First off, let me say that I have no "inside" information about the AAW Board's decision to terminate Mary Lacer as Executive Director. Further, I do not play politics.
So let me say that I would ask all AAW members to refrain from any hasty action until such time as these events are fully finalized. After speaking with an attorney about such matters, I was informed that if the Board of Directors has entered into a non-disclosure agreement, they are legally bound from saying absolutely anything until Mary has made her decision as to whether or not to accept the severance package or decline. Customarily such decisions must be made and finalized within 30 days. So, all I'm asking is for everyone to do 2 things:
1. Keep your ears open, and,
2. Do not stir up any more trouble until ALL the facts are really known.
If, after 30 days, you are still unhappy with this decision, you have an excellent way of relaying this to the Board ... just don't re-elect them!
So, my call for Reason ... none of what I've read or heard so far has enough factual evidence behind it to allow me to make an informed decision. I may never have enough evidence for that matter, especially if the Board members who made this decision are legally estopped from providing such facts.
So, please, let us calm down, bite our collective tongues, and wait to see what happens. I am certain that "the other shoe has not yet dropped".
The firing of anyone in a non-profit organization is always a traumatic event.
I agree that we should all take a deep breath before passing judgement. All of these messages of outrage are based on hearing only one persons side of the story and written with the assumption that every one else is wrong. We may never know the real or imagined reasons for the Board actions. Personally, I am going to wait until I hear both sides of the story before passing judgement.
This is not the first of the traumatic events in the AAW history, and I suspect it won't be the last. The AAW almost disappeared in its early years when the President stole all of the funds just after the annual renewals had been paid. More recently, about 5 years ago, were the actions of a few of the Directors that prompted several resignations and the formation of an Ethics Committee.
Russ, You're right except that it was the treasurer who made off with the funds and not the president. He left Texas, where he lived and moved to Orcas Island in the San Juans in Washington state. I know this because the board members who were on their way to confront him stopped in to talk to me. I lived in Bellevue, Wa at the time. The AAW was only a year or two old at the time.
Currently, the only "course of action" would be to resign... I'm not there yet.
Looking at the limited information available, deductive reasoning tells me that someone has something to hide. That alone is enough to annoy me.
The facts are that Mary was told she was leaving, define that how you like, the circumstances and manner by which Mary, Malcolm and Bill learned this was sufficient to have Malcolm and Bill resign on the spot.
I know I don't have ALL the "facts," but this sure LOOKS like a duck to me. What kind of duck is yet to be revealed but a duck for sure.
Russ, the "one side of the story" is from a respected and reliable source with no axe to grind that I can see. The fact that there have been problems in the past and that there is now an ethics committee doesn't help me much, there will always be problems and what relationship to the board does the ethics committee have are the chickens or the foxes guarding the hen house?
As a matter of safety, once things start to look bad (and they do) it seems perfectly reasonable, to me, to question everything and expect anything (well, maybe we would be foolish to expect full disclosure, unless that disclosure would vindicate the actions taken by the board).
Everyone has good reason to be upset and to view the actions of the board with suspicion. Yet, in fairness, we should also acknowledge the following salient fact: If the board were acting fairly and honorably, it's actions might well look exactly the same. This is not to imply any wrong doing on Mary Lacer's part. Indeed, it's possible for a board to determine that a change in personnel is appropriate without that change being prompted by any failures of the current employee.
Let's suppose that's the case here (if just for the sake of this discussion). What would be the proper way for the board to deal with such a situation? I'd advise my clients to bring in the person who's about to be replaced and inform her of the board's decision, explain to her the severance package available to her (and any conditions on her receipt of any part of the package), and then escort her from the premises. For her benefit, the board should offer to allow her to say she'd "stepped down" and the board should refuse to discuss the circumstances surrounding her leaving employment with the organization. Whether someone is being terminated for cause or just because the organization decided to go another direction, this is how terminations are handled in the professional world.
This appears to be what has happened in this case -- which is why I say we cannot tell from the board's actions whether or not the board acted in good faith or out of malice. Most importantly, the fact the board is silent provides us zero evidence about the board's motives. Nor does the fact Mary was blindsided by the board's decision. As a practical matter, it's seldom a good idea to let a senior executive know in advance that they're about to be let go. As a consequence, such decisions are almost always a surprise to the one being pushed out the door.
Lastly, while we know at least two board members were upset about Mary's firing, we don't know if they were privy to everything that went on. Board's often have one or more committees. For example, the executive committee might review the performance and compensation of each executive. The details of the committee's work may not be shared with the rest of the board. Instead, the rest of the board would receive a summary of the committee's work in the form of a report. Thus, it's possible the two dissenting board members may not know everything about the situation. It's also possible that, knowing everything, board members might feel so strongly that a decision is wrong that they'll resign even though the decision was made in good faith.
My point is we don't have all the information nor, for (possibly) good reasons, are we likely to get much more information. That being the case, it seems unwise to form firmly held and strong opinions.
You start out with the premise of "EXACTLY THE SAME and then go on to describe something completely different:
First of all, you make no conjecture about the underlying cause of the "decision." Then you say; "I'd advise my clients to bring in the person who's about to be replaced and inform her of the board's decision, explain to her the severance package available to her (and any conditions on her receipt of any part of the package), and then escort her from the premises." You don't mention that it was done without any kind of notice, in an odd location without the full advance knowledge of the whole acting board which implies that she needed to be ambushed.
Then you say; "For her benefit, the board should offer to allow her to say she'd "stepped down" and the board should refuse to discuss the circumstances surrounding her leaving employment with the organization." THAT'S not what happened. The first I saw, it was REPORTED (by a board person) that she had resigned. It was a lie directed by the board, NOT Mary.
And then "Whether someone is being terminated for cause or just because the organization decided to go another direction, this is how terminations are handled in the professional world." Always??? NO!
The boards silence doesn't prove anything, but the facts from reliable sources says LOADS. Malcolm and Bill QUIT after the ambush. They relinquished any opportunity to have any effect on AAW business. They have no dog in the fight.
I'm still going with this:
Look at the relationship to the board that the replacement has. I'm betting it will be more than casual and that the search company is nothing more than a smokescreen.
I understand that you're upset. You have a right to be. What I don't understand is what the two of us are disagreeing about nor why you should so misconstrue what I've written.
Let me try to be clear:
* I'm not defending the board's actions. I don't know whether I would agree with what was done even if I had access to all the information -- which I don't. It may well be the board acted incorrectly and all should be replaced and Mary rehired (assuming she'd take the job). We have plenty of reason for being suspicious.
* I'm ONLY saying nothing in the way Mary's firing was handled is out of the ordinary. If I were fired tomorrow, I'd expect to be dealt with in exactly the same manner. My termination would come as a complete surprise even though several other people (many of whom I consider friends) would know in advance. I would be escorted to my office and told to clean out my desk. I would then be escorted out of the building. I would be offered a generous severance package on condition of my agreeing to a non-disclosure agreement. If I chose not to sign the non-disclosure agreement, my severance package would be reduced (dramatically). All of this is standard practice. It's the way the termination of any senior executive in my firm would handled. The fact I'd be treated exactly the same as others would be treated (and as I've been forced by circumstances to treat others) would not lessen the embarrassment I'd feel nor would it prevent my friends and family from thinking I'd been wronged. But the knowledge of how other firms deal with the termination of a senior executive tells me there's nothing in the reports we've seen about what happened to Mary that is out of line with common practice.
Does your experience differ? In my professional life, I've advised corporations on how to terminate a senior executive. I've also advised clients who've gotten the axe. What's your experience?
* I'm NOT saying the board could not have handled things differently. Just because something is "standard practice" does not mean it's the only way to do the thing. They could have taken a kinder, gentler, approach. Escorting someone to her desk (or hotel room, in this case) is harsh. Not giving her any warning is unfair. Not providing any information seems overly secretive. Harsh, unfair, and overly secretive this approach may be; but it's also the approach most professionals would advise be taken.
It's the approach I would have advised the AAW take and for very good reasons. Disgruntled former employees (especially those who've just been fired) sometimes lash out and try to hurt their former employer. While rare, the risk is very real. The approach taken with Mary reduces that risk. While I doubt anyone would think Mary would do anything the hurt the AAW (just as I doubt anyone would think I'd do anything to hurt my firm), if the AAW did not follow this procedure with Mary, how would they be able to apply it in the case of another employee where there is a legitimate concern?
So, again, my only point is you cannot look at how Mary's firing was handled and from that conclude anything about the merits of her termination. (Well, of course, you could conclude anything you'd like to conclude. Your reasoning would just be unsound.)
Please don't take it personally. I don't think I know you beyond your words here which is all I can use to value you and I'm sure you have much more depth and diversity than I could glean from your thoughts on this topic. People who DO know me know I have strong beliefs and that I don't hold back. We just agree to disagree, till it comes to what I consider (I can't think of a better word) primordial moral issues come into play, then I just disengage.
For me, here, it boils down to this:
That a thing is "proforma" within (an) industry or at a level of business, doesn't make it right. Sexism, racism, all kinds of things in life were "just the way things are" till enough people said it had to stop... OK, it still hasn't COMPLETELY stopped, but it is now unaccepted and practiced by fewer people in fewer places (but I digress).
At some point people have to stand up for what we believe in, whatever that is for each of us. For me, "standard practice" is neither justification nor acceptable.
My experience? Self employed for the last 37 years. I don't play well with others who live by connivance. I'm sure I could have made a lot more money working in an industry and rising through the ranks, but I never liked or accepted the game you seem to have to play. I was rightfully fired for chronic lateness at my last "real" job (after failing at a rock n' roll career), but I had just had my first child and it was the last day before the Christmas holidays, I had to go to a restaurant to be fired, standing there while my boss ate and told me with his mouth full. Fortunately, I was already making more money buying and selling things at flea markets in my spare time, so the job couldn't have had much of a future.
I didn't realize it, but Mary faced a similar unexpected fate, probably part of my visceral response to all of this.
I do contract work at a better than decent day rate for people who all know me well and know me long enough to know MY rules for employment (and they like me and my skill set well enough to accept me on those terms). And I've never been fired in that set of circumstances, but I did ask to leave one job in the middle because of how their business was run - they wanted me to take advantage of customers, I don't do that.
I'm no angel. I've crossed my own lines before to my shame and regret, but I have lines and have always been willing to take the hits for what I believe. This is no different in my mind. For whatever it's worth, all things considered, I'd have to be in pretty dire straits to even consider taking the gag money. Values can't have a price tag and be values.
People like me who stand up against this COULD, in theory hurt themselves badly within the industry. People who hire demonstrators are powerful here, they can make or break even outstanding craftspeople to a certain degree. By simply ignoring them, administrators could really put a dent in the earning potential of people who go against them. I know that Malcolm is established, they would have a really difficult time hurting him, Bill I don't know or know about. Others may be staying quiet because they are fearful that when this all blows over, and it will, that there will be reprisals. I just don't care. I'd really LOVE to be famous, I have some pretty interesting ideas and I'm getting pretty good at implementing them. I'd enjoy the money and all that other stuff, but I can't trade myself in for that and for me, there is just no guarantee that if I did sell out that I could "make the grade."
And I should add here, that I have nothing against anyone who make choices different from mine based on their values... My issue comes when others think I have to just sit back and take their values as my own, without agreeing, without consideration, without knowing the why of my values. In this case, the actions taken impact me personally and other than protest and withdraw like Malcolm and Bill, there is little I can do.
I can only hope that by standing out and standing up I can get one or two more to take the risk next time till we reach critical mass and change happens.
And you're right, I CAN look at things any way I want to. Change comes when enough people see that the status quo is not acceptable. "They came for the..."
This isn't personal against you, it's just personal. So I'm sorry if I offended you.
Now, now, ladies and gentlemen, let's settle down and listen to "reason" as promulgated by the "oldtimers" and "beancounters", and "lawyers", and wait until the "cabal" deigns to make a public statement.
Or, you can make your thoughts known to the Board of Directors NOW because if they decide to NOT make a public statement, by the time you find that out, your fire will have dwindled just like they want. So send an email to the BOD and let them know that you support them, you don't support them, or whatever. But please don't sit on your hands like the living dead down here in Florida. That's how one of our recent Presidents got "appointed" by the Supreme Court.
Having recently gone through a process just like you were describing (they said my position was eliminated but it still felt like being fired) I agree with you totally but had a question for you. I was a sometimes telecommuter and had company equipment at my home. As far as this went they requested the equipment be available for pick up by a freight service (which is what happened) and that was that. I am thinking about Mary's case and think the "retreival of AAW owned items" from her hotel room (given hotel rooms are an extension of one's home) was a gross invasion of privacy. I wondered what you thought. I did think the timing very much approximated what goes on in business given the board canned her right after the symposium which no doubt had a ton of her work put in it.
I don't know what AAW equipment/property Mary may have had in her hotel room, so I can do nothing more than speculate on the appropriateness of going to her hotel room. In my experience, firms want anything that might give someone access -- keys, computers (with remote access capabilities), and the like.