Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

small constrained hollowing systems...

Posts

small constrained hollowing systems...

#1

small constrained hollowing systems...

GaryG in MD

I may be interested in getting a SMALL constrained hollowing system.

I would appreciate hearing about the utility and tradeoffs of the Don Derry and Elbo systems. I realize this is a bit subjective, but I'm interested in comparing effectiveness, ease of use, safety, limitations, etc. The bottom line, of course, is: "Which one is better?" and why. Are there other small ones that should be considered? Right now I have a 1/2" outrigger (torque arrestor) that works pretty well. So do I really need anything more? Maybe not? Thanks, Gary

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#2

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

Charlie Drake

Gary, I have both the Derry system and the Monster articulated arm. I like both but they are certainly different. The Derry is small, very quick to set up (maybe 30 seconds) and relatively nice to use. A word of caution-it is set up for reverse turning-I didn't like that so turned everything around to use in the "correct" direction. That is a little bit of a problem with the laser. Also, you are limited in the maximim diameter you can turn because of the laser arm and perhaps the maximum practical depth you can turn comfortably without a lot of chatter is 3-4 inches. I just use it on small projects. It is not nearly as smooth as the Monster. The Monster takes a little longer to set up and requires a larger opening. That said, it is very smooth in the action (quite a bit smoother than the Derry) and you can hollow several inches deeper than the Derry and because of the adjustable laser, turn much larger diameter items. I guess I'm saying if you just want to turn small stuff, the Derry should work just fine but for maximum flexibility, I would consider sometning like the Monster or Elbo or ...... Good luck.

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#3

Re: Charlie and I have the exact same .....

JamieDonaldson

...tools and thoughts! I switched the Derry from R side to L side hollowing, but seldom use it now that I have the Monster, among other hollowing toys. The Monster is a real professional production tool compared to the Derry.

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#4

build your own. go yo lyle jameison web site

bob davis

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#5

I built my first one for a mini lathe

John Lucas

I only had a mini lathe when I got interested in the Jamieson style boring bars. I didn't have a welder or a way to heat metal back then so I built it from off the shelf parts using a hacksaw and drill press.

Go to Lyle Jamieson's site and look at his directions. I used 3/4" rod for the side pieces. I connected those together with all thread rod and square tubing. Looking back on how these rigs work you don't need the square tubing. You could just put nuts and lock washers on both sides of the rod to lock them in position.

I purchased steel sleeves from Lowes that fit over the 3/4" bar. I pinned on side to the bar with 1/8" roll pins. I left about 1 1/2 hanging over the bar for the cutter bar to lock into. I drilled and tapped the sleeve for set screws to lock the bar in place.

For the secondary tool rest I built a wooden stand that sat on the floor. It had a wooden cross bar for the boring bar to sit on and a wooden piece over that to function as the captured part. At first I had this attached to the lathe with another 2x4 but eventually realized that I didn't need it. I just moved it the secondary rest wherever it needed to be.

I used this rig for several years until I built a better one. I still use the wooden secondary rest I redid the mount so it sits on my powermatic lathe bed. I keep telling myself I have the tools and skills to build a metal one but this one works so I keep on using it.

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#6

Re: small constrained hollowing systems... *LINK*

charlie belden

I think knowing what "small" means would help us help you in your decision.

I've got a JET VS mini/midi. Between centers I've got about 9" diameter by about 12" of length to turn in.

BUT - with a piece mounted in a chuck I'm down to around 9" of length - and there has to be room for the tool rest. So I'm down to about 7 1/2" of length. Take an inch for mounting the Mini-Monster and I;m left with about 6 1/2" for the length/height of the piece - by 9" diameter.

So, if by small you mean turning up to 9" diameter by 6 1/2" tall - the Elbo, like the MiniMonster will meet your needs.

But there's a difference between the Elbo and the MiniMonster that may, or may not, be important to you - and that's Height Adjustment. There doesn't seem to be any on the tail stock end of the Elbo, while the MiniMonster, having its own tail stock end support that's vertcially adjustable. That verttical adjustment permits you to set things up so you can turn a little above, below or AT centerline.

Remember, these tools cut more like a scraper than a bowl gouge - and that requires finding the right tilt angle to get each cutter to cut well. Things change when you change cutters - and you WILL be changing cutters.

Which brings up Adjustability. Having large adjustment ranges can be a PITA to "dial in" so the tool works well and is easy to use. Having NO adjustability may mean the tool doesn't work at all - on your lathe - or doesn't work very well for some of the cuts you may want to make. I don't know the details of the Elbo, but I do know that the MiniMonster has three adjustment options available, and the adjustability at each is small, but just enough for "tweekability" when needed.

Working backwards from where the cutting/scraping edge meets the wood

- the rectangular or hexaganol cross section cutters fit in a hole in the cutter tip holder and held there with set screw. If the set screw comes down on a flat surface of the cutter - the cutter is self aligned. But you CAN tweek things either way - just a little bit - IF you want to use it - and still hold the cutter securely.

- the shank of the cutter tip holder is round, but has a flat spot on it. So when the set screw on the "arm" that holds the cutter tip holder and cutter - and attaches to the articulated arm, is screwed down, it auto aligns the cutter tip holder - but - again, with a little tweekability - IF you want to use it.

- where the "arm" connects to the artciluated arm there's another flat spot on the shank - so you've again got auto alignment - with a little tweekablity - IF you want to use it.

This set up is almost automatically self aligning due to "flat spots" on shanks and cutters, something that's a shortcoming of round shanks in round holes. But it also allows for three Tweekabilities you can use IF you need them.

About round shanks into round holes - held together with a set screw or two. The end of set screws WILL "dimple" metal. What that means when you have a round shank being held in a round hole is - getting a "dimpled" round shank out of - or into - a snug fit hole may require - PLIERS. A flat spot on the shank eliminates that problem. And if that flat spot is ground in the right spot - it self aligns things - with just a little tweekability - if you need to use it.

Given the two choices you presented, the articulated arm system has so many advantages over the hand held tool. And of the articulated arm captured systems, the MiniMontster is the most up to date generation of articulated arm captured systems - with the shortcomings of earlier generations dealt with really well.


More About The MiniMonster - a lot more ; )

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#7

Steven Antonucci

Building one?  Who da thunk it?

steven antonucci

I highly recommend building one for a few dollars and figuring out if you actually need to buy one. I suspect that your home brew will do the job nicely...

Steve

(still freehand hollowing with carpal tunnel syndrome in my right hand...)

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

Lyle Jamieson

Hi Gary, It seems to me that you are looking for a lateral move. Why not keep the 1/2 inch torque arrested system you already have. What do you have to gain from your choices?? Lots of obstacles!! I hate obstacles, like the ones everyone so far has outlined. " tweak adjustments, laser reach, limited mouth openings, long set up, laser capabilities, reverse turning, max diameter, depth limitations, height adjustments"...EEEK. Why purchase a small system?? I use my system for Christmas ornaments and many of you have seen me hollowing on my mini lathe at the regional symposiums around the country.

If you have a mini lathe stay with what you have. The mini will not support big things with any hollowing system. If you have a full size lathe you will out grow the small systems very quickly and wish you built or bought a full size system from the beginning. Look back at the responses so far and note how many people upgraded, some many times. I can turn small things with a big tool, but I can not turn big things with a small tool.

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#9

outstanding answers...

GaryG in MD

Wow, those are great replies.

My thanks to Charlie, Jamie, Bob, John, Steve, Charlie, and Lyle for those thoughtful replies. I now have a LOT better feel for the situation.

FYI, I have a Jet 1236, so by "small" I meant something less than a Keith Clark rig -- not for a mini-lathe.

I saw and appreciated the recent posts (in March) by Steve about making your own, simply, out of wood, and that is very attractive.

I think I'll stay with my CA Savoy torque arrestor for a while longer and see where it leads me. That should be good to 5" over the rest. I guess I'll know when I need more.

Thanks again to all, Gary

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#10

Steven Antonucci

FWIW- I go 15-18" over the rest hand held

steven antonucci

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#11

Re: outstanding answers...

steve worcester

I guess it depends what small is...

I use a system that will take a 1/2" McNaughton system all the time, and the new versions (a year or so) drop the center of the cutting tip so you can get less than 3/4" opening easy. Smaller I use the smaller McNaughtons (3/8 rod?) with a Trent Bosch tool handle inserts.

All of them in a smaller Jamieson style captive system

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#12

Thanks Steve...

GaryG in MD

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#13

Re: FWIW- I go 15-18" over the rest hand held

GaryG in MD

I can't even begin to imagine that!

How long is your tool on YOUR side of the tool rest? ...Gary

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#14

Steven Antonucci

3' steel bar inserted about 12" into 4' black pipe

steven antonucci

with a hook tool insert for end grain or an Ellsworth style cutter for side grain...

S

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#15

Bill Blasic

Re: 3' steel bar inserted about 12" into 4' black

Bill Blasic

I use the Kelton Hollowers with the Monster system very often. This allows a smaller hole and the tools work great. The more I use the Monster the more I like it as it is so versatile.

Bill

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Re: FWIW- I go 15-18" over the rest hand held

Lyle Jamieson

You have to admit Steve, that you cant turn 15-18 inches deep on a mini lathe no matter what boring bar you use, hand held or supported. The one inch spindle and bearings of a mini will not carry the load.

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#17

Steven Antonucci

Think outside the box...

steven antonucci

Who says that the starting point is a solid log? Perhaps it is a segmented piece? Or perhaps it is a balsa wood hollow form? :D

I wasn't suggesting that a mini could be used for vessel that deep, only that the capabilities of the systems would probably be limited by the length of the system and lathe combination. I have a 24" bed on my Nova, but I lose the first 3-4" inches because of the chuck or faceplate (how the work is mounted) and the last 2-3" because of the banjo. Theoretically, 18" is about the best I can do in one piece with current equipment (discounting bearing loads).

I suspect that most mini's are probably 7-10" +/- in practical length for hollowing. a 5/8" bar is plenty sturdy to that depth. If you have a holloing system, you probably lose some of that capacity along the ways bolting it on...

You and I should put together a session for the AAW one year on hollowing. I think it would be fun...

Steve

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Think outside the box...

Lyle Jamieson

Great idea Steve, Dueling hollow forms. If Mike Mahoney and Stuart Batty can do it with bowls why not hollowing. That would be a hoot for us, but I don�t know how the audience would react to our drastically different approaches. We can agree to disagree and respect the others opinions. People tend to get uncomfortable with conflict. And our turning processes are certainly in stark contrast to one another. And we both have strong opinions. It would be great to get both sides of the story out in the open. The proof can be seen side by side on the lathe, and let the viewer decide what way they want to pursue. Ill meet you at noon behind the barn.

Re: small constrained hollowing systems...

#19

Steven Antonucci

I'll bring my homemade hook tool ;-)

steven antonucci

If you've ever wanted to be known for something, you know that it's going to take something "new" to get noticed.

Not sure what new is, but I hollow with a bowl gouge and/or a homemade hook tool. That's got to be worth the price of admision somewhere.

S

P.S. I bet we'd pack them in!