Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

McNaughton question

Posts

McNaughton question

#1

McNaughton question

Sean Troy

On a 3hp motor, what speed is optimum for coring?

Re: McNaughton question

#2

Steven Antonucci

800-1000 RPM

steven antonucci

Re: McNaughton question

#3

Re: McNaughton question

Greg Haugen

Sean,

My opinion, (and you know what they say about opinions....), horsepower doesn't matter that much. Horsepower is nice, yes. But it doesn't take the place of sharp tools and good technique. As far as speed, I look at the size of the bowl. 10 inch bowls and under I like it around 800 rpms. Once I get around the 15" size, I like 500 to 600 rpms. Even though the bigger bowls are slower rpms, the rate the wood is being cut is similar. A larger circle is turning at a higher rate of speed than a smaller bowl at the same rpm.

If the speed is too high and something goes wrong, it goes REALLY wrong. If it's a little slower, at least for learning, and something goes wrong-it's not that bad.

If it's too fast, you'll know it. It will have a higher....umm...."pucker factor". :-)

Turn at a speed that is comfortable. As you're used to it, you'll speed it up.

Hope that helps.

Greg

Re: McNaughton question

#4

Re: McNaughton question

Sean Troy

Thanks all for the info. I haven't used mine in years and now have some large bowl material I'd like to get the most of.

Re: McNaughton question

#5

Re: McNaughton question

robo hippy

Like Greg said, it depends on the size of bowl you are coring, but my rule of thumb is core about 1/2 to 2/3 your turning speed. I will core smaller (8 inch) bowls at 800 to 1000 rpm or so, but I have no digital readout. I will core some large bowls at 400 or so. If you go too slow on the bowls, the tool does not work nearly as well.

The type of wood can play into the speed factor here as well. With a harder wood, like locust, oak, or Mountain Mahogany, I core slower as well. With Madrone (wood grain smooth as butter), or cherry, I will core a lot faster.

Like Pat's Fan on Woodnet forums says, "when sphincter tightening exceeds chuck tightening, you have a problem."

robo hippy