Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Kelton Center Saver

Posts

Kelton Center Saver

#1

Kelton Center Saver

Mike Mahoney

This is in response to problems with the Kelton Center Saver.

They do follow a curve but not a sphere. A hemisphere shape wont allow

you to plunge deeper like a curve that has a slight bend like the

Kelton tools. This is what makes kelton's tools more versatile because

we are not always looking to remove hemispheres out of blanks. I

didn't mean to respond to your particular comments and I am no way

defending any manufacturing defect of the Kelton tools. I am new to

this Wood Central and noticed a ton of comments on the curvatures of

the blades. I have used this tool probably more than anyone I suspect.

I have gone through countless blades and I have never bought a set

that had a defect on any of the curves. All the best! Mike

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#2

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for weighing in, Mike

Ellis Walentine

I've never used a coring tool, so I'm innocent of any knowledge or bias about the tools involved. The whole recent discussion of the McNaughton tools seems to underscore the variability and complexity of what a lot of people expect to be a straightforward mechanical operation. Your message seems to be that there's more to it than meets the eye, and that a degree of experience is needed to get the feel for the coring operation.

Of course, you must admit that the kerf created by the cutting tip must clear a path that the shank of the blade can follow, and that it needs to be at least approximately semi-circular. What I hear you saying is that there is enough slop to allow slight deviations from a perfect arc. Manufacturing quality control is still necessary to keep the curvature within reasonable tolerances.

Maybe I should try this sometime. :)

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#3

Thanks for chiming in

John Lucas

As a new user of this tool I've been following this closely. I bought the tool not too long after watching your demo in Nashville. I have also watched Bill Grumbine's video. I was very successful on my first set and thought, man this isn't as hard as everyone suggests. Then on my second set of bowls I had nothing but trouble and broke one of the cutters in 3 places. I have no idea what I was doing different than on the first set.

2 things are possibilities. There is a pretty large gap between the gates and the cutter bar. I compensated for this by torquing the tool clockwise so it was touching the gate on the bottom left and top right. That way there would not be any catches dues to the twisting. The second thing is I think the knife may have gotten at or below center as it approached the middle. I'm not sure of this but based on what I'm reading that could easily have been one of my problems.

I hope to get back into coring after the AAW symposium so maybe I can learn a few things from this discussion.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#4

Steven Antonucci

Should not any gap in the gate?

Steven Antonucci

Did you have it in the wrong set of pins? I can't twist mine at all? I wonder how many folks have issues from "set-up" misuse?

My original point was that these are not simple to use, and there is probably a lot of room from improvement in the instructions. At the price for the basic set, I think that there should be some kind of instructional video that demonstrates proper use. With all of the conversations, I think we're getting there...

Thanks for weighing in, Mike. Now go cut a deal with Kel to include your video in his box!

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Should not any gap in the gate?

Richard Allen

Talk of a video has been mentioned several times in this thread. Kel should have video on his web site.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#6

Re: Should not any gap in the gate?

Barry Irby

Steven, I should stay out of this, but that has never stopped me before. I have an older set and my post has three posts I believe. I use it infrequently, but when I do, intensely for a few days.

There must be just enough clearance to allow you to slide the knives easily and with a small ability to redirect the angle. This allows you to point the knife and slide it forward into the work, but not enough room to allow the knife to tip or rotate, at least not much.

Apparently the larger and smaller sets of knives are made of steel of different thickness and width. the newer more sophisticated posts ave several sets of pins that are set at different spacings and the post has steps in it to a accommodate the the different thicknesses and widths.

The knife must be set up to travel pretty much horizontal and at the same height as the shaft of the lathe. At that point the inner face of the blade is vertical and tangent to the inner bowl. If the knife were substantially higher or lower, it would have to lean to remain tangent and in the kerf. Get It?

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#7

Re: Should not any gap in the gate?

John Lucas

My post has several sets of pins and I set it in the ones that it fits. The others are too narrow and have the raised step.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#8

Re: Thanks for chiming in

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

John, when you broke the cutter, did you check to see if there was anything in the wood? I have used my tools very hard over the years, and have never broken a cutter unless I hit something in the wood. Nails come to mind. I was doing a demo for a student/visitor and had a piece of walnut on the lathe. I discovered no less than one galvanized roofing nail, two 10 penny common nails, a bullet, and a cut nail, all in one stinking blank! >( My coring knife make quick work of the bullet, but the other nails were hard on the tip, with the cut nail being the worst.

Normally a dark stain in the wood alerts me to the presence of iron, but with this particular piece of walnut, it wasn't dark enough to warn me. After two hits, I just got stubborn and decided it wasn't going to beat me. Beyond hitting something like metal or stone (or glass) I have not had an issue with a tip breaking, and I have cored some pretty hard and abrasive species. I'm not known for taking my time and going slowly either. ;)

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#9

Re: Thanks for chiming in

John Lucas

Bill There wasn't anything in the wood. I just got a BIG catch and it snapped. I finished the cut using my homemade cutter and there wasn't any reason as far as the wood was concerned that would cause a catch like that. It was box elder.

I was probably something I did but didn't think I did anything different than when I cored the first set of walnut bowls .

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#10

Re: Thanks for chiming in

Dick Strauss

John,

The large gap you are seeing is the same defect I'm seeing! The gap allows the tools to rotate even though they shouldn't. The only way I've discovered to fix the gap is to use a feeler gage or piece of metal and bend it around the turret capture post that is full height to make a bushing of sorts. This gets rid of the gap and makes the tool tons more stable.

The twisting motion that you did to keep the knife engaged with both sides of the capture posts may also drop the end of the knife by quite a bit depending on where you are on the knife shaft.

Check all of your knives to see if the gap is consistent. If so, you leave the bent gage around the post. If not, you'll have to add or remove the bent metal gage/bushing based on the knife in use. I'd suggest you try to get the ones in question replaced including the one that broke from poor fit.

FYI-I sent a note to KM last week and have not heard from him yet...I'm still hopeful though.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#11

Steven Antonucci

Can you post a picture?

Steven Antonucci

I just can't visualize what you guys are talking abotu?

S

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#12

Re: Center saver

D. Hansen

I bought an old version in the "yellow box" with the large knives several years ago. When I bought the mid size knives they came with a ring that fit around one of the posts and a piece of metal with half circles cut on opposite sides that raises the smaller blades to the same height as the large knives in relation to the posts. . When I use the mid size knives I use the step and the ring bushing. When using the large set I take the extra stuff out. I use the tool regularly and although I am way way away from being proficient the tools works well on an old Nova with small HP motor and rather large blanks. I wonder if the "slop" being talked about comes from not having the bushings and step piece.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#13

Re: Can you post a picture?

Dick Strauss

Steve,

We are using it in the right set of capture posts. The knives only fit in one set if you have the large set of knives like I do. They would also not be flush with the top of the capture posts if you put the knives in the wrong slot.

Now, imagine if your system had a gap between the correct capture posts that was 0.020" too wide. This would allow for the knife to sit on edge and rock back and forth while "captured" between the posts. Since the bottom of the knives are also rounded to allow them to slide easily throough the posts, the knife really wants to tip from side to side. This issue ruins almost all stability in the system, especially as you get deeper in to the bowl and the effects are magnified. It also allows for the knife tip to drop below center or go above center depending on whether the knife is pitched clockwise or counter-clockwise in bewteen the capture posts.

In case you might be wondering, my posts aren't worn in the least...you can still see the original black finish over most of the post's cylindrical surface.

My system was purchased before the bushing issue came to light. One of my knives (the straight one IIRC) fits nicely while the others have a sloppy gap (from the knives being too thin) to varying degrees.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#14

Dick Hines

Re: Can you post a picture?

Dick Hines

Well, I guess I am will have to check my coreing system. I keep reading the post about all the trouble everyone is haveing. I have not used in a while so I am not sure if there is gap between the post or not. As best as I can remember there is not.

I have had the large set for years. In the begening I had trouble with them. After watching Mike's DVD and watching Bill Grumbine do a deom most of my troubles went away. Not all but most. Most of the problems I hace now is just me being stupid and trying to core to fast.

Re: Kelton Center Saver

#15

Re: Can you post a picture?

Joe Staller

I have the older set in the yellow box also. I have the problem with too much slop between the pins, but only when starting the cut. I finally realized that my blades neck down behind the cutting edge, and then thicken back up 1 to 2 inches behind the tip. The solution for me was to locate the tool rest/support mechanism a couple of inches away from my blank until I got the cut started, and then move the support closer to the wood as the cut proceeded. Coring was a very stressful operation until I figured this out.