Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Hand chaser problems.

Posts

Hand chaser problems.

#1

Hand chaser problems.

john lucas

So I'm laying on the couch after a frustrating day chasing threads. I can cut the threads fine. Well most of the time anyway. However about every 34d one comes out with the gap when screwed together. I had tried everything so I thought.

Then I get this phone call. It's my friend Mark StLeger. He says he saw the thread and new exactly what the problem is. He's had it before and finally figured out what it is. When cutting the female threads if the cutter is not perfectly level it throws it off. I went out to the shop, re installed the box lid from the photo that shows the gap. I made sure the cutter was flat and made 2 more passes over the threads. Screwed on perfectly flat.

He told me he is trying a new technique that works well for beginners. Use the Bestwoodtools box hollowing tool rest. Set the chaser flat on this and it keeps it perfectly level. I don't have one of those but I do have something almost exactly the same. My tool rest for doing the micro turnings has a flat bar on top that holds the mini tool rest. I'm headed out to the shop to give it a try.

Mark is teaching a threading workshop but I forgot to find out where and when. I'll ask him at the symposium. You can't find a better teacher.

Isn't this site amazing. I've read all the literature on thread chasing and never saw this mentioned. You post it here and people like Fred Holder, Jorge, and Mark all give good answers to move you along.

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#2

Level, how?

Allen Neighbors

John, are you talking about level... as parallel with the lathe bed? Or level as measured across the axis of the handle...?

I guess I'm just dense...

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#3

Re: Level, how?

john lucas

Allen I didn't understand either so I questioned him at length. Parallel to the lathe bed. Tilted up or down changes the angle of the teeth themselves. This goes along with what Mike Hunter and I discussed about thread angles changed based on the diameter of the thing being threaded. I still don't quite understand how this changes the angle of how the whole lid screws on but I played with it this morning and works.

I took a lid that was crooked. Rechased the threads with the tool level with the bed and it straightened right out. Then I did another ornament using my new thread chaser platform and it worked.

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Hand chaser problems.

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, let me toss out a theory. If the chaser is not parallel to the bed, it reduces the pitch of the resultant threads a bit. Also, most of us will end up with a bit of taper on one or both of the mating thread chases. This means that the alignment of the male and female pieces will be determined by the first or last thread, depending on the direction of the taper. Given these conditions, the best fit of the two mating threads of different pitch will occur when the axes of the pieces are slightly cocked with respect to each other. Try to couple a nut and bolt with different thread pitches and you will see what I mean. I don't immediately see why the female thread should be more vulnerable than the male thread, but maybe we just instinctively do a better job of leveling the chaser on the male threads. Dennis

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#5

Re: Hand chaser problems.

john lucas

Thanks Dennis. Your stating what I think happens. The reason the male thread doesn't have this problem is that it sits flat on the tool rest. You can get a tapered thread pretty easily if you don't hold the tool square but to do the same thing that is happening with the female thread you would have tilt the tool which would actually be hard to do since the wood is pulling the tool down onto the rest.

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#6

Re: Hand chaser knowledge

Galen Vetterick

John

Thanks for the valuable information you have posted on hand chasing threads. Got to try it soon.

The flat box type rest to hold a level plane sounds like a good deal for any beginner like me.

Only thing I missed is what speed you found works well.

Did you use 3/4-16NF bolt just for the extra material to weld it to your tool base metal rather than 3/8-16NC bolt? Did the 3/4 NF have better cut threads than maybe that found on 3/8 bolt with roll formed NC thread? No differnece?

When are you going to start production of your signature thread chasers and rest?

Thanks again for posting what you have learned.

Galen

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#7

Re: Hand chaser knowledge

John Lucas

Galen I doubt the bolt size makes much difference now that I've played with both. As Mark and I discussed when you are cutting slightly above center you are only using the top part of the tooth so tooth angle shouldn't be a concern.

I notice the commercial tools are much thicker which is part of why I went with the 3/4x16. No difference in thread quality.

I've tried speeds from 200 rpm up to 600. If you have a long area to chase it doesn't seem to matter. When you only want 3 or 4 threads with very little space before the shoulder then you really have to be quick to get the tool out of there. 200 to 250 seems to allow this. If you have a lathe that won't go under 500 get the threads started, which you do at an angle. Then as you work the tool around toward square simply pull it out early. Then you can rotate the work by hand and cut the last few threads. Yea it's slow but it does work.

Mark StLeger makes a great tool so I don't see any reason to make my own to sell. He's done a lot of work teaching threading threading so I'll gladly help him sell his tools as well as Fred's Book. Heck I learned from these guys.

Re: Hand chaser problems.

#8

Re: Hand chaser problems.

Fred Holder

Hello John,

I haven't had the problem that you describe, but it sounds like a flat tool rest might make inside threading easier. There would be less problem for the chaser to twist a bit, which could mess up the threads a bit. Seems like I have a flat tool rest designed for hollowing boxes. I'll give it a try and see how it works. I don't make may threaded boxes anymore. The Chinese Ball has been taking up a lot of my turning time the last few years. It is so much fun, because you can break it at any time and when you don't you feel great.

Incidentally, my book, "Making Screw Threads in Wood", has been removed from the market. I did manage to purchase 50 copies of the last that they had so I have a few copies on hand for people who wish to add it to their library.

I especially like to make threaded lids for needle cases. I once made my wife one without a threaded lid and when she threw it into here sewing kit, the lid came off and dumped her needles. I will no longer make a needle case with out threading the lid.