When you CANNOT travel to JCC to learn to turn boxes from Mike Stafford you learn the hard way.
Turned from a piece of dry cedar given to me that you only got dust not chips.
I did not want to damage the soft box lip by gripping the outside and ruin fit so I used the jaws in expansion mode on the inside to finish the bottom!
I'm sure it is written somewhere not to do that????????
It would be very mean of you to assemble the box and leave it on a shelf for some unsuspecting person to come by and remove the lid. Don't do that. Resist that temptation.
Galen, I doubt there is a box maker around who has not tried that expansion technique at one time or another and gotten away with it. I am sorry it did not work for you.
My preferred method is to reverse turn the bottom on a jam chuck but you can split a box doing that as well.
I have also gripped the body flange in a compression mode using the chuck jaws and scratched/marred the body flange. I used to wrap the flange with blue painter's tape to prevent this. I now almost always use a jam chuck and (knock on wood) seldom have a failure.
I am sorry your box split. It is beautiful. You did a fabulous job. Turn another with some more dense wood and I believe you will be 100% successful. You were 99 and 44/100% this time.....Oh, that was Dial soap....right?
you know those rubber grippers that are used to loosen tough jars? I have used them instead of painters tape to grip more tender woods. It has worked very well for me. The cost is such that if you need to trim it down so it does not bunch up you can.
They used to give these away as promotional items. Just leave the one in the kitchen drawer for you wife (or make sure she doesn't see it in your shop)
Galen: You didn't do anything wrong except the last twitch of the jaw key. I have used the internal jaws on dry cedar many times, but I use the jaws more for centering and bring up a padded tailstock to keep the box in place while finishing off the bottom. The last touch is with a small disk sander.
Yes you picked up on one of my other faults. I am guilty of turning the inside to non-uniform wall thickness. Actually turning the inside it just was fine powder and I must have stopped a million times to suck out the dust and just stopped too soon.
Wonder if anyone ever made up a suction tube that could be run inside to evacuate the dust in this case, while turning?
Famous last words? I didn't think I turned the jaws that tight and had the tailstock up in place till I turned off the nub. I had actually completed the cut and it was enough removed it blew into pieces with a "nice" pop.
I guess I would have thought even that thin rubber would make the piece vibrate. Probably works for those who make the right light cut with a sharp tool.
I think I remember you had also told me you use the dovetail type jaws so if you grip the box lip it is applying the pressure down closer to the main box?
I'd still need the experience to know the jamb chuck was tight enough but not too tight to stress the piece. It only takes time right!
The bad part about this box was I had intended to give it to a former co-worker who retired today. Was so glad I was near done in time then it sure busted my pride! I had to fall back on another piece so it made it feel second best.
I once saw a tool made from a tube that could be hooked to a vacuum. Seems like it would clog most of the time unless the chips were fine or dust. You could easily rig a tool with a tiny air tube that would blow air into the piece and force at least some of it out the opening as long as the opening was big enough.
Galen, I do prefer to use dovetail profiled jaws if I am going to try and grip the flange but I seldom do that anymore.
I find it much easier to turn a jam chuck and with practice it is just as easy as the other methods and safer because you have a tenon inside the body and shoulder abutting the flange.
To turn a jam chuck you need to round up any softer scrap wood and then turn a tapered tenon. You continue to turn a taper until the body of the box will just begin to fit on the tenon. Once you determine the exact diameter upon which the body will fit it is just a matter of reducing the taper to the same diameter as the point where the body is a tight fit. You have to sneak up on it just like you do to jam fit the lid.
It is important to have a very snug fit with the top of the body flange tight against the shoulder of the tenon on the jam chuck. If you are not certain of your fit reduce the waste wood to the left of the box until it is the same diameter as the body flange and then use a bit of tape to secure the box to the jam chuck.
I also almost always used the tailstock in support until I remove nearly all of the waste on the bottom.
If you turn your jam chuck slightly too small you might try wetting it or if that fails use a piece of tissue. However if you have to use a section of a moving quilt for a tight fit it is best to recut the jam chuck....