Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Participatory Pieces

Posts

Participatory Pieces

#1

Participatory Pieces

charlie belden

For the most part, turned pieces are YOU LOOK, I SIT HERE. Of course, the really good turnings can evoke - or provoke - thoughts and feelings. But the piece is essentially static - and passive. The piece is not an ACTIVE participant in the interaction with its visitor or owner - except by implication.

As I delve into programmable "stamp controllers", I'm beginning to see how they can be utilized to make a piece that is an ACTIVE participant in its interaction with a being - human or otherwise. The piece can have a sense of touch, can see and hear - and can respond to what it can "see" and "hear" and "feel" - with light, sound and movement. Its "mood" can change based on what's going on around it, detected by its senses, albeit pretty primitive senses. A piece could be flashy and brash and loud one moment and calmer, more subdued and subtle the next moment. Different behaviors can be triggered by different conditions, each interaction with a person can be different - each time.

And it might be possible that pieces can have "behaviors" changed by changing the "program" - adding or subtracting - rearranging - perhaps by downloading "software" off the internet directly to the piece's "controller". Imagine pieces that aren't DONE when their maker has "finished" them - that the owner, or guardian, can continue to change for as long as they care to? Unfortunately, you may also need to imagine lawyers, and licenses and contracts and . . . But those are "business issues". I, for one, have no interest in "business". I'm after the fun - of making the initial piece - and hopefully getting to see what happens after that.

Now if I can just get a little speaker to change tones as the shadow of my hand passes over it - and still have the piece flash once in a while, then, after 30 seconds or so, get a red dot on a piece to start glowing brighter then dimming and finally going out. And I've got an infra red sensor detecting when I blink my eyes or stick out my tongue while otherwise sitting still - in the sensor's field of vision. And I've got to find something that will detect sound so a piece can "hear" - and respond. Smell - I'm afraid THAT will have to wait. But at the rate things are changing . . .

The evolution of turning is changing constantly, new tools and materials being used, new uses of colors and textures. What may be coming next will only accelerate the changes - leading to pieces we can't even imagine at the moment (and I can imagine some pretty Wild Hare possibilities).

I sincerely hope that folks can look passed the initial odd, gimmicky stuff that will show up initially, and see the possibilities rather than the shortcomings of Alpha pieces. Beta pieces will follow - sure as the sun will come up tomorrow. Perhaps by the time Version 10.2.6 gets out "stamp controlled" pieces will be passe, old hat, kind of boring.

We live in very interesting times. And it keeps getting more interesting.

Are YOU content with doing "just" YOU LOOK, I SIT HERE pieces?

Re: Participatory Pieces

#2

Re: Participatory Pieces

fgvanatta

Are YOU content with doing "just" YOU LOOK, I SIT HERE pieces?

Matter of fact, I am. There is something personal and calming in the quiet contemplation of a piece of wood and the form it has been made into. In today's raucous world of ringing phones and constant babble I don't need another noisy "interactive" bit of work in my life. We may very well see the day when some type of artificially intelligent "thing" drives works to react with the observer, but it will never replace the soothing feel of a silky piece of wood or the wonder evoked by the patterns and colors nature creates every day.

Re: Participatory Pieces

#3

Well said, Frank.

Carole Valentine

Re: Participatory Pieces

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Participatory Pieces

Richard Allen

What you are talking about with "stamp controllers" has little to do with woodturning. You could use clay or styrofoam or paper miechie... Talking about the possibilities on a woodturning forum really doesn't follow.

You can have a collection of wood turnings which could be rearranged by the owner to express different things. The owner doesn't need "stamp controllers" to interact with a wood turning. And a "stamp controller" doesn't need a woodturning.

Re: Participatory Pieces

#5

Re: Participatory Pieces *LINK*

charlie belden

If "woodturning" ends when the last shavings of wood leave a gouge or chisel, or when the last grit of sandpaper is no longer is abrading the wood or handful of dry shavings is no longer burnishing the wood - ANYTHING done after that is NOT "woodturning"?

If, while still on the lathe, a finish is applied to the turning, be it oil, lacquer, shellac, poly, wax, stain or dye, it's still a "woodturning". But if the piece is removed from the lathe and oil, lacquer, etc. is applied to the piece - it's no longer a "woodturning"?

If, once the piece has been turned, it's carved or pierced or textured or pyroed or metal foil "leafed" or "limed" or sandblasted or grouted or "egg shelled" or airbrushed or patinated - or "laser engraved" - it's no longer a "woodturning"?

"Woodturning" evolved from making practical, utilitarian objects on a lathe to creating utilitarian pieces - that were also aesthetically pleasing to see and touch. Much of what is being done by woodturners today have little, if any, utilitarian purpose. They've become objects - whose appeal is visual and tactile rather than functionality.

The use of "stamp controller" controlling lights and sound makers and movement makers as Post Lathe Enhancements is just another branch on woodturning's evolving/ growing tree. It may wither and die - or it may grow and branch off in directions we can't even imagine today.

The wonderful thing about turning is that it includes both simple, beautiful, quiet, contemplative pieces as well as whimsical/ shocking/ provocative pieces - and everything in between.

Would I like to see Michelangelo's The David or The Pieta move and talk? HELL NO.

Are there kinetic sculptures that I really like? Absolutely.

Can kinetic / dynamic pieces be aesthetic and contemplative?

Attached is a video of what I think you may find to be a contemplative kinetic piece (ignoring of course the BMW ad - unless you're a car nut) - that I'm pretty sure is computer controlled. The range of looks it CAN have is almost limitless.

Will kinetic pieces I come up with be beautiful and aesthetically pleasing? Highly unlikely since I'm not after those qualities now - and probably will not attempt to pursue that avenue. But someone else might - and pull it off - well. If, in a small way, I can help that happen - I'll be happier. If not, well exploring this path has been interesting and fun - so far.


Interesting Kinetic Piece

Re: Participatory Pieces

#6

Re: Participatory Pieces

Barbara Dill

Hey Charlie,

You have an amazing mind. I loved the Kinetic sculpture at the BMW Museum. However I don't have a clue about the stamp whatevers. But go for it!!