Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Exploiting Expectations

Posts

Exploiting Expectations

#1

Exploiting Expectations

charlie belden

One of the things that makes a piece appealing - is its ability to astonish us.

Astonish: to greatly impress or surprise.

I've seen a large number of really impressive pieces here and over at WOW. Aside from the beauty and often visual complexity of these piece, the skills and abilities required to make such things alone is impressive. Some of these pieces impress because of their high "I Wonder How This Was Done?!" factor.

The SURPRISE astonishing pieces, the ones that trigger smiles - or pleasant confusion and then a smile or even an out loud laugh - are - surpisingly - rarer. Now it could be that static pieces or even static still images of a dynamic/kinetic piece are unable to convey the SURPRISE. Somehow, Alby Hall and a few others regularly pull off SURPRISE - really well - with static pieces - and Still photos of them.

Maybe videos, with sound, might bring more of these types of pieces "out of the closet".

Maybe SURPRISE pieces have a negative connotation - seen as a gimmick, sophomoric, unelegant, not aesthetic, "just not proper" - so not even considered for a future piece. It is conceivable that "impressive" AND "surprise" could both exist in a single piece and someone here or elsewhere has the skills and abilities to do such a piece. Peter Rand, for one, has done it, or gotten very close to doing it. Besler will probably pull it off as well. I'm sure there are others making sketches and rounding up parts for a SURPRISE idea out there as well. ( Come out, come out - wherever you are!)

Oddly enough, surprising people isn't that hard to do. One of the ways to surprise people is to Exploit Expectations by having a piece DO SOMETHING UNEXPECTED. Doing a Pleasantly Surprising piece isn't difficult to do - though it can be - if you choose to make it difficult

Me, I really enjoy figuring out ways of incorporating an element of surprise in many of my pieces. Coming up with ideas is fun. Figuring out how to do them is fun. The process of making them is fun - most of the time. And it's fun to play with a piece that works as it's supposed to. Hell, even ideas that don't turnout as expected usually yield ideas for other, potentially fun - and surprising - pieces.

Case in point - the hollow form I'm thinking about using for a Stamp Controller (Arduino) controlled. battery powered, motion detecting, glowing RGB LEDs and/or servo driven movement and/or sound generating and/or solar powered piece - has been used for two earlier "failures" - a Bot Sugar Bowl and a MagLev Hollow Form. If I can figure out how to get the electronics to work as I want them to, this hollow form may become part of my first micro computer controlled dynamic/kinetic piece.

Attached are two ideas for potentially "astonishing" pieces. The first is a variation of a piece I've already done - using a ball and socket penduluming finial on a Hyper Ellipsoid lidded box. The second idea using a battery powered stamp controller has already provided a bit of fun learnng about what a stamp controller and some "actions" parts can do - and how to get them to do it. I've already started a stamp contoller controlled prototype out of 4" ABS pipe and have turned the parts to hold the electronic components in place. Now I just need to prototype the electronics on a "breadboard", develop the "sketch" (software) to make things work and maybe - just maybe - there'll be a YouTube video of a piece when it's done.


Here's the Wild Hare Ideas Prototype Bench - with most of the "stuff". Have only burned myself ONCE - so far ; )


Have YOU done, or considered doing, a SURPRISE Piece? If so, care to share?

Re: Exploiting Expectations

#2

Re: Exploiting Expectations

Bob Macgregor

Charlie, if you figure out how to make it "track" the person who approaches, or passes by, you could combine it with the "eye" from your marble piece and really freak people out!

When I saw your sketch, I thought it would be interesting to have the pendulum weight be a small magnet with another magnet on a moving platform below...same poles facing. Depending on how the platform moved, the reaction of the finial could be quasi-random, patterned or simple rotational...I suppose if the platform had a rocking element(cam?), you might even get the finial to bump up and down a bit.

BOB

Re: Exploiting Expectations

#3

Re: Exploiting Expectations

charlie belden

Bob:

Great IDEAS!

There are all sorts of sensors that can detect things - changes in infra red background levels, changes in sound relfections, changes in visible light striking a sensor, changes in temperature sensors, . . .

Once a change is detected, the micro controller can then initiate actions - get LEDs to do all sorts of things, have a small speaker sounds, make things move . . . - all dependent on what's going on in the vicinity of the piece.

The idea to use small rare earth magnets rather than mechanical linkage between the pendulum finial and a servo below it is fantastic. And with the right combination of Attract and Repel, it might be possible to get TWO types of motion - swiveling finial AND bobbing up and down finial. A "cross" attached to the servo, with a pair of "attractors" on two of the arms and a pair of "repellers" on the other other two arms might do it. When the arms are moving slowly, the "attractors" would swivel the finial. But if the arms were to rotate quick enough, the finial's magnet might not be able to keep up with the "attracter" magnets on the servo - and get over "repeller" magnets on the other arms.

OR

If the servo and its "cross" were tilted, the distance between the magnets on its "arms" could vary enough to move the finial by attraction, release it from the attracter, pick it up with the repeller and push it. Push, Pull - swivel, rotate and move up and down!

I'm a bit concerned about having magnets, especially strong magnets, close to a computer, even a micro computer. A metal shield around sensitive electronis can probably take care of this potential problem.

Going to have to put these ideas in the "Arduino Ideas" folder for sure.

I've learned how to get an infra red sensor and a light sensing resistor to trigger and control "actions" (light, sound and movement). Next up is working out how to make them work together to do a variety of "actions" based on what's going on around them.

Working out voluntary or involuntary interaction with pieces using this "stamp controller" thing keeps getting interestinger and interestinger.

Got any more ideas?

Have YOU considered doing this kind of stuff?

Re: Exploiting Expectations

#4

Re: Exploiting Expectations

Bob Macgregor

"Have YOU considered doing this kind of stuff? "

One of the things that has impressed me about you, Charlie, is that you actually execute your hare-brained ideas; I seldom go beyond the imagining stage. I still have a lot of conflicting demands on my time, money and energy and am reluctant to invest much of any of these in a project that is very iffy. I also don't have anywhere near your technical skills yet in turning nor in electronics, which further inhibits me from diving into a complex and unproven undertaking.

BOB