Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

Posts

McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

#1

McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

Steve Russell

Hello,

After reading the recent threads about using the McNaughton Centre Saver, I thought I would share my take on this tool. I purchased my first Kelton Centre Saver more than 14 years ago and in fact, it was from one of the first batch or two of these tools sold in the U.S. Back then, the tool post/surfboard featured a sliding gate and used what was later called the "Standard Set" of coring knives and came in a bright yellow box.

Since that time, I have used the Kelton Centre Saver (KCS) in it's various forms to core thousands and thousands of bowls and I have demonstrated using it more times than I can recall at various locations around the U.S. I have also written a few articles about using the system, as well as featured it in one of my videos on bowl turning. The current MK8 instruction manual is largely excerpted from my original and follow up articles on using the Kelton Centre Saver system, so I think I'm in a unique position to comment on this tool, since I'm one of the handful of turners around the world that have the most experience with using this tool.

I can only speak for myself on this, but I have never had any quality issues with the KCS, or it's coring knives in the 14 years I have used the system. None of my knives have ever been supplied with improper curves, or with blades that were of improper width. The KCS was one of the primary money making tools in my studio for many years, since I made my living as a production bowl turner for the first 12 or so years of my studio. I used the KCS on a daily basis and through the years, I developed a few advanced protocols for using it that were subsequently adopted by many woodturners worldwide.

These include my CTM "Concave Tip Modification" that was popular on the older coring knives that were supplied with a flat face on the cutting tip (before the spear point tips), my FPT "Fluid Pulsed Technique" for using the system on low HP lathes, my CASP "Complimentary Arc Sighting Process" for setting the penetration curve, my PACP "Pneumatically Assisted Coring Protocol" and my FACP "Fluid Assisted Coring Protocol" to name a few. I've written about many of these protocols through the years and I will continue to do so as I develop new ways to get the most from this impressive tool.

I have also held numerous private classes for students who want to learn this tool and I've helped literally hundreds and hundreds of woodturners around the world via email and through phone calls, with challenges they had to getting up to speed with this tool. Through the years, I've found (my personal experience) that the problems I was seeing with students, from turners at demos, or in emails from woodturners were primarily due to two main things: 1.) Improper Setup of the Tool, or 2.) Improper Use of the Tool. When these two factors were corrected, the tool performed as it should and the turner was popping out cores faster than you can say "Bobs Your Uncle, Fannies Your Aunt."

For me personally, this tool was a lifesaver and one that allowed me to make a very handsome profit with with my production bowls. Had there been some problem with the design of the tool, it would have become readily apparent. Back in the day, it was not uncommon for me to use this tool for 12 - 14 hours per day, several days each week. The tool worked exactly as it should, day in and day out. I do not know most of the blokes who were a part of the original thread on the KCS, so I can't comment on their experience. I can only relay my own personal experience with this tool, that has been honed over the last 14 years using it at my lathe.

I count myself as lucky for having met Kel many years ago at an AAW symposium. He had a few less grey hairs on his head back then (like myself), but he convinced me many years ago to give his new centre saver a try and the rest as they say is history! I have always found Kel to be responsive to customer concerns and he is passionate about making superb woodturning tools and genuinely cares about his customers. In these days where most manufacturers will not give you the time of day, much less answer an email, or have a human on the customer service line, his personal approach to customer service is refreshing and welcome. That's my take.

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

#2

Re: McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

fgvanatta

I would have to agree with your assessment of the McNaughton tool. I, too, got one in the yellow box many years ago. I bought this tool instead of the others available because I wanted to core bowls of varying shapes. It has worked very well for that purpose. I started out on dry, natural edge mesquite, so coring was a chore. But that was a function of the wood, not the tool. I did have a little trouble with the sparse instructions, but Mike Darlow's fine book, Woodworking Techniques quickly cleared that up.

The only criticism I have of this tool is that I wish I had bought the micro set of blades when they were cheaper.

Frank

Re: McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

#3

Re: McNaughton Centre Saver - This Blokes Take...

Wilford Bickel

Steve,

All I have ever found from Kel was service that went way beyond what most everybody else would have supplied. I had a very minor issue with my turret when I purchased my coring system. I sent Kel an email and by the time he called me from New Zealand I had fixed the problem. In the next few weeks he and I corresponded and talked several times as he wanted to make sure the unit was right or he was going to make it right. I have since come to be one of the lucky ones that calls Kel a friend. He has even gone out of his way to try to help me with special set ups on tools to help me keep turning with my inherited joint disease and the secondary arthritis. You cannot put that kind of caring about a customer and fellow turner into dollars. I too have demonstrated the unit and have not found any problems with the curve of the blade - never even checked mine to see how circular they were as I did not expect them to be a circle but more of an elliptical curve since they are made to allow you to cut more then one shape of bowl. I agree with your comments and you certainly did better then I could have done. I am proud to have the unit in my shop and very proud we have Kel supplying us. Thanks for doing such an excellent job on your comments.

Wilford