I think I have a shape developing here but I'm sure it's not unique to me. Spalted maple� approx 4� high x 4� dia. 5/8� opening. Walls approx 1/8� - 3/16� . A little heavy in the bottom. Velvit Aqua Shield. Any and all comments are welcomed.
I like the tuck in of the foot and yet the peice still seems stable
I dont see the weight in the bottom as a problem I have a few pieces from other turners whose work blows over becuase they are so light.A worry as they can end up on the floor
If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, I've found it's also usually a pretty good way to practice a new skill. A lot of turners I know, myself included, gravitate to this shape because when well executed, it is a very pleasing, classical shape. At least that's one of my theories. If so, it may resonate with us because of something in our cultural heritage or because it has been so well exploited by the venerable turners we tend to emulate, consciously or unconsciously.
One thing that makes turned shapes pleasing is the way their curves run together. The concept of the "fair curve" is one that I always try to be aware of, and that has to do with all the curves being a progression, whether accelerating, decelerating or recurving. A progression has no lumps or flat spots, and all the transitions are smooth. To me, your spalted maple form is a lot closer to the ideal than the black gum form.
I personally think that this is a good "starter form" because it's relatively easy to reach everything (not too deep, not too undercut...) It can be stretched or squished within reason and is somewhat "forgiving" if you get most of the elements within reason.
My advice is to try turning the same shape, only upside down. If it still looks good, you got it down.
It looks very nice. When I think of form and dimension, I generally think of cube resulting in an orb, short square results in oval, and a tall rectangle results in a vase or high shouldered vessel. Looking at your form (vessel's width and the curve from the shoulder to the foot), I think that a little more height to the vessel would accentuate the shape with a longer taper to the foot.
Forget about the Golden Triangle and allthat stuff. As once explained to me by a seasoned turner regarding form and balance in a taller form (high shoulder), divide the form into thirds, and the widest point is located at the upper 1/3 point. It tapers from that point to the foot (lower 2/3 of form). Adjusting this slope of the curve from the widest point to foot (full curve or relatiively straight line can change the form from organic to formal).