Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Failed experiment

Posts

Failed experiment

#1

Failed experiment

John Lucas

I had an idea for a new gift ornament shape and wanted to play with carving a little more so I threw this together. When I was inserting the upper finial the fit was snug. I put CA in the hole and when I put the tenon in it grabbed before it got seated. Bummer. I think I'll be able to save it by cutting the tenon off at the ball and re-drilling the hole. Then I'll add a short extension onto the dowel and reglue it.

This shows you how bad something can look when not planned in advance. I should have at least made a sketch. The next one is already started and you can bet I'll do a drawing first to make the dimensions work better and the flow from tip to tail will work out better.

Re: Failed experiment

#2

Re: Failed experiment

Texian

Very cool ornament, almost. Just missed it by "that much".

Re: Failed experiment

#3

Re: Failed experiment

charlie belden

Cut it off flush with the lid, drill another hole - and try again.

OR

Turn a small collar, cut it in half, glue it in, with a little veneer to make up the the saw kerf - and you've turned a mistake into - a FEATURE!

Re: Failed experiment

#4

Steven Antonucci

Why I don't sand until it's all assembled

Steven Antonucci

A lot of work to let go... I think you could razor saw the tenon and redrill carefully. If it's a through tenon, turn a button for the inside to cover the hole...

Were you going for a goldfish or similar?

Steve

Re: Failed experiment

#5

Re: Why I don't sand until it's all assembled

John Lucas

Steve It will be an easy save I think. If I can't rechuck the top accurately enough to redrill I'll just bore out the waste with a Dremel. Been there done that before so I know it will work. Adding more wood to the existing tenon will be simple because it's the same size as a 3/8" dowel.

I did test fit everything before I started sanding. The first thing I did after turning the initial shape was to check the tenons for fit. They did fit with one being a more snug fit than the other. That's the one that jammed. I've done probably a hundred turnings with tenons like this and never had one lock up.

I'm not sure what I was after. I wanted a Christmas ornament that had Gold carved flowing things coming off of it. However none of the shapes work together so I gave up on the gold leaf idea. I do think it looks fishy so I'm actually working on 2 designs. One will be very fishy, the other will be more like a flashy fragile ornament.

Re: Failed experiment

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Why I don't sand until it's all assembled

Dick Hines

Next time use the med. or thick CA. Like the look of the ornament though. Except for the big gap between the ball and finial. :D

Re: Failed experiment

#7

I'm learning that lesson

George Guadiane

I have this really REALLY nice ash burl hollow form with a crack on the bottom... NICE water based poly finish on it, with a crack on the tenon that I wanted to CA glue before I turned it off and finished the bottom...

You know how sometimes cracks go all the way through? I didn't check and pumped a LOT of CA through the crack.

I turned it over to check it out, no problems (it seemed) then I turned it on it's side and managed to get a REALLY NICE glue run on my fresh finish :(

Finishing should be the VERY LAST THING (I guess).

Re: Failed experiment

#8

that was medium CA

john lucas

Re: Failed experiment

#9

Re: Failed experiment

Terry Scott

John bind some leather strips around the spigot and hang them down a bit and cut the ends to look like the bottom

Re: Failed experiment

#10

Re: Failed experiment

john lucas

Good idea Terry. I really need to relax and think outside the box, or at least stand on the edge and look out a little.