Re: OT: A personal experience--long
Dinyar Chavda
I came to the US in 1973, after the Vietnam War had ended. While I met many vets where I went to school and in my subsequent career, by definition, I never knew anyone who had died in Vietnam.
So, on a visit to Washington after the Vietnam Memorial was built, my wife and I went to see it. I expected it to be just another sight�really wasn�t sure what to expect, given the press reports and controversy about just a slab of black marble with names.
I was totally unprepared for my reaction when I saw the name after name after name of young men and women who had been killed. Whatever your feelings about the war, you could not help but be moved to tears by the senseless waste of the tragic loss of so many lives cut short when they had barely started. Plus, in those early days of the memorial, there were many vets and their families, as well as families of the victims touching the names and grieving.
The second time I went there was much later. One of my very close friends in LA had volunteered into the Marines. In his words, 128 young men boarded a plane at Dover AFB, 3 eventually came back, of whom, 2 died shortly after their return, leaving my friend as the sole survivor�a heavy burden. He had never been to the Memorial, and a few years ago, he asked me if I�d be willing to accompany him to it��It was time�, he said. I was honored to be asked, and so, he flew in to Philly, and we took the train to Washington. As we got closer to Washington, I could detect a change in him. And when we walked from Union Station to the Memorial, his breathing changed, and, for the first time in all the years that I had known him, he looked nervous. When we came to the Memorial, I took his bag, and told him to go on ahead, but that I would be nearby, watching him.
What happened next reminded me forcefully of the opening scene in �Saving Private Ryan� (where Ryan, as a grandfather with his family, visits a military graveyard in Normandy, and collapses at the thought of all the men who had died to save him, and asks his wife to reassure him that he has lived a good life). My friend walked over to the name of someone who had been close to him, and squatted, just like he had done all those years ago in Vietnam. He rocked back and forth, moved over to another name, and repeated this several times. Eventually he got up, and looked for me, and we embraced, and then walked over to the Lincoln Memorial nearby, which is such a peaceful and wonderful antidote. We walked inside and around it, reading the wonderful words, and then sat on the steps, enjoying the view. After a while, he wanted to go back, and this time, he walked by the names, stopping every so often, and nodding. Finally, he was done, and we walked back to Union Station, and took the train home. He slept on the way back.
Later, he told me that he had felt like a giant load had been lifted off his shoulders, and that he had finally closed that chapter. I have neither the ability nor the experience to understand that, but I accept what he says, and consider myself fortunate to have had the opportunity to help someone who, given what he�s been through both during and after Vietnam, has made more than the ultimate sacrifice for his country.