I have been following your wood threading on the wood lathe with interest. I know you have a small metal lathe and was wondering if threading is possible on that or ?
The last power tool on my wish list is now within reach, a Modern 11x22 metal lathe and I was just wondering if this is possible? I would like to thread boxes and such.
Thanks for any insight on this.
Best regards,
Wayne
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe
Wayne I haven't tried it. Normally on a metal lathe the cutting is done with a stationary cutter that travels with the screw feed. That would work with very hard woods I'm pretty sure. You could cut in the same fashion you would when cutting metal.
with soft woods I would think you would need to have a powered cutter. You could still use the screw feed but would probably have to rig up some sort of contraption to hold a device that would power the cutter. An air die grinder would probably work as well as a Foredom with a flex shaft. I don't know if you can find a cutter of the right size for a Dremel. It would be difficult for the other 2. Most cutters I've found have a 3/8" shank.
Ornamental lathes have a specially designed cutter but it's held in what looks like a metal lathe tool holder. I've looked at building such a device. If you look at the article on in American Woodturner on building a Rose Engine lathe he shows such a device. It's on my list of things I'll build if and when I ever get to retire.
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe
Dave Belser
Wayne - funny that this would come up. I've recently started using my metal lathe for cutting threads. Using a traditional metal tool (stationary point tool) gives pretty pour results in my limited experience. I attempted this with mahogany and it was a complete failure, even using super glue didn't help. I also tried osage orange it was mildly better.
For that particular project I ended up casting epoxy in a groove and then cutting threads in the epoxy. Epoxy works particularly well - it cuts quite nicely with a point tool.
What I ended up with is using a tool post grinder - a small motor with belt driven arbor that's meant to be used with grinding wheels on the lathe. I had the great fortune of visiting Fred Armbruster and learned a lot about how the OT guys do it. Fred ended up making a small tool holder that threads on the end of the tool post grinder. This holds an 1/8" dia carbide engraving cutter which has a 60 degree tip. The cutter spins at 20K rpm and the engraving cutter protrudes about 1/2" perpendicular to the axis. This essentially functions as a "cutting frame" in OT terms.
You could accomplish something similar with a rotary tool or laminate trimmer.
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe
Not to highjack this thread - but I had a question about Fred's tenon size calculation. The diagram and formula show the threads as full (come to a point at the tips) threads. It's my understanding that you usually truncate the peaks by 1/8 of the thread depth.
I would expect that this is especially important with wood threads because the wood grain makes the tips quite easy to break. Am I missing something?
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe
Dave I've done it both ways with the threading machine and so far I don't see a difference. On soft woods the tips can get broken. Leaving them short means that you have less room for wood movement problems. However on a 16TPI thread your only talking about .010" which isn't very much. If you follow the instructions on my 16TPI threader it calls for .035". This leaves a pointy thread. When fitting the second part I go for a good "feel" which might be anywhere from .020" to the full .035". This may leave that tooth slightly flat on top.
These aren't metal lathes. There are some inaccuracies because of the fit of all the parts and whether you use a chuck or faceplate and how long the box is. Because of that you may get a thread that is pointy on one side and slightly flat 180 degrees on the other side. I took the threader back to Vic to check it and it's with .0003" of being dead on so it's something to do with my chucks, faceplates or lathe itself. It's not a serious problem I just want to know where it exists so I'm taking the whole lathe over to bestwoodtools one of these days and Vic and I are going to seriously go over it and see where the problem is. I know it's just being picky but that's me.
When hand chasing(which I'm still new at) I try for a good fit. This might mean that the second set of threads will be either way depending upon my skills at both measuring, cutting the opening and then chasing. Right now I'm happy when they fit. Later on I'm sure I'll concentrate more on the appearance.
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe
I guess I will use the new lathe to refurbish an old Simpson jewellers lathe and work on converting it to cut threads using a rotary cutter setup. Lots of experimenting to do.
Wayne
Re: John Lucas et al-threading wood on metal lathe