legal issues by �looking the other way��I sincerely hope Binh has another explanation.
7. Binh asked me why I would do something for a financial loss. I told him I was a bad businessman and a bit crazy. In reality this was my time and financial donation to the AAW exhibitions efforts that I do dearly support and profoundly believe in that effort.
8. In the same conversation with Binh I recounted the story of his friend, Frank Sudol. Some years back the AAW Board hired me to manage the Back To Nature show. In the wrap�up of the travelling show, Fedex damaged work made by Frank Sudol. In many exchanges with Fedex their legal department said they would pay nothing. Out of a deep sense of personal responsibility I wrote Frank a personal check for $4500. I am not a wealthy man and this was a large part of my income for that year. Within two years a considerate board repaid me (without interest). As Binh seemed a bit incredulous about this I will locate and send Binh the cancelled and signed check to Frank. How many current board members would have gone this far?
See a pattern evolving yet? Over the years I have donated thousands of hours and thousands of dollars to the AAW since being in the room at Arrowmont when it started in 1985. Guess what? So has Mary Lacer. We have often purchased things or used our own money or volunteered � because it might look bad. We have been acutely aware of even the perception of conflict of interest.
On a related matter, last fall I encountered a rumor while teaching in the Missouri area. It seems someone on the board or close to the board put out a rumor that Mary Lacer was hiring Alan to review articles for the journal at somewhere in the range of $45 to $75 /hour. The implication (and possibly stated) was that we were �working the system� --code for �embezzling.� I have worked under four different editors of the journal and reviewed countless (I�m sure over 100) articles written by others. Guess what, my pay was $0. Mary never hired anyone for the journal, that is the role of the editor. You may not know but an outside auditor audits the AAW books yearly and a bookkeeper maintains the books. The board�s reaction to this rumor was not to ask who started it but to ask�is it true? The words of Carl Voss, Mary and myself counted for nothing. New board member, Warren Carpenter was directed to review the records going back many years. Warren, tell us what you found � he found nothing. They have made a scandal about what I was paid since 1995 (after I left the board) for my paid services from the editors. In truth I was paid approximately less than 1/4th what some magazines have paid me as a Contributing Editor. I did this out of my love for the AAW, not the great wealth I was building. Many seem to forget that I have a life in the woodturning community/world independent of my wife, Mary, and the AAW. Does that count for anything? One major magazine removed all contributing editors when they were sold�but one: me. Give me some credit; I don�t need my wife to give me work!
Those who know the source of that rumor are keeping it under their hats and will not tell me WHO. If any of you have heard such rumors please tell me the content, who said it and where and when. Send that information to my attorneys Dewey, Chettam and Howe. How would you have reacted to a situation involving you?
So, what about untrue allegations? What about board members who look the other way? What about not sharing the allegations�that are now being told to members�with Mary so she could have defended or explained?
Do you see patterns in Mary, myself or the board? You decide.
Alan Lacer, AAW Member #300
Re: copy of Aaan Lacer's letter
Dick Hines
Well.that really screws the pooch. Now let us all see what the AAW has to say for them selves.
AAW I for one am waiting to hear the other side of the story. I am not holding my breath.
Re: copy of Aaan Lacer's letter
Mike from Saint Clair Shores
Alan's reply more than convinces me that we need to shake up the AAW. I feel terrible that all of this has transpired within an organization that I have thoroughly enjoyed belonging to for the last 7 years. In all that time I know of no other person who has worked harder than Mary Lacer. This just stinks and if the board was smart(20/20 smart) they would reconvene and undue the wrong the has been done. This will not go away and our AAW will suffer immensely for their pompous actions.
Hold your breath, because this thing stinks!
steven antonucci
Re: Dick- it is not the AAW that.......
JamieDonaldson
....owes us an explanation, but the out of control "gang of 6" Board members we should be hearing from. We members are the AAW, and we have been hijacked! 
Re: Dick- it is not the AAW that.......
Barbara Gill
Jamie, how can the membership get rid of them without waiting for their term to expire?
Re: Dick- it is not the AAW that.......
bill crommett
Barbara: It may be drastic, but if all the members would put their dues in escrow and demand a constitutional convention, the board would find themselves in a libelous situation they could hardly afford not to comply with. It would be very interesting if the editor was denied the funds to continue with the WOODTURNER and the board would demand to be paid per diem and travel expenses to the board meetings.
700
George Guadiane
Barbara,
If we can get 5% of the membership to get together AND AGREE we can make whatever laws we want and the board will have to accept them.
I'm not saying it would be easy, but I'd drive a couple of hundred miles to make the scene.
Re: 700
Mike Stafford
One of the things that bothered me was last year when they changed the voting format from electronic to mail-in ballot.
I think they understood human nature and by changing the voting format they knew that people by nature are lazy and would not go to the trouble to send in their ballot. I wonder what percentage of the membership bothered to vote. A reduced ballot count almost certainly favors the "activist" contingent who seem to have taken power.
Probably the best way to change things now is to get some different candidates on the ballot and then get out the vote. Vote the entire board out and start anew.
I would like to see Jamie Donaldson and a few others on the ballot next year so we have board members who participate in the various turning forums where most of us meet. With the exception of Malcolm how many of the other board members ever participate in the mainstream turning forums such as WoodCentral, WoW, etc. I can't recall any instances of hearing from many of them.
Occasionally you will see a message from on high which is usually a reprint of an article or letter by the president on the AAW board and forum but not very often. It might be beneficial if board members actually participated in the on line activities where most turners congregate and find out what is on our minds.
Re: Some of us are having discussions...
JamieDonaldson
...,preliminary for now, about a recall vote of the sitting BOD members as Malcolm suggested in his resignation letter.It would require 5% of the membership, or about 650 affirmative votes. I'm at a show this weekend, but next week we will discuss this plan further and attempt to lay out a plan of action. I would like to see Mary, Malcolm and Bill reinstalled in their respective positions as a start if they are willing. Then an interim Board could be appointed until legal elections can be held.
I will talk to NJ and Water Gap Woodturners
steven antonucci
And I will bring all 50-60 AAW members votes with me if you guys can get this rolling.
I suggest that other concerned AAW members rally their local support as well.
Steve
Re: Dick- it is not the AAW that.......
Dick Hines
I am not holding my breath until I get any information from the either. This whole thing was a setup.
Re: Some of us are having discussions... *LINK*
Stuart Johnson
This might be tricky. The way I read the by laws 5%+ can request a special members meeting. Once that is done 5%+ or about 650 members must show up for there to be a quorum for business to be conducted. Proxies are allowed for voting but I don't think having the proxies is the same thing as having a quorum. If that is correct then at least 5% of the general membership must be willing to travel to the meeting. Once that number is reached then you have to take into account the number of proxies held by the 650 versus those held by the BOD.
I'm no legal expert but the only place I see for making amendments to the the bylaws is section 14.01 which gives the BOD the power. Major revisions must be approved by the general membership. I also don't see any provision for recalling a director other than by the BOD voting removal.
AAW Bylaws
Re: Some of us are having discussions...
bill crommett from Seneca
Stuart has it right> The situation can only be corrected by a new constitution that changes the rigid and excessive control of the BOD.
Your Discussions
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Need to include a review of the AAW Articles of Incorporation, not (so much) the By-Laws. It is in the Articles where you will find the power, as a constituted corporate quorum meeting, to effect the Board, elections, recall of directors, etc. By-laws are day-to-day operational and procedural rules. The Articles hold the real power. The A/C may be on file with the Minnesota Secretary of State, will have been filed with the IRS for the 501(c)(3) application, and must be made available to any member in good standing.
Re: Your Discussions
Stuart Johnson
Thanks Mark.
PS
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
When y'all convene your "Constitutional Convention" you'd best get some real legal advice on what you can and can't do. If you start your redrafting of either the Articles or the By-Laws, you do want to check with the IRS and counsel to make sure that what you propose to do doesn't result in violation and loss of the Section 501(c)(3) charitable exemption.
Loose that, the AAW is "dead meat."
Somebody best get ready to lay out some coin for all of this, but know that it's not going to be cheap.